I also have stayed at all three DL hotels. I have not been to WDW so can't compare to their hotels. I will say that I was pleasantly surprised by PPH when we stayed there. We did it to specifically be able to compare all three hotels. We were on the 9th floor and had an awesome view of DCA. They do not turn off the lights at night and it is great to enjoy the site. If EP is showing, you can even view it from your room.
Our room was not one of the remodeled rooms but I thought it was quite roomy. Yes - it has hair dryer, mickey soaps and shampoo, coffee maker and small frig. I believe the rehab is set to be completed by May - if you are going before that, request a rehabed room if they are booking them. Even if you don't get a rehab room, I don't think you will be disappointed. I would try to get a least a lower theme park view, though, to see the lights of DCA.
As far as distance goes - yes, the entrance to DCA is across the street but honestly, it took us at most a few minutes to cross that street and walk down the path into DCA. If you want to catch the Monorail, go out the BACK of the hotel and follow the brick path and it will take you right there. It is only a few minutes longer than walking from the Bonita Tower at DH (furthest tower). If you want to walk directly to DL, go out the front of the hotel, cross the street and CUT THROUGH THE GC LOBBY. We found this easily saved us 7-8 minutes.
As far as the pool goes, it was just a bland rectangle pool. It is being rehabed right now and I have heard that it will be "Beach" themed and they will be putting in a slide with a "roller coaster" theme so it sounds like they are trying to bring it in line with the DH and GC. One nice thing, you can watch the fireworks from the pool area and they pipe in the music. They are working hard to tie in PPH with the Paradise Pier area of DCA. The renovated rooms will have surfboard room numbers on the door, Mickey with surfboard lamps, new carpet in hallways in coordinating colors. They are redoing lobby to also fit into the theme.
I really was expecting to be let down when we stayed at PPH after numerous visits to DH and a conceirge suite stay at the GC. I actually think the service is better at PPH than at GC (my heart still belongs to DH!!). I came back from that trip very impressed and have recommended it to several people.
Have a great trip!
