I am no expert, but here are my thoughts. At Sunset Pointe, you can see the castle in the background which is really nice. It is open with a beautiful view of the lake. I think it was MelMel who recently got married there (sorry if that is wrong). The real downside is that you can only invite 8 guests total (besides you and your DF). As for the YC Gazebo, it is also very nice. It is located in a beautiful rose garden. The drawback (for us at least) is that the gazebo is surrounded on three sides by the YC. When photos are taken, you see the hotel in the background. FantasiaSam had her wedding at the gazebo. On the other hand, you can invite up to 18 guests. So, I guess I would go with Sunset Pointe because of the view (unless you can't stick to the 8 guests). That is just my opinion, though...everyone has their own view of the locations. Take a look in the photos thread at the top of the forum. Good luck with your choice!