6 thumbs up!!
Here's our review --
The 6 of us, ages ranging from 41 to 3 years, had breakfast there in December 2002 and of all the places we were everybody agreed this was the best.
The food -- okay it's not on the same level as a 4 star restaurant but you're not at a 4 star restaurant either. We enjoyed it. Not one of us had a bad item off the buffet. Our 20 year old got up for seconds, thirds, fourths ... I lost track after that, he might have even had fifths!
The characters -- Minnie, Pluto or Goofy (I can't remember which) and then Chip and Dale. They each came around twice, signed the autograph books and posed for pictures. And they didn't just interact with the little ones either. We were in a booth so they couldn't get in the picture with us in the back but they made a point of waving or shaking hands with us. Chip/Dale kept messing up our 16 year olds hair each time he came by too.
In comparison -- at the Garden Grill, which was empty at our 4pm seating, they stopped once. They walked past our table several times but they never stopped again. At the Crystal Palace the CM told us to stay seated and all the characters would come around. Well, Tigger never signed the books, we got him later at AK though, and Pooh never came around. We asked a different CM and she told us you have to go up to him. We felt rushed at the Castle breakfast, the Norway breakfast was good.
I'd have to say for us that H & V was our number one favorite, hands down, Norway and Crystal Palace were tied, then the Castle and dead last was the Garden Grille.
At H & V Minne and Pluto or Goofy did a little song and dance thing a couple times. Yes, it was loud but it was cute. Most everybody was clapping, taking pictures, kids were getting up to dance ... not ours, they're too shy.
We'd go back there. I think you have to keep in mind that buffets are loud/noisy, we have buffets places here at home and they are always noisy. Why should Disney buffets be any different? The food is okay. It's for a buffet so it's mass prepared. You can't expect to die for, write home about food at a buffet no matter wher the buffet is. The money you're paying is as much for the chacter interaction as the atmosphere. We hd a meal in Chicago once (Kahunaville), it's like the RainForest Cafe. It was well over $50 for 2 adult meals and 1 kids meal. The food was mediocre but the atmosphere was great, that's what we paid for.
Sorry I got so long with this -- bottom line is we loved it and would go back again!!!!!!!!!!!