rate in order best to worst, Disney resorts you've stayed at

[DAWGPOUNDAJ]

Best to Worst:
Carribean Beach Resort by a landslide
Polynesian
All Star Music
All Star Movies
All Star Sports
POFQ
POR
GF (Worst by a landslide)

 

[macs4us]

OKW
BWV
FWC
WL
CSR
PO-R
AKL

Good topic OP!!!

 

[goofynme]

1. Poly
2. Contemporary
3. Beach Club Villas
4. Boardwalk Villas
5. Animal Kingdom
6. Carribean Beach

I loved everyone of these resorts and would go back to any of them in heartbeat! I am partial to the monorail but I think I like the Beach Club the best if the monorail was not in the equation.

 

[Dee & Greg]

BC
AKL
PO/Riverside
PO/French Quarter
Coronado Springs

 

[newholidayx2]

WL / VWL
CB & PO/FQ are tied - (CB was a smoking room and PO/FQ I didnt want to be at WDW)
All Star Movies

 

[minijeanie]

had to give this some thought


1. Poly (concierge) so really who could not love it
2. WL ( kids were small, it was convenient and great memories)
3. BWV (love the convenience of being by epcot & MGM
4. Dolphin - great location, we had superb view, rooms large
5. FW(cabins) nice cabin but too out of the way for me
6. Port Orleans-loved pool
7. Dixie Landings - just okay, not crazy about pool, food court great
8. BC -hated it, staff unfriendly, room size horrible for deluxe room..had to move the table and chairs to get to balcony. pool overrated

 

[crazy4wdw]

1. Beach Club
2. Contemporary
3. Port Orleans French Quarter
4. Animal Kingdom Lodge
5. Poly
6. WL
7. All Star Movies
8. Port Orleans Riverside
9. All Star Music
10. Caribbean Beach

 

[WDWLVR]

Boardwalk Villas - home sweet home!
Grand Floridian - honeymooned here so it holds a special place in my heart!
Poly - a long time favorite
Contemporary - love the large rooms and a Disney classic
Yacht Club - great memories
Beach Club - same as Yacht Club
Old Key West - love the size of the villas
Beach Club Villas - nice
Wilderness Lodge - great themeing
Coronado Springs - cool pool and nice themeing
All Star Movies - fun, but could do with bigger beds
Caribbean Beach - nice but very spread out
Villas of Wilderness Lodge - our least favorite of all the DVC resorts. Probably the only place on property we won't stay again.

 

[iloverags2]

Wilderness Lodge
Yacht Club
Beach Club
Port Orleans Riverside
Caribbean Beach Resort
Ft. Wilderness Cabins
Old Key West
Coronado Springs
Contemporary
All Star Music
All Star Sports

 

[NCRedding]

OKW
AKL
Poly
VWL
CR
POFQ
ASMu
POR
BCV
Dolphin
CSR
Pop

 

[travellady]

Didn't dislike any of them but the order I liked them are:

1. AKL - loved watching the animals from our room
2. Contemporary - tower room, great view, great size room
3. POFQ - had connecting rooms for 4 of us, just refurbed so nice and clean
4. Poly - good size room but seemed outdated, dark, loved the pool

 

[dmonroe]

BWV
BWI
BCV
Treehouse Villas at the Disney Institute
POR
POFQ
ASMo

 

[WDW Poly Princess]

1. Poly
2. WL- almost tied for 1st with the Polynesian, but ranked 2nd because the Poly has better transportation.
3. PO-R
4. DAK-Lodge
5. ASMu
6. ASMo
7. PO-FQ

 

[missycj96]

Poly
CR
YC
WL
POR - RS

 

[antmaril]

Boardwalk Inn
Beach Club
Port Orleans French Quarter
Port Orleans Riverside
Caribbean Beach Resort

 

[BadgerBruce]

1.Boardwalk Villas-great rooms & location
2.Yacht Club-beautiful, new room & location
3.Swan-great resort & great location
4.Dolphin-great resort & great location
5.CSR-would be the favorite except I love to be able to walk to Epcot/MGM
6.Dixie Landings-our first onsite & still a beautiful place
7.Beach Club-even with the great location we were still disapointed here
8.POFQ-found we like the spread out moderates better

 

[MickeyisanNDfan]

Contemporary
Coronado Springs
Poly
CBR
Swan
POR

And I only put the Poly before CBR becasue it has the monorail.

 

[huntconn]

1. Polynesian
2. Contemporary
3. Wilderness Lodge
4. Caribbean Beach Resort
5. All Star Sports

Absolutely LOVE the Poly. Been goin' there since 1971 (2 yrs old at the time!). Can't say I really DISLIKE any Disney resort overall.

 

[kathy carleton]

this is tough... love them all for different reasons and at different times of the year!!

AKL- just such a special place, where else can we go to Africa? service great!
WL-love at the holiday time, great boat to MK
CSR- we love the pool and think this is more like a deluxe than a mod...
BWI-great pool & slide and location... staff a little impersonal
POR- this could easily be my #1... I love AB... pool just not as great as above resorts..
YC- pool and location!!
OKW- I know it has it's fans, but never again for us and we tried it 3 times!
CBR- just not for us

haven't tried a value yet, but hope to this summer... how bad can it be? we are at disney world!!!

 

[MinnieM21]

I've only stayed at the Grand Floridian so the GF would be the best resort I've stayed at.

I don't think I'll ever stay at anywhere but the GF.