Rate the Restaurants You've Been to

[shannn]

Ohana (dinner) 2 1/2
Liberty Tree Tavern (Dinner) 2
Hollywood & Vine (dinner) 1 1/2
Cinderella's Royal Table(Lunch) 3
Kona (Lunch) 3
Fulton's Crab House(dinner) 3 1/2
Brown Derby(dinner) 3 1/2
50's Prime Time(lunch) 2 1/2
Akershus (lunch) 3
Le Cellier (dinner) 4
Narcoosee's (dinner) 4
Chef Mickey's (breakfast) 3
California Grill (dinner) 4 1/2 (OUT OF 4)
Yachtsman (dinner) 3
Grand Floridian Cafe (lunch) 3

 

[disneyfav4ever]

Downtown Disney

Captain Jack’s - 4 (Out of 1 Rating)
Fulton’s 4-½ (Out of 2 Raitings)
House of Blues - 2-½ (Out of 3 Ratings)
Paradiso 37 - 4-½ (Out of 1 Rating)
Planet Hollywood 3-½ (Out of 3 Ratings)
Portobello dinner: 3 (Out of 3 Ratings)
Raglan Road - 3-½ (Out of 4 Ratings)
T-Rex 3-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
Wolfgang Puck Cafe Lunch/Dinner - 3 (Out of 6 Ratings)
Wolfgang Puck Dining Room - 4 (Out of 1 Review)

Animal Kingdom Lodge

Boma - Breakfast 4 (Out of 7 Ratings)
Boma - Dinner 3-½ (Out of 9 Ratings)
Jiko - 3-½ (Out of 9 Ratings)
Sanaa - Dinner 4-½ (Out of 3 Ratings)

Beach Club

Beaches & Cream - 3-½ (Out of 3 Ratings)
Cape May Café - Breakfast 3 (Out of 6 Ratings)
Cape May Cafe - Dinner 3 (Out of 5 Ratings)

Boardwalk

Big River Grille - 2-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
ESPN Club - 2-½ (Out of 4 Ratings)
Flying Fish - 4-½ (Out of 6 Ratings)
Kouzzina Breakfast - 4 (Out of 1 Ratings)
Kouzzina Dinner - 3 (Out of 2 Ratings)

Contemporary

California Grill - 4 (Out of 8 Ratings)
Chef Mickey's - Breakfast 3 (Out of 6 Ratings)
Chef Mickey’s - Dinner 3 (Out of 4 Ratings)
The Wave 4 (Out of 4 Ratings)

Coronado Springs

Maya Grill - 0 (Out of 1 Ratings)

Fort Wilderness

Mickey’s Backyard BBQ - 1 (Out of 2 Ratings)
Hoop Dee Do - 4 (Out of 1 Ratings)

Grand Floridian

1900 Park Fare Breakfast - 3 (Out of 5 Ratings)
1900 Park Fare Dinner - 3-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
Citricos - 4 (Out of 3 Ratings)
Garden View Lounge Tea 4 (Out of 3 Ratings)
Grand Floridian Café Breakfast - 3 (Out of 1 Ratings)
Grand Floridian Café - 3 (Out of 4 Ratings)
Narcoossees 3-½ (Out of 4 Ratings)
Perfectly Princess Tea Party - 4-½ (Out of 1 Ratings)
Victoria & Albert’s 5 (Out of 4 Ratings)

Old Key West

Olivia’s Café - 3 (Out of 2 Ratings)

Polynesian

Kona Café - Breakfast 4 (Out of 5 Ratings)
Kona Cafe - Dinner 3-½ (Out of 8 Ratings)
Kona Sushi Bar - 3-½ (Out of 1 Ratings)
Ohana - Breakfast 3-½ (Out of 5 Ratings)
Ohana - Dinner 4 (Out of 5 Ratings)

Port Orleans

Boatwright’s - 1 (Out of 1 Ratings)

Saratoga Springs

Turf Club - 3-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)

Swan & Dolphin

Blue Zoo - 4-½ (Out of 3 Ratings)
Il Mulino - 4-½ (Out of 1 Ratings)

Wilderness Lodge

Artist Point 4 (Out of 5 Ratings)
Whispering Canyon Café Breakfast - 4 (Out of 1 Ratings)
Whispering Canyon Cafe - Dinner 2 (Out of 6 Ratings)

Yacht Club

Captain’s Grille - 3-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
Yachtsman Steakhouse 4 (Out of 6 Ratings)

Extinct Restaurants

Alfredo’s - 2-½ (Out of 2 Ratings)
Boatwright’s Breakfast - 3 (Out of 1 Ratings)
Spoodles - Breakfast 4 (Out of 1 Ratings)

 

[Metsoskil]

Surprised to see The Wave up there with 4 stars. Gonna have to add that to the itinerary for the next trip.

 

[zhazhazsu]

*****= best - * = worst

Liberty Tree Tavern Breakfast ****1/2
Yak and Yet Lunch ***1/2
Saana lunch *****
Le Cellier ****
San Angel Inn ***1/2
Ohana **1/2
50's PTC ****

 

[Twende]

Table Services
.......

Resorts and Other:
..........

Wave 3 stars
California Grill 5 stars
Hoop Dee Doo Food - 3 1/2 stars Show 5 stars
1900 Park Fare - Food 3 stars Characters 4 stars
Boatwright's -POR Riverside 4 stars
River Roost - Food 3 stars Entertainment 4 stars
Raglan Road - Dinner 4 stars Entertainment 4 1/2 stars
...............

This is the averaged ratings of the theme park table service restaurant from page one of this thread. I have all the ratings from the resort table restaurants copied and pasted into a word document, I just have to average them all out. It's easy, just time consuming.
..........



Port Orleans

Boatwright’s - 1 (Out of 1 Ratings)

You have done a great job of organizing this results but I did catch a mistake on the scoring for Boatwights in POR Riverside.

 

[skier_pete]

This is great - I am rating restaurants based on our visits since 2006, I am weighing most heavily on the food, but skewed a bit for the overall experience (Sci-Fi gets *** for the food, and an extra one for the experience - but a great experience will not cancel out lousy food). Normally I would rate restaurants based on "value" as well, but as I consider them all overpriced, I have ignored the cost as a factor. (For instance, I would never pay the prices for the food at CRT if it wasn't in the castle.)

Overall, there is only one restaurant I've been to that I would never go back - Breakfast at Cape May Cafe, but I even gave that two stars. Three stars is would go back but not in a hurry. Four stars is consider it every trip. And 5 stars is Sign me up!

MK
Cinderella’s Royal Table Lunch - ****
Liberty Tree Tavern - Lunch ***
Crystal Palace - Breakfast ****
Crystal Palace - Lunch/Dinner ****

Epcot
Akershus Lunch/Dinner - ****
Biergarten - Lunch/Dinner ***
Chefs de France - Dinner *****
Coral Reef - Dinner ***
Le Cellier - Dinner *****
Marrakesh - Lunch/Dinner ****
San Angel Inn - Lunch/Dinner ***

MGM-Studios
Hollywood & Vine Lunch - Lunch *** (note you really should separate lunch and dinner, since lunch has characters and dinner does not - this is a case where the characters are the only reason I would go back)
Sci-Fi Dine In - Lunch/Dinner ****

Animal Kingdom

Tusker House - Lunch/Dinner ****

Resorts
Cape May Café - Breakfast **
California Grill - Dinner *****
Chef Mickey’s - Dinner ***
1900 Park Fare Dinner - ***
Whispering Canyon Cafe - Lunch ***

 

[koolaidmoms]

I'll give this a try:

MK

CRT - lunch ****
CRT - dinner ***1/2
CP - lunch/Dinner ****
LTT - Dinner ***1/2
Tony's Town Square Dinner ****

Epcot:
LeCellier Dinner*****
Marrakesh Dinner *****
Biergarten Dinner****
Nine Dragons Dinner***1/2
San Angel Inn Dinner****
Garden Grill Dinner ***1/2

DHS
H&V - Dinner **
'50's PT Dinner ****1/2
SciFi - Lunch ****

AK:
Tusker House Lunch/Dinner - ****

DTD:
Raglan Road - Dinner ****
Cap-N-Jack's Lunch ***1/2

Resorts:
1900 Park Fare - Breakfast ***1/2
Cape May Cafe - Dinner ****
Boma - Dinner ****

I think that's everything. I ate at more places than I thought and that doesn't include CS. Wow.

 

[MissBritt]

You have done a great job of organizing this results but I did catch a mistake on the scoring for Boatwights in POR Riverside.

The poster who was averaging only used the very first page of this thread for the results she has posted so far. There are a few more votes from almost all of the restaurants she listed, and more restaurants listed in the second to fourth pages.

 

[Pugmalion1]

Okay, here are my ratings in numerals 1-5, with quarter-points (I usually mentally rate things on a 1-10 scale with half-points, so this is my only way to do that and fit it in a 1-5 scale). Table Service only. Scores are in red.

ANIMAL KINGDOM

Rainforest Cafe - Breakfast 3.75
Yak and Yeti - Lunch 3.75

DISNEY'S HOLLYWOOD STUDIOS

'50s Prime Time Cafe - Lunch 3.00
Brown Derby - Lunch 4.25
Mama Melrose's - Dinner 3.00
Sci-Fi Dine-In - Lunch 3.50

EPCOT

Future World
Coral Reef - Lunch 5.00
Coral Reef - Dinner 5.00
Garden Grill - Lunch N/A (We had reservations, but when we got there, the fixed menu for the day looked pretty terrible. We decided to cancel.)

World Showcase
Bistro De Paris - Dinner 4.25
Chefs de France - Lunch 3.50
Le Cellier Steakhouse - Lunch 4.00
San Angel Inn - Dinner 4.00
Tutto Italia - Lunch 3.50

MAGIC KINGDOM

Liberty Tree Tavern - Lunch 3.75
Plaza Restaurant - Dinner 3.50
Tony's Town Square - Lunch 3.50

RESORTS

ANIMAL KINGDOM LODGE - JAMBO and KIDANI
Jiko (Jambo House) - Dinner 5.00
Sanaa (Kidani Village) - Dinner 4.50

BEACH CLUB
Beaches and Cream - Lunch 3.50

BOARDWALK
Big River Grille & Brewing Works - Lunch 4.00
Kouzzina - Breakfast 4.25
Kouzzina - Dinner 4.50

CONTEMPORARY
California Grill - Dinner 5.00
The Wave - Breakfast 2.00

DOLPHIN
The Fountain - Lunch 3.00
Shula's Steak House - Dinner 5.00

GRAND FLORIDIAN RESORT AND SPA
Grand Floridian Cafe - Lunch 4.50
Narcoossee's - Dinner 3.75

OLD KEY WEST
Olivia's Cafe - Breakfast 3.5

POLYNESIAN
Kona Cafe - Breakfast 3.75
Kona Cafe - Dinner 4.00

SWAN
Kimonos Sushi Bar - Dinner 4.00

WILDERNESS LODGE
Artist Point - Dinner 4.00

YACHT CLUB
Yachtsman Steakhouse - Dinner 4.25

DOWNTOWN DISNEY

Marketplace
Fulton's Crab House - Lunch 3.00
Rainforest Cafe - Breakfast 4.00

Pleasure Island
Paradiso 37 - Dinner 3.00
Portobello - Dinner 3.50
Raglan Road - Dinner 4.00

 

[disneyfav4ever]

You have done a great job of organizing this results but I did catch a mistake on the scoring for Boatwights in POR Riverside.

The poster who was averaging only used the very first page of this thread for the results she has posted so far. There are a few more votes from almost all of the restaurants she listed, and more restaurants listed in the second to fourth pages.

I was just coming to post the same thing.

I just started on page two of the results, and should have the new averaged results posted by the weekend depending on how quickly I get it done.

 

[Twende]

I was just coming to post the same thing.

I just started on page two of the results, and should have the new averaged results posted by the weekend depending on how quickly I get it done.

Sorry the mistake was mine. I did not read your post carefully enough!

Thanks for doing this!