Rate the Restaurants You've Been to

[MickeyNicki]

Kona breakfast - 5 stars
Kona lunch - 5 stars
Kona dinner - 2 stars

Grand Floridian breakfast - 5 stars
Grand Floridian dinner - 5 stars
1900 Park Faire breakfast -
1900 Park Faire dinner -
Citricos - 5 stars

Whispering Canyon lunch -
Chef Mickeys breakfast - 5 stars
Chef Mickeys dinner -
The Wave dinner - 5 stars
California Grill - 5 stars

Tonys Town Square lunch - 3 stars
Tonys Town Square dinner - 3 stars
The Plaza dinner - 4 stars
Crystal Palace breakfast - 5 stars
Crystal Palace dinner - 2 stars

BlueZoo - 5 stars
Il Mulino - 5 stars
ESPN - 3 stars
Flying Fish - 5 stars
Yachstman - 2 stars
Cape May breakfast - 4 stars
Cape May dinner - 4 stars

Boma breakfast - 5 stars
Boma dinner -
Jiko - 2 stars
Pepper Market breakfast - 2 stars
Pepper Market dinner - 2 stars

Fultons - 5 stars
Rainforest Cafe - 2 stars
House of Blues - 3 stars
Planet Hollywood - 2 stars
Raglan Road -

50's Prime Time - 4 stars
Sci Fi lunch - 3 stars
Hollywood & Vine dinner -
Mama Melrose lunch - :3 stars
Mama Melrose dinner - 4 stars

Coral Reef dinner - 2 stars
Le Cellier lunch - 5 stars
Le Cellier dinner - 5 stars
Chefs de France lunch - 5 stars
Chefs de France dinner -
Teppan Edo lunch/dinner - 3 stars
Nine Dragons dinner -
Tutto Italia lunch/dinner - :5 stars
Beirgarten - 5 stars
San Angel lunch - 5 stars
Norway breakfast - 4 stars

 

[Metsoskil]

Great feedback! Now if only we had someone with enough time on their hands to do a running average for each place...

 

[DisneyGirlie]

Well, this is fun

Liberty Tree Tavern DINNER: 5 stars
Captain's Grille LUNCH: 2 Stars
Boatwright's BREAKFAST: 2 stars
Rose & Crown LUNCH: 3 stars
Jiko: 5 stars
'Ohana BREAKFAST: 5 stars
Whispering Canyons Cafe BREAKFAST: 3 stars
Grand Floridian Cafe LUNCH: 4 stars
San Angel Inn DINNER: 2 stars
Chefs de France LUNCH: 3 stars
Nine Dragons LUNCH: 3 Stars
Yak & Yeti LUNCH: 3 stars
Hollywood & Vine DINNER: 1 star
Mama Melrose LUNCH: 1 star
Tony's Town Square LUNCH: 4 stars
Chef Mickey's BREAKFAST: 3 stars
The Plaza LUNCH: 4 stars
Kona Cafe BREAKFAST: 2 stars
Rainforest Cafe: 3 stars
House of Blues: 3 Stars
T-Rex: 4 stars
Tokyo Dining DINNER: 5 stars
Sci Fi Dine In DINNER: 2 stars
Planet Hollywood: 1 star
Biergarten: 3 stars
1900 Park Fare BREAKFAST: 2 stars
Cape May Cafe BREAKFAST: 3 stars
Raglan Road DINNER: 3 stars

 

[disneyfav4ever]

Great feedback! Now if only we had someone with enough time on their hands to do a running average for each place...

I could try and start to put something together tonight. I can never sleep, and there's not really much to do at 4:00 AM.

 

[Smiling Cheshire Cat]

I think I'm going to stick with TS places that we have eaten at in the last year. I'm considering food, service, and character interaction when applicable:

Chef Mickey's dinner- 4 stars
Kona breakfast- 4 stars
Crystal Palace breakfast- 5 stars
Crystal Palace lunch- 4 stars
CRT breakfast- 4 stars
CRT lunch- 1 star
Tony's dinner- 3 stars
Garden Grill- 3 1/2 stars
Akershus breakfast- 4 stars
Chef de France dinner- 2 1/2 stars
Tutto's- 5 stars
Donald's Safari Breakfast- 3 stars
Yak and Yeti lunch- 4 1/2 stars
50's PTC lunch- 4 stars
Mama Melrose's dinner- 1 star

 

[Metsoskil]

I could try and start to put something together tonight. I can never sleep, and there's not really much to do at 4:00 AM.

Wow! That would be great! What an amazing resource this thread could turn into.

 

[mom2taylorandemily]

Oh, this should be fun!! Here goes:

CRT Breakfast - 4 1/2 Stars
Ohana Breakfast - 5 Stars
Ohana Dinner - Used to be 5 stars, but they slipped last time 3 1/2 stars
Tusker House Breakfast - 3 1/2 stars
Hollywood & Vine Dinner (Fantasmic pkg.) - 2 stars
50's Prime Time Dinner - 5 Stars
Sci-Fi Drive Inn Lunch - 4 stars
Cape May Dinner - 5 Stars
Beaches & Cream Dinner - 4 Stars
Le Cellier Dinner - 5 + stars
Biergarden Dinner - 5 stars
Askershus Breakfast - 4 stars
Askershus Lunch - 3 stars
Teppan Edo Dinner - 5 + stars
Tutto Italia Dinner - 5 + stars
1900 Park Faire Breakfast - 3 stars
1900 Park Faire Dinner - 3 stars
Chef Mickey Breakfast 3 stars
Chef Mickey Dinner - 3 stars
Crystal Palace Breakfast - 3 stars
Crystal Palace Dinner - 4 stars
LTT Lunch - 3 1/2 stars
LTT Dinner - 5 stars
Tony's Town Square - 3 stars
WCC Breakfast - 3 1/2 stars
WCC Dinner - 3 stars
Shutters - 2 stars
Kona - 5 + stars
Nine Dragons - 1 star

I think that's all, if I think of any others I'll add them.

 

[MissBritt]

Okay, 1-5 for an overall rating, but using #s as they are easier than counting astericks/stars...

Cosmic Rays 3.5
Pinnochios 3
RFC in DTD 3
50s Prime Time 3.5
Sci Fi 3.5
Riverside Mill 4
Yak & Yeti 4.5
Tusker House 2.5
Sassagoula Floatworks 3
Restaurant Marrakesh 2
Chefs de France 2.5
Main Street Bakery 4.5
The Plaza 4.5

 

[dvcdisney]

These ratings are based solely on the food and are dinner meals unless otherwise stated. Currently, for us:

5 stars:
Teppan Edo
Ohana
Le Cellier

4 stars:
Yak and Yeti
Nine Dragons
The Wave
Cape May Cafe
T-Rex
Boma
Whispering Canyon Cafe
Mama Melrose
Chef de France
Kona Cafe
Maya Grill
Captain's Grille


3 stars:
Cinderella's Royal Table
Akershus - Breakfast
Akershus - Dinner
Chef Mickey
Rainforest Cafe
Hollywood and Vine
Coral Reef
Tony's Town Square
Captain's Grille Breakfast
Beaches n Cream
Grand Floridian Cafe
Turf Club Bar (SSR)
Wolfgang Puck Cafe

2 stars:
1900 Park Fare
Garden Grill
Tusker House
50's Prime Time Cafe
Sci Fi Diner
Plaza Restaurant

1 star:
Planet Hollywood

I believe that's it. I only rated TS restaurants. However, I think most CS fits between 1 and 2 stars. Again, this is based on food. We continually go to Akershus for the character interaction even if we don't like the food.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

So I've started a master list of all the ratings averaged out, and wanted to post a bit in case anyone had any suggestions on how to make it better.

Here's what I've done so far, using the first four posts and Magic Kingdom restaurants as an example.

Magic Kingdom

Cinderella's Royal Table - Breakfast 4 (Out of 1 rating)
Crystal Palace - Breakfast 3-½ (Out of 3 ratings)
Crystal Palace - Lunch & Dinner 3 (Out of 2 ratings)
Liberty Tree Tavern - Lunch 3-½ (Out of 2 ratings)
Plaza - Lunch & Dinner 4 (Out of 3 ratings)
Tony's Town Square - Lunch 3 (Out of 2 ratings)

I made breakfast it’s own category, but combined all the lunch and dinner scores, since some of them weren’t separated, and I don’t see huge differences between lunch and dinner like I do breakfasts anyway. They’re organized by park, then Downtown Disney restaurants, and then resorts which are in alphabetical order. Also, if anything wasn’t specified breakfast, lunch, or dinner, I assumed it was a lunch or dinner rating. Also, for anything that averaged to an odd number, like 3.33 or 2.66 I rounded up to the next half or whole star point.

I have the first four posts copied and pasted and organzied by park, but I'm going to add more ratings before I average them all, just wanted to post the first couple MK restaurants (not including CS yet, I'll get around to it though,) as an example in case anyone had any suggestions to improve.

 

[Metsoskil]

So I've started a master list of all the ratings averaged out, and wanted to post a bit in case anyone had any suggestions on how to make it better.

Here's what I've done so far, using the first four posts and Magic Kingdom restaurants as an example.

Magic Kingdom

Cinderella's Royal Table - Breakfast 4 (Out of 1 rating)
Crystal Palace - Breakfast 3-½ (Out of 3 ratings)
Crystal Palace - Lunch & Dinner 3 (Out of 2 ratings)
Liberty Tree Tavern - Lunch 3-½ (Out of 2 ratings)
Plaza - Lunch & Dinner 4 (Out of 3 ratings)
Tony's Town Square - Lunch 3 (Out of 2 ratings)

I made breakfast it’s own category, but combined all the lunch and dinner scores, since some of them weren’t separated, and I don’t see huge differences between lunch and dinner like I do breakfasts anyway. They’re organized by park, then Downtown Disney restaurants, and then resorts which are in alphabetical order. Also, if anything wasn’t specified breakfast, lunch, or dinner, I assumed it was a lunch or dinner rating. Also, for anything that averaged to an odd number, like 3.33 or 2.66 I rounded up to the next half or whole star point.

I have the first four posts copied and pasted and organzied by park, but I'm going to add more ratings before I average them all, just wanted to post the first couple MK restaurants (not including CS yet, I'll get around to it though,) as an example in case anyone had any suggestions to improve.

I think that looks fantastic! Thanks for taking the time to do this.

 

[Twende]

Thanks for organizing this!

I am wondering if we should explain any of our ratings?

For example I enjoy the variety of food choices for a large group when we go to Sunshine Seasons in the Land in EPCOT. There is always something for everyone but the seating in that place put me over the edge. We normally have at least one person in a wheel chair and another in a scooter and neither fit between the chairs. It makes getting to a table a real chore!


I agree with whomever said that "Ohana was not as good recently as it has been in the past. It was a combination of the changes in menu with a very poor server. The server can really make or break a meal there.

We had a horrid experience with Brown Derby one time. The server was beyond poor and the food was poorly prepared. One half chicken dish was literally raw and oozing with bloody juices. Yes, I sent a written complaint on that experience!

We also had trouble at Marrakesh in Morocco in EPCOT. It was not so much the food as it was the manager. We had misinformation on the Candle Light Processional Package and that made for a huge argument during our dinner. I had to repeatedly get up from our table since I did not want to discuss the problem in front of the entire family and the other diners. The server was no help at all and the manager was just plain rude to me. I think part of it was a cultural thing as he did not a woman explaining the problem and possible solutions to him. It took the entire meal to just get someone to understand and even then after our meal, I had to go see the director of the CP to get things fixed. I doubt I will ever got back into Marrakesh because of all the poor customer service I was given!

 

[mickeysgirl17]

Chef Mickeys dinner - 3
Garden Grill lunch- 2
Coral Reef dinner- 4 and 1/2
1900 Park fare dinner- 3
mama melrose dinner- 3
Ohana dinner- 5
Cinderella's royal table dinner- 4
Crystal palace dinner- 2 and 1/2

 

[chanty]

4 stars:
Cape May Cafe
Boulangerie Patisserie (France) (CS)
Chef Mickey
Beaches n Cream
Tutto Italia

3 stars:
Sci Fi Diner
Cinderella's Royal Table
Rainforest Cafe
Casey's Corner (CS)
Pecos Bill (CS)
Boardwalk Pizza Window (CS)
ESPN Club
Spirit of Aloha (dinner & show)
Boatwright's riverside

2 stars:
Whispering Canyon Cafe
Restaurant Marrakesh
Liberty Inn (CS)
Hurricane Hannah's Grill (CS)
Big River Grille and Brewing Works

1 star:
Planet Hollywood
Mama Melrose
Toy Story Pizza Planet (CS)

 

[goldielocksraj]

Sci-Fi had outstanding service and just okay food.



I couldn't agree more about Sci-Fi service! Sis & I went New Year's lunch 2009, and we split a cheeseburger. I expected them to bring it on one plate like it was just for one person; if we were lucky, they would bring a second plate. Well, they went way above that-the cheeseburger was cut EXACTLY in half and placed on two seperate plates; an equal amount of fries and toppings were on each plate. I didn't expect Disney to be so accomidating to diners saving $$! I was sure to leave a generous tip.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

MMRI ***1/2

What's MMRI stand for?

 

[disneyfav4ever]

This is the averaged ratings of the theme park table service restaurant from page one of this thread. I have all the ratings from the resort table restaurants copied and pasted into a word document, I just have to average them all out. It's easy, just time consuming.

All breakfasts are averaged seperatly, but lunch and dinner scores are combined, except for LTT and CRT, since lunch and dinner are different experiences at those restaurants.

I'll try and get some of the resorts up tonight. That actually shouldn't take as long since there are less restaurants at the resorts then in the parks, and now I have a system for doing this figured out. Then I'll start in on page two for the ratings.

Magic Kingdom

Cinderella's Royal Table - Breakfast 3-½ (Out of 5 Ratings)
Cinderella’s Royal Table Lunch - 4 (Out of 1 Rating)
Cinderella’s Royal Table - Dinner 3-½ (Out of 4 Ratings)
Liberty Tree Tavern - Lunch 4 (Out of 4 ratings)
Liberty Tree Tavern - Dinner 3 (Out of 4 Ratings)
Plaza - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 7 ratings)
Crystal Palace - Breakfast 4 (Out of 8 ratings)
Crystal Palace - Lunch/Dinner 3.5 (Out of 7 ratings)
Tony's Town Square - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 7 ratings)

Epcot

Akershus - Breakfast 3-½ (Out of 4 Ratings)
Akershus Lunch/Dinner - 2 (Out of 3 Ratings)
Biergarten - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 8 Ratings)
Bistro de Paris - 4-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
Chefs de France - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 11 Ratings)
Coral Reef - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 9 Ratings)
Garden Grill - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 7 Ratings)
Le Cellier - Lunch/Dinner 4 (Out of 8 Ratings)
Marrakesh - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 6 Ratings)
Nine Dragons - Lunch/Dinner 2-½ (Out of 1 Rating)
Rose and Crown - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 8 Ratings)
San Angel Inn - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 10 Ratings)
Teppan Edo - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 3 Ratings)
Tokyo Dining - Lunch/Dinner 4 (Out of 5 Ratings)
Tutto Italia - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 6 Ratings)

MGM-Studios

50's Prime Time - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 11 Ratings)
Brown Derby - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 8 Ratings)
Mama Melrose’s Lunch/Dinner - 3-½ (Out of 7 Ratings)
Hollywood & Vine Breakfast - 2-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
Hollywood & Vine Lunch/Dinner - 2 (Out of 5 Ratings)
Sci-Fi Dine In - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 10 Ratings)

Animal Kingdom

Rainforest Cafe (DTD) - Lunch/Dinner 2 (Out of 7 Ratings)
Tusker House Breakfast - 3 (Out 6 of Ratings)
Tusker House - Lunch/Dinner 3-½ (Out of 5 Ratings)
Yak and Yeti - Lunch/Dinner 3 (Out of 9 Ratings)

 

[Metsoskil]

disneyfav4ever,

You are the best.

sincerely,
metsoskil

 

[Metsoskil]

What's MMRI stand for?

I'm assuming Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano.

 

[disneyfav4ever]

I'm assuming Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano.

You're probably right! I always forget about the Ristorante Italiano part, so the RI threw me off.