we ate at the California Grill on the 15th floor of the Contemporary. You should cross this off your list for next year.
We had a 5:30 p.m. ressie, we got there about 20 minutes early and went out to the observation deck to take a few pictures and were seated right at 5:30.
First off, I should say I am a VERY picky eater.. I'm a meat and potato girl. My Daughter is not as bad as me, she'll TRY new things. Me? NO WAY, My dad taught me early with the "yuck, that looks terrible, you don't want to try that!!"
The view was fantastic. We had a window view of the castle and could see it changing colors, that was the best thing about the whole dining experience. As far as the food, well $45 each for dinner was really expensive, I thought. You select what you want from a limited menu. We didn't like any of the appetizers, so we ended up with the "bread" kind of like pizza flatbread, I pulled the red peppers and the hunks of goat cheese off. My daughter had the salad - which she took one bite of and said it tasted like it had soap on it instead of salad dressing. Me, I'm a plain garden salad person.. no romaine, this looked like a cesar salad, so, no thanks, none for me.
I had the turkey dinner, it was somewhat cold, but then turkey usually gets kind of cold by the time it gets to the table as you finish getting the veggies, etc ready. My daughter didn't like ANYTHING on the menu, so she ended up with Goat cheese ravioli and only had a few bites.
We didn't get any dessert, although it was included in the dinner price... no cheesecake, no ice cream, just yuck to us. I had ice water to drink, she had an ice tea and a glass of house champagne ($7)
SO, $112 later plus tip, we were outta there for some food... My daughter had a peanut butter & jelly sandwich when we got back to the Polynesian to change so we could go to the Magic Kingdom.
Try the Hard Rock Cafe (if you have your own car)... We used Yourride transportation to get back & forth from the airport. When Rabbit picked us up to drive us back to the airport, he said he had gone there and it was great.. I believe he said it was around $28 a person for the all you can eat buffet... and they had a HUGE selection.