I'll tell you my tale...
Returned to school as a single mother of 2 in 1991. Associates in humanities at the community college, only b/c I could transfer it to a 4yr school. Transferred into a private university (more willing to work with my credits, I was in a time crunch due to alimony and court orders and all). Completed a BA in English/Education in 1993 at 29yo. In case you haven't heard it, there is a song about "What do you do with a BA in English" in case you want to Google it.

I taught English for 2 years before I decided it was not for me. Remarried, 2 more kids, yada-yada. Started my own business, it was fine, but I had working for Disney in the back of my head since my older 2 went through the CP.
I started University of Phoenix online in the Master's of Management/HR program in Jan 08, partly b/c I wanted to run my business better, partly b/c I was eyeing the management internships. 2008, economy was on the skids and I saw the writing on the wall of my 9mpg/$5.50/gal cargo trailer. I applied for the internship. Went through the whole process and did well. Watching the economy and Facebook and Disboards, I got antsy and applied for the CP as a lifeboat. Turns out, I needed it.
The management internships were pretty much cancelled (a few had already been hired and got to come), so I moved my 2 DDs still at home to WDW to work for the Mouse on the CP. Spring 2009, got a call asking if I would still be interested in an MI if one were available (heck, yeah!) and was offered a position on April 22nd (Earth Day, I will always remember!). Did the MI from June 2009 - Jan 2010 when I was offered my current role as a statused resort duty manager. It's a part time role, which is actually perfect for me as I needed this year to finish my degree and catch my breath (I also homeschool my youngest 2). Now that I'm gearing up for graduation, I'm ramping up my search for full-time and moving on with my career.
All that said, while I believe that any degree is probably a good degree, I think you will gain more valuable and
practical knowledge by getting a degree in business. Of course you know to avoid a degree mill and my jury is still out on how I feel about the University of Phoenix. I'm torn between hating it and wanting to teach there myself.

However I feel about it, I will graduate in September, an achievement of which I am very proud and forever grateful that it was the vehicle that allowed me to reach my dream of being a manager at WDW.