Davenport is a perfect location, in my opinion. You are 20 minutes away from Disney, yet far enough away that it feels like you are living your day to day life, not living as a tourist. This is really important to differentiate that we are not on an extended vacation. Yet, on the other hand you are close enough for when you want that Disney magic.
Even though we bought a house in a community that allows short term rentals it feels like a home to us. Yes, we are surrounded by homes that rent out and the occupants come and go. But there are a few full time residents. And a few part time residents like us. School buses do make the rounds. We enjoy getting together with one retired couple who live up the street. When we are there we are, as 'aleksandr' says, just living our life. Twenty minutes from Disney.
I would stick to a home for sure.
There's lots of new development going on as well, but I also have concerns about the techniques and speed in which they put up these houses.
Yes, you do have to be careful about build quality. We made sure to buy a home built after the new hurricane protection requirements went into effect in 2002(?). We looked at a number of developments in Davenport. Some nice, some it was clear were starting to fall behind in care. We got a one story concrete block house built in 2004. Located in a very well maintained development. The kitchen and bathrooms are a bit 'dated' but in good shape. We do not need to have the latest tile/counters/cabinets. We made a very good deal on the property. But, as I mentioned above, we are now replacing the failing appliances. Expenses we budgeted for. The HOA does a very good job maintaining the yards and the common areas, keeping the community looking good. This is especially important since there is still new building going on in the community. Though the homes they are building now are mostly bigger, fancier, and much higher priced. Overall we remain very happy with our decision to purchase a home in Florida.