Rate the Restaurants You've Been to

[Metsoskil]

*****UPDATE***** Please see page 3 for the current average ratings of DISers (Thanks to disneyfav4ever). If you have not already posted your ratings, please add them to the last page. It would be helpful if you categorized your restaurants by theme park and/or resort.



When looking through guide books, they often give simple number ratings or stars based on what readers have told them. I'm curious as to how DISers would rate the TS places they've been to. I'm rating mine on the whole experience, not just the food. List where you've eaten, and give anywhere from 0-5 stars.

Here's mine (in random order):
Cinderella's Royal Table - Breakfast ****
Liberty Tree Tavern - Lunch ***1/2
Plaza - Lunch & Dinner ***1/2
Crystal Palace - Breakfast **1/2
Crystal Palace - Lunch & Dinner ***
Tony's Town Square - Lunch **1/2
Coral Reef - Dinner ***1/2
Le Cellier - Dinner ****1/2
Rose and Crown - Lunch ***
Le Chefs de France - Lunch **1/2
Marrakesh - Dinner ***1/2
Biergarten - Dinner ****
Tokyo Dining - Dinner ****1/2
Tutto Italia - Lunch ****
Akershus - Breakfast ***
San Angel Inn - Lunch & Dinner ***1/2
50's Prime Time - Lunch ***1/2
Sci-Fi Dine In - Lunch *
Spoodles (now gone) - Breakfast ****
Cape May Cafe - Dinner *1/2
Yak and Yeti - Dinner ***1/2
Tusker House - Lunch ****
Rainforest Cafe (DTD) - Lunch *
Kona Cafe - Dinner ****
'Ohana - Dinner ****
Chef Mickey's - Breakfast ***
Whispering Canyon Cafe - Dinner ****
Boma - Breakfast ***
Boma - Dinner ****
Sanaa - Dinner ****1/2
Garden View Lounge Tea ****

 

[KatMark]

LeCellier -- Lunch & Dinner *****
Crystal Palace -- Breakfast ****1/2
Boma -- Breakfast ****1/2
Fulton's -- Dinner *****
Sci Fi -- Lunch ****
50's Prime Time -- Lunch ***1/2
Mama Melrose -- Dinner ****
Hollywood & Vine -- Dinner NO STARS
Boatwright's -- Dinner *
Tony's Town Square -- Lunch & Dinner ***1/2
Plaza -- Lunch & Dinner ****1/2
Rose & Crown -- Lunch & Dinner ****
Biergarten -- Lunch & Dinner *****
Garden Grill -- Dinner **
Coral Reef -- Lunch ***
Akershus -- Lunch **
Yak & Yeti -- Lunch ****
Liberty Tree Tavern -- Lunch ***1/2
Whispering Canyon Cafe -- Dinner -- NO STARS
Cape May Cafe -- Breakfast ****
Cape May Cafe -- Dinner ***1/2
Chef Mickey's -- Breakfast ***1/2
Chef Mickey's -- Dinner **
Brown Derby -- Lunch **

 

[Leanne1977]

Heres mine.

Rainforest Cafe DTD dinner: *1/2
T-Rex lunch: ***1/2
Raglan Road dinner: ***
House of Blues dinner: ****
Wolfgang Puck Cafe dinner: ***1/2
Portobello dinner: ***
Donalds Safari Breakfast: ***
Hollywood and Vine lunch: **1/2
Hollywood and Vine dinner: *1/2
Mama Melrose FDP: ***1/2
Sci-Fi lunch: ***1/2
Coral Reef lunch: ***
Garden Grill dinner: ****1/2
Chefs De France dinner: *
Le Cellier dinner: ****
Rose and Crown dinner: ***
Crystal Palace breakfast: ***1/2
Crystal Palace lunch: ***
Plaza lunch: ***1/2
Boma breakfast: ***
Jiko: *****
Sanaa dinner: ****
Cape May Cafe breakfast: ***1/2
ESPN Club dinner: **1/2
Chef Mickeys breakfast: ***
Chef Mickeys dinner: ***1/2
California Grill: *****
Maya Grill: NO STARS
Mickeys Backyard BBQ: *
1900 Park Fare breakfast held in Grand Floridian Cafe during refurb: ***1/2
Kona dinner: ***1/2
'Ohana breakfast: ****
'Ohana dinner: ****
Turf Club dinner: ****1/2
Whispering Canyon Cafe dinner: **1/2
Yachtsmans Steakhouse: ****1/2

 

[Pygoplites]

I usually use a 4-star system, like many newspapers (where one star is still "good"), but here's my take on a 5-star ranking (where 1 star is poor and 5 is excellent):

Victoria & Albert's *****

Flying Fish Cafe ****1/2
Jiko ****1/2

California Grill ****
Fulton's Crab House ****

Narcoossee's ***1/2
Tokyo Dining ***1/2
Hollywood Brown Derby ***1/2
Artist's Point ***1/2
Citrico's ***1/2
Boma (breakfast)***1/2
Tutto Italia ***1/2

Grand Floridian Cafe (breakfast) ***
Yachtsman's Steakhouse ***
Yak & Yeti ***
Tusker House ***
Kona Cafe ***

Les Chefs de France **1/2

Wolfgang Puck Cafe **
Cape May Cafe (breakfast)**
Columbia Harbor House **

Liberty Inn *1/2
San Angel Inn *1/2

Hollywood & Vine (breakfast) *
Contempo Cafe *

 

[TinkerBelle_325]

Counting table service only

RESORTS
Kona Cafe
- Breakfast - 3 1/2 stars
- Lunch - 3 stars
- Dinner - 4 stars
Ohana - 3 1/2 stars
California Grill - 4 1/2 stars
The Wave
- Dinner - 3 1/2 stars
Yachtsman Steakhouse - 3 stars
Flying Fish - 4 1/2 stars
ESPN Club
- Lunch - 3 stars
Jiko - 4 1/2 stars
Victoria & Albert's - 5 stars+
Gardenview Tea Room - 3 1/2 stars
Artist Point - 4 stars
Whispering Canyon Cafe
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars

MK
Liberty Tree Tavern
- Lunch - 4 stars
- Dinner - 3 stars
Crystal Palace
- Breakfast - 3 stars
Tony's Town Square
- Dinner - 2 stars
Cinderella's Royal Table
- Breakfast - 3 stars

EPCOT
Le Cellier
- Lunch - 4 stars
- Dinner - 4 stars
Rose & Crown
- Lunch - 2 1/2 stars
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars
Chefs de France
- Lunch - 4 stars
- Dinner - 4 stars
Tokyo Dining
- Dinner - 4 stars
Biergarten
- Lunch - 2 1/2 stars
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars
San Angel Inn
- Lunch - 3 stars
Coral Reef
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars
Garden Grill
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars

DHS
50's Primetime Cafe
- Lunch - 3 stars
Hollywood Brown Derby
- Dinner - 3 1/2 stars

DTD
Wolfgang Puck Cafe
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars
House of Blues
- Dinner - 2 stars
Planet Hollywood
- Dinner - 2 1/2 stars
Portabello Yacht Club
- Dinner - 3 stars
Rainforest Cafe
- Lunch 2 1/2 stars

 

[msp2mco]

Tony's Town Square - Lunch ***
Le Cellier - Dinner *****
Le Chefs de France - Lunch ****
Marrakesh - Dinner ***
Biergarten - Dinner ****
Tutto Italia - Dinner **
Akershus - Breakfast ***
San Angel Inn - Dinner ***
50's Prime Time - Lunch ****
Sci-Fi Dine In - Dinner**
Yak and Yeti - Dinner **
Tusker House - Lunch ****
'Ohana - Dinner ****
Boma - Dinner ***
Jiko *****
Flying Fish *****
California Grill ***
Garden Grill ***
Brown Derby ****

 

[Pakey]

*****5 Stars
Victoria & Alberts

****1/2-4 1/2 Stars
Bistro de Paris
bluezoo
Il Mulino
Flying Fish

****-4 Stars
Jiko
Citricos
Wolfgang Pucks The Dining Room

***1/2-3 1/2 Stars
Hollywood Brown Derby
Ca Grill
Artist Point
Yachtsman Steakhouse

***-3 Stars
Narcoosees
Boma
Tusker House
Marrakesh
Portabello Yacht Club

**1/2-2 1/2 Stars
Chefs de France
Biergarten
Le Cellier
Turf Club
Olivia's
Cape May Cafe
Coral Reef
50's Prime Time Cafe
Teppen Edo
Ragland Road

**-2 Stars
Liberty Tree Tavern
Crystal Palace
Cinderella's Royal Table
Wolfgang Puck's Cafe
Tutto Italia
Rose & Crown
House of Blues
Grand Floridian Cafe
Garden Grill

*1/2-1 1/2 Stars
Sci Fi Dine In
Big River Grille
Rainforest Cafe

*-1 Star
Yak n Yeti
Planet Hollywood

No Stars
San Angel Inn
Whispering Canyon Cafe

 

[tiredsigh]

For character meals, I also did a separate rating for character interaction. For families like mine that go to eat at many places just for the characters, it helps push a so-so place to a must do again.

Donalds Safari Breakfast: *** for food, ****1/2 for characters
Crystal Palace breakfast: ***1/2 for food, **** for characters
Crystal Palace lunch: *** for food, **** for characters
Plaza lunch: **1/2
Cape May Cafe breakfast: ***1/2 for food, ***** for characters
Chef Mickeys dinner: *** for food, **** for characters
1900 Park Fare dinner: ***1/2 for food, ***** for characters
'Ohana breakfast: *** for food, **** for characters
Cinderella's Royal Table breakfast: *** for food, ****1/2 for characters
Pepper Market: * (I know it is a CS place, but you do have a waiter/waitress)
Yak and Yeti lunch: ****1/2
Brown Derby: ***
Teppan Edo: ****

 

[Sazzo'sMommy]

Here are ours:
DH - 45, Me - 41, DD - 20, and DD 7

*****
Victoria & Alberts
Wolfgang Puck Signature Dinner during Food and Wine Festival
4th of July Party at California Grill

**** 1/2
Todd English's bluezoo
My Disney Girl Perfectly Princess Tea

****
Yachtsman Steakhouse
Flying Fish
Bistro de Paris
Narcoossees
Tutto Italia
CRT (dinner 3rd of July watching fireworks from inside castle!)
Artist Pointe
JIKO
CRT Breakfast
Tokyo Dining Sushi during Illuminations
Coral Reef
Hoop de Doo
Garden View Lounge Afternoon Tea

***1/2
Princess Storybook Breakfast - 1st seating
Crystal Palace Breakfast - 1st seating
Hollywood and Vine Breakfast - 1st seating
Donald's Safari Breakfast - 1st Seating
Chef Mickey's Breakfast
Boma
Teppan Edo
Big River Grille and Brewing Works
ESPN
Beaches and Cream
Chef's de France Lunch
Sci-Fi (lunch)
Brown Derby
Mama Melrose's
Cape May Cafe Breakfast & Dinner
The Wave
Kona Island Sushi Bar
O'Hana Character Breakfast
1900 Park Faire Breakfast
Grand Floridian Cafe
Captain's Grille
T-Rex
Biergarten

***
California Grill
Whispering Canyon Cafe
Tony's Town Square
The Plaza
San Angel Inn
Garden Grill
50's Prime Time

**1/2
Yak & Yeti
Restaurant Marrakesh
Chef's de France dinner
Sci-Fi dinner
50's Prime Time dinner
1900 Park Faire Dinner

*
Mickey's Backyard Barbeque
Princess Storybook Dinner

 

[goldielocksraj]

I don't have many TS meals under my belt (yet!), but the ones I've had:

Alfredo's, dinner (now gone, I know): 3 1/2

Plaza-lunch : 3

Sci-Fi, lunch : 4 1/2

Mama Melrose's, dinner : 4

50's Prime-Time, lunch : 4 1/2

Paradiso 37, lunch : 4 1/2

Happy eating all!!!

 

[Hal Gurtner]

Random order:

Boma, breakfast - ****½
Boma, dinner - *****
Jiko - *****('05), ****('08)
Yachtsman - *****
Coral Reef, dinner - ****
LeCellier, dinner - **½ ('02 & '05)
Rose and Crown, lunch - ***
Les Chefs de France, lunch - ***½
Biergarten, lunch - **½
Restaurant Marrakesh, lunch - ***
San Angel Inn, lunch - ***½
San Angel Inn, dinner - ****
Alfredo's (now closed), dinner - *½
Tusker House, breakfast buffet - *
'50s Prime Time Cafe, lunch - ½
Mama Melrose, dinner (Fantasmic package) - **
Crystal Palace, breakfast - ****½
Kona Cafe, breakfast - ****
Kona Cafe, dinner - ***½
Raglan Road, lunch - *****
Rainforest Cafe (AK), lunch - nil
Planet Hollywood, lunch - bupkis

 

[disneyfav4ever]

Mine are rated in order, (i.e. Yachtsman Steakhouse is almost a ***** and Crystal Palace is almost a ****) I based my ratings on service and atmosphere as well as food. Breakfast at Cape May Cafe is the only meal I would not do again, anything else I'd give at least one more try.

5 Star
California Grill *****
Citricos *****

4 1/2 Star
Yachtsman Steakhouse ****1/2
Wolfgang Puck Cafe ****1/2
Flying Fish ****1/2
Hollywood Brown Derby ****1/2
Blue Zoo ****1/2
Sanaa ****1/2
Crystal Palace ****1/2

4 Star
Boma ****
Narcoossees ****
Artist Point ****
Yak & Yeti ****
Grand Floridian Cafe ****
Tusker House (Breakfast Only) ****
Tutto Italia ****
The Wave ****
Kona ****
Akershus ****
Cinderella's Royal Table ****
Ohana ****

3 1/2 Star
Jiko ***1/2
Le Cellier ***1/2
Rose and Crown ***1/2
Raglan Road ***1/2
Kouzzina ***1/2
Tokyo Dining ***1/2
Hollywood and Vine ***1/2
Liberty Tree Tavern ***1/2
Mama Melrose's ***1/2
Rainforest Cafe ***1/2

3 Star
Coral Reef ***
San Angel Inn ***
Chefs de France ***
Plaza ***
50's Prime Time Cafe ***
Sci-Fi Dine In ***
Beaches and Cream ***
Tony's Town Square ***
Chef Mickey's ***

2 1/2 Star
Garden Grill **1/2
Nine Dragons **1/2
Marrakesh **1/2
1900 Park Fare **1/2

2 Star
Cape May Cafe (Breakfast Only) **

 

[marielynn724]

Tony's Lunch - ***
Wolfgang Puck Dinner - ****
Boma Dinner - ***1/2 (my opinion, I'm really picky and didn't have much that I liked - my family would probably all say *****)
Coral Reef Lunch - ****1/2
50s Prime Time Cafe Lunch - ***
Whispering Canyon Cafe Breakfast - ****
Cap'n Jacks - ****

every other meal was CS, all were descent.

we really honestly loved all of our food this last trip with the exception of Tony's and 50's Prime Time which were just OK.

 

[cannp123165]

Here's mine, out of 5 stars.

Kona Breakfast ****
Kona Dinner ***
Ohana Breakfast ***1/2
Boma Dinner ****
Boma Breakfast ****
Sci-Fi ****
Beaches and Cream ****1/2
ESPN Club ***1/2
Rainforest Cafe DTD ***
Crystal Palace Dinner ***1/2
Tusker House Breakfast ****
MMRI ***1/2
Boatwright's Breakfast ***

 

[catne]

Kona Cafe breakfast ****1/2
Kona Cafe dinner****
Grand Floridian Cafe dinner ***1/2
The Wave dinner ****1/2
California Grill dinner ***1/2
Liberty Tree Tavern dinner ***
Cinderella's Royal Table dinner ****
The Plaza Restaurant lunch ****
Crystal Palace dinner ***1/2
Olivia's dinner ***1/2
Kouzzina dinner**
Captain's Grill dinner ***1/2
Biergarten dinner ***
Rose & Crown dinner****
Chefs de France dinner ***1/2
Coral Reef lunch ****
San Angel Inn lunch ****1/2
Le Cellier dinner *****
Boma dinner *
Boma breakfast *****
Cape May Cafe dinner ***1/2
Hollywood & Vine dinner ***1/2
Mama Melrose dinner ****
Tusker House dinner ****
Yak & Yeti dinner ****
Chef Mickey's breakfast ***
1900 Park Fare dinner ****

 

[eccobleu]

Le Cellier's (L&D) **** 1/2
Crystal Palace ****
Sci-Fi Dine In ****
'Ohana Dinner ****
'Ohana Character Breakfast ****
Donald's Safari Breakfast *** 1/2
Teppan Edo *** 1/2
Chef Mickey's ***
Mama Melrose ***
Rain Forest Cafe (DTD) ***
Hoop Dee Doo *** (Good show, not so good food)
Coral Reef **

 

[BadgerBruce]

Cinderella's-lunch ****
Liberty Tree-dinner *****
Plaza-lunch ***1/2
Crystal Palace-lunch ****1/2
Tony's Town Square-breakfast *****

Garden Grill-lunch & dinner****
San Angel Inn-lunch & dinner****
Biergarten-lunch*****
Marrekesh-lunch***1/2
Chefs de France-lunch****
Rose & Crown-lunch***1/2
LeCellier-dinner*****

Tusker House-lunch***

Mama Melrose-lunch & dinner****
Hollywood & Vine-lunch *1/2
Sci Fi Dine In -lunch***

Rainforest Cafe-downtown-lunch***1/2
Planet Hollywood-lunch & dinner***
Raglan Road-dinner****
Portobello's-lunch****

Beaches & Cream*****
Cape May-breakfast***1/2 dinner****
Big River Grill-lunch***
ESPN Club-lunch***
Chef Mickey's-dinner***
Hoop-de-doo***1/2
Whispering Canyon***
Ohana-breakfast***dinner****1/2

 

[TillyMarigold]

Not ranking anything earlier than our most recent trip, since it had been such a long time.

Epcot:
Akershus (dinner) ****

Studios:
Sci-Fi ***½
Mama Melrose ***

Resorts:
Jiko *****
Narcoossee's ****½
Kouzzina (dinner) ****½
Boma (breakfast) ****
Kona Café (dinner) ***½
Cape May Café (breakfast) ***½


But I think that's all a little misleading. For example, Mama Melrose had outstanding food and truly awful service. Sci-Fi had outstanding service and just okay food. Cape May had pretty good food and pretty good service, but just wasn't our thing.

 

[ShannonMB]

Fun idea!

Wolfgang Puck Cafe ***1/2
Coral Reef ****
Liberty Tree Tavern (dinner) ***
Ohana ***
Hollywood and Vine **1/2
Boma ****
Crystal Palace (dinner) ***
Crystal Palace (breakfast) ***1/2
LeCellier ***1/2
Sci-Fi Diner **
Yak and Yeti ****
TRex Cafe ***1/2
50s PTC ****
Tusker House (breakfast) ****
San Angel Inn ***
1900 Park Fare (dinner) ***
Cinderella's Royal Table (breakfast) ***1/2
Cinderella's Royal Table (lunch) **1/2
Rainforest Cafe ***

I rated not necessarily on *fine cuisine*, but on our overall experience, food, fun, and how satisfied with the dining experience I was when I left.

 

[Twende]

Table Services
AK:
Tusker House - Breakfast 3 stars Characters 4 stars
Rainforest Cafe (DTD) - Dinner 2 stars

DS:
Brown Derby - Dinner 1 star
Mama Melrose's - Dinner 4 stars
50's Prime Time - Dinner 3 stars

MK:
Liberty Tree Tavern - Dinner 3 stars
Crystal Palace - Dinner 3 stars Characters 4 stars

EPCOT:
Coral Reef - Dinner 3 stars
Le Cellier - Dinner 5 stars
Marrakesh - Dinner 2 stars
Biergarten - Dinner 4 stars
Chefs de France 4 stars

Resorts and Other:
Spoodles (now gone) - Dinner 4 stars
Kouzzina - Dinner 3 1/2 stars
Cape May Cafe - Dinner 4 stars
Kona Cafe - Dinner 4 stars
'Ohana - Dinner 4 stars
Boma Breakfast 5 stars
Boma - Dinner 4 1/2 stars
Narcoossee's 5 stars
Grand Floridian Cafe 3 stars
Turf Club Bar and Grille SSR 5 stars
Wave 3 stars
California Grill 5 stars
Hoop Dee Doo Food - 3 1/2 stars Show 5 stars
1900 Park Fare - Food 3 stars Characters 4 stars
Boatwright's -POR Riverside 4 stars
River Roost - Food 3 stars Entertainment 4 stars
Raglan Road - Dinner 4 stars Entertainment 4 1/2 stars


Counter Service
AK:
Flame Tree Barbecue Lunch 4 stars
Picnic in the Park 4 stars

DS:
Min and Bill's Dockside Diner 3 1/2 stars
Backlot Express 2 stars
ABC Commissary 2 stars
Studio Catering Company 2 1/2 stars

MK:
Cosmic Ray's 4 stars
Main Street Bakery - Breakfast 4 stars
Pecos Bill - Lunch 3 stars
Pinocchio Village Haus - Lunch 3 stars

EPCOT:
Sunshine Seasons - Lunch Food 4 stars Seating 2 stars
Yorkshire County Fish Shop - Lunch 4 stars
Tangierine Cafe - Lunch 3 stars
Yakitori House -Lunch 3 stars
Electric Umbrella - Lunch 2 stars

Resorts & Other:
Beaches and Cream - Lunch 4 stars
Hurricane Hanna's Grill - Lunch 4 stars
Pepper Market 4 stars
Everything Pop Food Court 4 stars
Earl of Sandwich 5 stars
Wolfgang Puck Express - Lunch 4 stars
Roaring Fork 2 stars

Snacks
MK:
Aloha Isle 5 stars
Ice Cream/Treat Carts 4 stars

EPCOT:
Kringla Bakeri og Cafe 5 stars
Boulangerie Patisserie 4 stars

Resorts and Other:
Beach Club Marketplace 4 stars
Beaches and Cream 4 stars Kitchen Sink - not a Snack Credit
Seashore Sweets - Boardwalk 4 stars
Goofy's Candy Shop 3 stars; used to be 5 stars with Mickey Rice Crispy Treats!