Phantom of the Opera (the movie).

[Charade]

It's on right now. I absolutely love the movie (the story) BUT I've decided I really don't like Gerard Butler as the Phantom. It's not his acting, it's his singing. At times it's quite irritating. What were they thinking!!

 

[DisneyGirl]

I have to agree-- but, I'm not crazy about his whole persona as the phantom-- when I saw it in the theater (three times), I always felt sympathetic towards the phantom-- in the movie, I felt *no* sympathy towards him whatsoever!!

I also didn't like that they took out the "hints" of magic, and actually showed all of the trapdoors and ways things happened!

 

[The Dark Dancer]

Really? I love Gerard as the Phantom. It's just the way he carries himself...very graceful and powerful at the same time.... I like his singing, also.

I do think he was a bit extreme at times....but

I think that he did a great job, but, that's just my opinion.