I think most people would agree, it wasn't the hat itself (which IMO was done MUCH more tastefully than the crappy wand over Spaceship Earth), it was the location, which destroyed a great view of what people consider to be "classic hollywood".
If they had the hat nearly anywhere else in the park, it would have been ok with most people I think.
Yes it is, but that doesn't mean people don't prefer it over MSEP. That was always a topic of discussion even after it went away. Just like when the hat goes away there will be discussions from people wishing it was still there.
I'll join the Spectromagic fan club here. Thought it was heads-and-shoulders above MSEP from an overall entertainment standpoint. Seemed to be a lot more character interaction with Spectromagic (in terms of their "talking" from the floats, etc.). Or maybe it's just because the MSEP song never...ever...changes...and, like "It's a Small World", it won't get out of my head once I've heard it again! (My apologies to those of you who are now singing either one.)