If their favorite part was seeing the castle and watching the fireworks, then a theme park view room would be awesome to them. It's much closer than the one's with a view at the Poly.
I kinda feel the same way about the Poly that pp feels about the CR. To each his own
agreed 1000%- we've stayed in a tower room with a theme park view past two years...my daughter runs in the first day and loves it 24/7....want Magical? walk to the Magic Kingdom in 10 minutes- that's magical...
i've asked my wife and daughter (now 10YO- first time she stayed at CR she was 1.5) about staying one time in the Poly and they say "no way- CR"....
gotta also add- while the concourse gets busy its not distracting or disturbing...it is great, and my daughter loves, seeing what's happening at Chef Mickey's as we are leaving, coming back to our rooms....got to say i really enjoy walking out the door (tower room) and seeing it as well...