After staying at AKL and loving it, we stayed at CR, and before that on a previous trip, the BC, which was so-so. Going from AKL to CR was as dofferent as night and day, tow totally different experiences. I loved the dim lighting and warmth of AKL, but I LOVED the excitement and open-all-night feel of the CR. I guess it's truly a matter of personal taste, but after 5 days of seeing the animals outside our balcony, it lost it's initial wow-factor. I do wish I had more time at AKL to enjoy the lounges and activities there. And the ambiance of the pool at night was great. But I'd stay at CR again before AKL.
This time we're trying WL, but only because it'll be Christmas-time, and we've heard that WL is beautiful at Christmas. I guess I'm a real city girl, because I still yearn for the CR.