XBOX!
No, I don't know why. But DH researched them thoroughly and came to the conclusion that the XBOX is better. He's had his for a year, and always took it to a friend's house to play, despite the fact that the friend had a PS2. The friend just got an XBOX for his anniversary, which means ours can stay at home!
I've been told that Halo, which is only available on the XBOX, is the "best game ever."
BTW, snowball, the XBOX is a DVD player, too. I yell at DH every time he takes it away from me, as at the moment, it's our ONLY DVD player!