Pulling kids out of school for a WDW trip

Does it really matter what anyone else thinks? Just be the parent for once, and don't ask for permission.


Exactly. I do understand feeling guilty about it and wanting to see how other people think, but in the end NO ONE can tell you what you can and cannot do as a parent.
 
I have one undergraduate degree and two Master's Degrees. None of them are in Education. Never taught, never worked for a school district. Like to think I am educated enough and thoughtful enough to have an opinion when it comes to educating children since I raised two who are both now marrried and functioning members of society. What I find most interesting of all when discussions of this nature occur that people become experts on a situation. In other discussions people will proudly extoll that they are authorities on subjects due to the fact that they work in banking, are an attorney, an IT professional, etc. However when the discussion turns to education everyone becomes an authority on the subject and will tell you that whatever the kid is doing while out of school is more educational and they will learn more doing the trip then they ever would at school. At the same time in other discussions people will tell you that Teachers are overworked, underpaid and unappreciated.

I am no authority on education, never said I was, do not purport to be. But, people here are more than willing to make judgement and try to justify their actions by saying the trip is more educational, and the kids will do whatever work assigned while away from school. They feel the need to justify why they are taking them out of school. I contend now and always have that if you want to take them out of school for whatever reason then take them out of school and go on your trip. Don't rationalize, don't justify, don't try to convince anyone here or at your kids school why you did what you did. Just do it.

To try and convince others that the trip is "better" than being in school is a no win situation. People come off sounding like I know more than educators. It causes extra work for the Teachers because they have to prepare the package of work the parents want the kid to do. Actual teaching time is cut, concepts may and in most cases will have to be repeated to the missing student. It causes more work for the Teacher that many freely admit are already taxed pretty hard in terms of work and pay. They have an entire set of work that they have to grade seperately.

I am not trying to be judgemental merely saying that do what you want and then deal with whatever the district throws at you. Know the rules and accept consiquinces.
 
Exactly. I do understand feeling guilty about it and wanting to see how other people think, but in the end NO ONE can tell you what you can and cannot do as a parent.

While I have certainly advocated that you should do what you want in terms of vacation during school, I do freely admit there are limitations due to the law. One can read this statement at it's extreme and say "Hey if I want to keep my kid out of school all year to tour Africa, then I can" Well yes you can, but at that point if your permanant residence is in the US then you have an obligation to apply for Homeschooling and follow an accepted curriculum to make sure your child is being educated. If not then you will be held accountable for your actions. That is the world we live in.

While it seems strange in some instances my wife as an Attendence Clerk was able to help people avoid issues if they spoke to her first. We live in a suburb of Houston and due to our location we have people live here from all over the world. Many to work in the Medical Center and at MD Anderson Cancer Center, Many to work with NASA, and many who come for the Oil and Gas business. As a result people want and need to take international trips all the time for family matters, funerals, weddings, etc. Obviously these trips can exceed the allowable days out of school for the student. In those cases my wife's best and easiest advice was to withdraw the student from school and upon return just re enroll them. No problem. no missed days on the record, no missed homework, no one questioning where the heck the kid has been. In other words there are solutions that do not turn into huge issues. So ask and be flexible and it does not become an issue.
 
I don’t doubt that it might be a good school district. Think pp just saying she wouldn’t like that & I can understand. These threads always remind me of why we will pay for private school. It’s for many reasons in the area we live, but we won’t have to deal with any of those issues.
I understand that and that is her prerogative. I was only pointing out that the academic credentials far outweighed the strict absence policy and didn't seem to be keeping many people away, in fact, people are trying their hardest to get into the district.
 
I was going to say - we live in a state that consistently ranks very high nationwide for quality of education, and our town is one of the best in the state. They do not have nearly as strict a policy, when we opted to take the kids on vacation for a week we just communicated with the teachers, and all were very willing to set aside any work that was done that week for my kids to catch up on when they got home. Correlation doesn't equal causation (i.e. the attendance policy isn't making or breaking the school quality in yours, mine or the PP's cases)
absolutely, correlation does not equal causation. I didn't say that our attendance policy was the reason the academics were so strong. I said that because of the academics, the strict attendance policy had no impact on people wanting to attend in the district. The poster I replied to said she would never go to our district because of the policy. That is the choice people have to make when choosing a district. You have to balance the district policies including absence vs academic strength. Again, it is choice, which is a good thing. The thing you can't have is your cake and eat it too. You can't be part of the best school district here and also expect teachers to accommodate your whims to travel outside of school breaks.
 
Does it really matter what anyone else thinks? Just be the parent for once, and don't ask for permission.
I agree. Do what you want with your children. But also accept any and all consequences of your choice without complaining. If your student gets a zero for missing a test (ie: no makeups allowed in our district,) you can't complain to the teachers.
 
Disney World is extremely educational as well.
As are the many other locations you can take your kids. Are you going to Disney because it's educational, or because it's "fun"?

Does it really matter what anyone else thinks? Just be the parent for once, and don't ask for permission.
Go right ahead. But be willing to accept any consequences of your actions. Why is that so hard for people to do?
 
I live in Orleans Parish so DS will definitely attend private school. And, I don’t know anyone from this area who attended public school including my grandparents who went to school in the 1930s. So, I hate to say, but I’m not really concerned if they improve other than it sucks for those poor kids without options.

And, not all private schools are the same like public schools, of course, so we intend to choose carefully. In this area, there are several private schools to choose from (almost as many as public). I’m curious, did your DIL attend a private school in Slidell?

Related to this thread, IMO, public schools are most concerned with their funding & scores b/c they have to be. And, that’s really the only reason they have strict attendance policies.


Kind of off topic, but sometimes I believe the “bad school” thing is kind of a chicken & egg scenario. Do good students avoid the school because of poor results? Or, are poor results due to the fact good students don’t attend? Perhaps both.
 
Disney World is extremely educational as well.
Take your kids out because you enjoy Disney as a family. But let's not go to ridiculous extremes and claim that a theme park with cartoon characters is educational. Going to Rome to see history, that is educational. Visiting the World in Epcot is visiting a theme park. Not even close.
 
Missing a week of school isn't going to be detrimental to a good student, or even an average student. Depending on the age, even a bad student either.
Education doesn't always come from a classroom. I'm not saying that you should look at a vacation as an educational trip or even use that excuse for an absence but kids can and do learn when just "living life". Sometimes that education is more useful than what they learn in a classroom too. You need more than book smarts to live in the real world.
We took our kids out for a few trips when they were younger and we decided that after a certain point we wouldn't anymore.
Then an opportunity came up when 2 of my kids were in HS and we took it. It was the best decision ever, that trip set my dd on her future for path. Before that she was kind of lost about what she wanted to pursue in college. I think that was totally the worth the week of HS classes she missed.
 
A couple pages back someone mentioned online assignments & I wonder going forward how this will impact these things. One of DD’s HS math teachers gave ZERO in class instruction. Rather, each day consisted of a pre-recorded lecture the kids could watch in class or at home. The teacher spent the hour working with individuals & small groups who needed extra help with the current or previous day’s lecture/assignment. My kids submit all their tests & assignments online now at the MS & HS levels. Eventually, this will become the norm in elementary as well.

Going forward, this may become a double edged sword for those who take kids out of school for vacation. On one hand, it will become much easier to get assignments & instruction to those not in attendance. On the other hand, the expectation of assignments & tests being completed on time will increase as well.
 
DD was just informed that her University is cancelling classes due to the dangerously low wind chills and blizzard warning.
And this is in an area that is very used to being pummeled by snow and wind in the winter

ETA sorry I meant to post this in the polar vortex thread LOL
 
Last edited:
While I have certainly advocated that you should do what you want in terms of vacation during school, I do freely admit there are limitations due to the law. One can read this statement at it's extreme and say "Hey if I want to keep my kid out of school all year to tour Africa, then I can" Well yes you can, but at that point if your permanant residence is in the US then you have an obligation to apply for Homeschooling and follow an accepted curriculum to make sure your child is being educated. If not then you will be held accountable for your actions. That is the world we live in.

While it seems strange in some instances my wife as an Attendence Clerk was able to help people avoid issues if they spoke to her first. We live in a suburb of Houston and due to our location we have people live here from all over the world. Many to work in the Medical Center and at MD Anderson Cancer Center, Many to work with NASA, and many who come for the Oil and Gas business. As a result people want and need to take international trips all the time for family matters, funerals, weddings, etc. Obviously these trips can exceed the allowable days out of school for the student. In those cases my wife's best and easiest advice was to withdraw the student from school and upon return just re enroll them. No problem. no missed days on the record, no missed homework, no one questioning where the heck the kid has been. In other words there are solutions that do not turn into huge issues. So ask and be flexible and it does not become an issue.


I would think it is common sense that there are consequences for any actions in life.

If a parent does not realize this then they have bigger problems that go beyond the scope of this thread.
 
absolutely, correlation does not equal causation. I didn't say that our attendance policy was the reason the academics were so strong. I said that because of the academics, the strict attendance policy had no impact on people wanting to attend in the district. The poster I replied to said she would never go to our district because of the policy. That is the choice people have to make when choosing a district. You have to balance the district policies including absence vs academic strength. Again, it is choice, which is a good thing. The thing you can't have is your cake and eat it too. You can't be part of the best school district here and also expect teachers to accommodate your whims to travel outside of school breaks.

True. I suppose my point was that you can be in an excellent school district that has very different policies on absence/makeup work. totally understanding that it varies greatly by state - we are extremely fortunate to live where we do and know that even our worst schools are "average" in many states. Of course, we choose to stay here with the higher taxes and cost of living, that is our trade off.
 
I say go for it if that is what works for your family.
Our children's educations should not hinge on missing 5 days of school.
They could miss those same 5 days due to illness, injury or a family emergency...vacation is such a better reason to miss school!
Do your best to let the school know in advance & have your child do their best to get the work turned in when they get back.
My coworker is taking her 2 kids out of school for 2 weeks for a Disney trip :)
 
absolutely, correlation does not equal causation. I didn't say that our attendance policy was the reason the academics were so strong. I said that because of the academics, the strict attendance policy had no impact on people wanting to attend in the district. The poster I replied to said she would never go to our district because of the policy. That is the choice people have to make when choosing a district. You have to balance the district policies including absence vs academic strength. Again, it is choice, which is a good thing. The thing you can't have is your cake and eat it too. You can't be part of the best school district here and also expect teachers to accommodate your whims to travel outside of school breaks.
I also live in a very highly rated school district. We have a long waitlist of kids trying to get into our district through school of choice. We also have a fairly liberal attendance policy. So I beg to differ that you “can’t have your cake and eat it too”. I stand by my statement that I wouldn’t live in a district in which I don’t agree with the policies, whether it is absence related or otherwise.
 
A couple pages back someone mentioned online assignments & I wonder going forward how this will impact these things. One of DD’s HS math teachers gave ZERO in class instruction. Rather, each day consisted of a pre-recorded lecture the kids could watch in class or at home. The teacher spent the hour working with individuals & small groups who needed extra help with the current or previous day’s lecture/assignment. My kids submit all their tests & assignments online now at the MS & HS levels. Eventually, this will become the norm in elementary as well.

Going forward, this may become a double edged sword for those who take kids out of school for vacation. On one hand, it will become much easier to get assignments & instruction to those not in attendance. On the other hand, the expectation of assignments & tests being completed on time will increase as well.


Our school no longer has "snow days," etc, they have digital learning days. Each kid has access to a device. They are required to complete a certain amount of material, and log their reading, etc, as well. We were gone for a week for death in the family, and yes, we did take the kids to Universal over that week spent in Orlando, but they had their laptops and did their work. Times are different, for sure!
 
As are the many other locations you can take your kids. Are you going to Disney because it's educational, or because it's "fun"?


Go right ahead. But be willing to accept any consequences of your actions. Why is that so hard for people to do?
Why not both?
You dont think other educational places are fun? My niece had a blast in China, Europe, and Peru.
And when I was growing up and my parents were taking me out to go to Disney we road tripped it so we stopped in DC, went to Stone Mountain, Rock City, Ruby Falls, The Lost Sea, Silver Springs, Weeki Wachee Springs (home of the mermai), Homosassa Springs (home of the manatee), Cypress Gardens..... tons of fun and education to be had all around you.
 
Last edited:

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom