WOW, I have a pretty decent sized list! Here goes:
1. Mama Melrose (I'm way too picky about Italian food)
2. Tony's Town Square (same as #1)
3. Rainforest Cafe (ate at one in Niagara Falls and it was just OK)
4. Planet Hollywood (do I have to explain this one?)
5. Nine Dragons (we eat Chinese all the time at home and in NY we have excellent Chinese food so I don't feel like I am missing out)
6. Teppan Edo and Tokyo Dining (we also eat Japanese food often, both excellent sushi and excellent hibachi, at home, so don't feel like we are missing out)
7. Trail's End Buffet (if I'm going all the way to Ft. Wilderness, it would be either for HDDR or a campfire, nothing else)
8. ABC Commissary (just heard such horrible things about it)
9. Plaza Restaurant (it's just nothing special)
10. Casey's Corner (the only hot dogs I eat are either Nathan's, Hebrew National or straight from a NYC Kosher deli)
11. Liberty Tree Tavern dinner (no more characters so not worth the price to me)
12. Shutters at Old Port Royale (the menu just doesn't appeal to me...but I am open if they change the menu)
13. McDonald's!! (do I need to explain?)
I have a few "maybe's" as well (I guess Shutters could be considered a "maybe" based on my above comment...see #12). Here is the "maybe" list:
1. Rose & Crown (I could get fish & chips at the CS location but I may still try this place at some point)
2. Le Cellier (don't flame me please!! DH may want to go here, it's not a must-do for me, but I am not going to bend over backwards for an ADR either!)
3. Bistro de Paris (DH and I talk about doing a fancy dinner when both kids are both old enough to go to the kids' club at Beach Club Resort, and this is a consideration, although we lean more towards V&A, or Yachtsman Steakhouse if we don't want to spend quite as much as V&A costs!)
4. Raglan Road (I hear good things about it, so maybe if we could fit it into one of our trips)
5. Kouzzina dinner (I love Greek food, but a lot of their menu items have fennel which I literally come close to gagging on if I put it in my mouth or if there is any trace if it...maybe if I was ordering just a couple of appetizers)
6. Tutto Italia (it's off our list for the next trip, but we may still want to try it in the future. It's the only Italian restaurant I would ever even consider at WDW...see #1 & #2 of my "never" list)
7. Sci-Fi (too many negative reviews about the food at this point, but in the future when my boys are older, they might enjoy the atmosphere so maybe one time for lunch)
And, to add to this already long post, I will add restaurants I definitely want to try at some point:
1. Narcoossee's
2. Yachtsman Steakhouse
3. Kona Cafe breakfast and dinner
4. 1900 Park Fare breakfast
5. Marrakesh
6. San Angel Inn
7. Liberty Tree Tavern lunch
8. California Grill
9. Beaches & Cream
10. Fulton's Crab House
11. House of Blues
12. Flying Fish
13. The Wave
14. Garden Grove character breakfast
15. Boatwright's
16. V&A
My selections are in no particular order, in any of the lists!!