Please bring back Interval International

patmcg

Mouseketeer
Joined
Apr 25, 2000
Messages
86
I was quite disappointed when the DVC announced in late 2008, that they decided to drop Interval International (II) and replace it with RCI.

Prior to DVC’s decision, I always felt that if I wanted a change of scenery and travel to a location other than a Disney resort, I knew that my wife and I would have many options available to us that would provide accommodations and service similar to the DVC. In the past, we had visited a number of them and were extremely satisfied.

As a matter of fact, were it not for the availability of II, we would not have purchased additional points while cruising on the Disney Magic back in the Spring of 2008.

Once I received word from the DVC that they were dropping II, after I had a sinking feeling in my stomach, I let my feelings be known to Member Services during Dec. of 2008. They attempted to reassure me that if I were to give RCI a chance, my wife and I would feel differently. Well quite honestly, after viewing the options, to switch to, I am more convinced than ever that I will be spending more of my points at DVC resorts. (Perhaps that’s what DVC really had in mind).

Disney Vacation Club should consider switching back to II for the following reasons:

• The better the travel options the more likely DVC will attract new members.
• Existing members are more likely to purchase additional points.
• Members of II when switching to a DVC resort will be exposed to the DVC experience (potential new members.)
• II has big name resorts while RCI has a number of small no name resorts and quite honestly, I don’t wish to take a vacation and not know if I am going to be satisfied. I want to go with brand names, like Marriott, Four Seasons, Starwood and Wyndham, Hyatt, etc…

I have to admit what fueled my message came about after speaking with a friend this weekend who owns at the Wyndham Vacation Club, formerly Fairfield. He too had expressed his dissatisfaction with the selections of RCI. I knew then I was not alone.

Perhaps at the two year mark this December, we will hear news from DVC (perhaps at the annual meetings) that DVC will be going back to II.

We can only hope.
 
:) We have another timeshare and they use II so we never joined RCI because we knew we would not be trading our DVC. We have always been pleased with II.
 
RCI has most of the Wyndham resorts and it has the Hilton vacation club.

I'd like to see DVC dual affiliate with both. Then the membership wold have access to it all. :goodvibes
 
Unfortunately, Wyndham throws out the older less desirable resorts to RCI most of the time.

The Wyndham resorts in II are not the newest top of the line resorts, but at least they are some of the nicer ones (exception Star Island-IMO).

My Wyndham points and my other TSs trade in II, so I would love to see DVC back in II.
 

I will never, ever, exchange to RCI and would much prefer II. The only time I used them ( not as an exchange though) we were supposedly at a premium property. The furniture was mismatched, old- the CS was horrid, and I couldn't wait for the week to end. I felt like I was at an upscale Motel 6 with some activities. No offense to RCI owners and yes, I know there are some nice, desirable properties. I'm not about to take a chance when I'm giving up DVC quality and then getting something way below my expectations.---Kathy
 
2009 was our 25th anniversary. I had been checking out those short term reservations you could make right online for months, waiting till it was close enough to book. We figured rather than spend money on a one-time trip we would buy 100 more points as our anniversary gift to each other, and bank and borrow to use them to book a big Interval International trip. That way we would get a trip and still have the points for future years. Then they switched to RCI. We were so disappointed!! Very little selection, especially for short stays, as we wanted to travel around Europe staying a few days at each resort. Plus we lost the option of booking immediately online - A major perk in my opinion.

We decided to just pay for a trip and skipped the points. We have enough points if we are only using them for Disney.

I'd love to hear advice from people who own non-Disney timeshares about which are the best companies and what places are best to buy to be able to trade for International Travel.
 
I liked the fact that there were good solid choices like
Marriotts in places like Aruba...I think at that time Marriott Surf Club and Marriott Ocean Club were choices with Interval!

I haven't studied the RCI option probably for over a year ago, but I was not impressed when I did!

I WOULD LOVE TO SEE INTERVAL INTERNATIONAL BROUGHT BACK TOO!:banana::banana::banana::banana:
 
Keep in mind that the recent changes introduced by Marriott Vacation Club may mean far, far less Marriott inventory will be available through Interval International. Would you still want to go back to II if you couldn't have Marriott?
 
Keep in mind that the recent changes introduced by Marriott Vacation Club may mean far, far less Marriott inventory will be available through Interval International. Would you still want to go back to II if you couldn't have Marriott?

Curious what are these changes?
 
Curious what are these changes?

Way too complicated to distill into a small post here. Go over to TUG and check out the Marriott board. I think it's going to be a mess.

I'm just glad I passed on a few Marriott buying opportunities I had in this past year.
 
I'd like to see DVC dual affiliate with both.
There's no advantage to DVC of doing this---with an exclusive agreement, Disney has much better negotiating leverage.

I would not expect DVC to ever dual-affiliate.
 
We are new members and I have to say I am not that keen on RCI. When I looked online at the resorts, none seemed that nice and I could get them for less money than trading out with my points. I don't know what II offered, as I am new to the whole timeshare thing, but I can only assume or hope that they are better options.
 
I would agree with the II too. I haven't yet tried to exchange with RCI, but my friends own another resort in the RCI system, and it's not easy. Also, when you exchange, you often get the "dregs" as far as location and condition are concerned.
 
I must admit, I've been perfectly happy with my RCI exchanges over the past several years. The resorts I've stayed in have all been fine, but I've also done my homework before making an exchange. I haven't had the "dregs" experience yet with my RCI exchanges. But with some larger resorts, you can always run the risk of being placed in a unit that's closer to the end of its refurbishment cycle and really needs some attention. For example, the OKW unit I had in February of '09 as an II inbound had stains on the carpet, a disintegrating dishwasher, and rust on the fridge.

That said, I'm using a mix of fixed weeks and Wyndham points, all purchased resale; nothing is very expensive. The Wyndham points are good "bargain hunters" for shoulder time, over-supplied areas, or last-minute bookings because you can deposit small-point units that are very inexpensive. The fixed weeks are for "big game"---Hawaii, DVC, summer coastal Atlantic, etc. RCI uses a tighter notion of "like for like" than II did, and trade-ups in terms of supply/demand got a lot harder last year, so folks' experience really depends on what they are depositing, and it takes some time to figure it all out. Naturally, everyone thinks that they are depositing something that everyone else wants, but it doesn't always work out that way, and that leads to some disappointment. The rumored "credit system" will solve some of these problems, but it's still a rumor---albeit a pretty strong one. My fixed weeks aren't quite tiger traders, but they see the vast majority of the deposits in the system.

DVC Members won't have an issue here, because they're near the top of the food chain in terms of supply/demand---not quite at the top because it is Orlando and the DVC system has grown to be relatively large, but close enough. My sense is that DVC actually has more favorable treatment in RCI than it did in II, because fewer of the resort systems in RCI use an internal preference period: VRI does, but that's about it. In II, no DVC owner ever got a shot at a Marriott or Starwood deposit until after owners in those systems had their exclusive access period expire.

In any event, it's almost always a better deal to rent out your points and use the proceeds to rent the non-DVC lodging you desire---and that's true whether the current affiliation is RCI or II. Hawaii, New York, and maybe a few other urban locations might be exceptions to this. Exchange is easy, but not a good value because DVC owners can ride the coattails of Mickey's vast marketing machine to get good value for their rentals.
 
DVC Members won't have an issue here, because they're near the top of the food chain in terms of supply/demand---not quite at the top because it is Orlando and the DVC system has grown to be relatively large, but close enough. My sense is that DVC actually has more favorable treatment in RCI than it did in II, because fewer of the resort systems in RCI use an internal preference period: VRI does, but that's about it. In II, no DVC owner ever got a shot at a Marriott or Starwood deposit until after owners in those systems had their exclusive access period expire.

In any event, it's almost always a better deal to rent out your points and use the proceeds to rent the non-DVC lodging you desire---and that's true whether the current affiliation is RCI or II. Hawaii, New York, and maybe a few other urban locations might be exceptions to this. Exchange is easy, but not a good value because DVC owners can ride the coattails of Mickey's vast marketing machine to get good value for their rentals.

I agree.

Plus DVC members that want to exchange will have better luck booking in peak season at high demand areas with RCI than with II (due to the II preference period and the developer controlled deposits of mostly offseason weeks in II).

For those thinking about an exchange, definitely read all of the reviews before you make a decision. All timeshares are not created equal.
TUG's Resort Database is a good start (http://tug2.com/RnR/ResortsGrid.aspx?GoldCrown=true) and http://www.tripadvisor.com/ is another resource.

Another option is a private exchange via the TUG Marketplace (see exchange ads - http://tug2.com/timesharemarketplace/)
 
I liked the fact that there were good solid choices like
Marriotts in places like Aruba...I think at that time Marriott Surf Club and Marriott Ocean Club were choices with Interval!

I haven't studied the RCI option probably for over a year ago, but I was not impressed when I did!

I WOULD LOVE TO SEE INTERVAL INTERNATIONAL BROUGHT BACK TOO!:banana::banana::banana::banana:


If you're still interested in Aruba there are some highly rated resorts in RCI for Aruba.

Here's the TUG ranking and rating for Aruba - http://tug2.com/RnR/ResortsGrid.aspx?ResortArea=7&ResortGroup=67

#1 Marriott's Aruba Ocean Club (MAO) - Rating 9.20 (II only)
#2 Marriott's Aruba Surf Club (MSU) - Rating 9.00 (II only)
#3 Costa Linda Beach Resort (2604 CDA) - Rating 8.74 (Dual RCI & II)
#4 Playa Linda Beach Resort (2139 PLB) - Rating 8.60 (Dual RCI & II)
#5 Divi Village Golf and Beach Resort (6881) - Rating 8.58 (RCI only)
#6 Occidental Grand Aruba (5764) - Rating 8.50 (RCI only)
#7 Royal Palm Club at the Aruba Grand (1931 ROY) - Rating 8.50 (Dual RCI & II)
#8 Divi Village Golf & Beach Resort (4988 DVV) - Rating 8.47 (Dual RCI & II)
#9 Casa del Mar Beach Resort (1200 CSD) - Rating 8.40 (Dual RCI & II)
#10 Divi Aruba Phoenix Beach Resort (4032) - Rating 8.20 (RCI only)

NOTE: Normally RCI has four character resort codes and II has three character resort codes

I would suggest reading the reviews on TUG and Tripadvisor to determine which resort best fits your vacation style. AIso use the search function on the TUG forums for additional information
 



















DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top