My response to this question is always the same. If I had paid attention to all the bad reviews I've read about all the resorts we have stayed at, we would have missed out on many fantastic WDW memories. We would not have stayed at any of them because I have read negative reports on all of them.
We have never been disappointed in any of them, including POFQ. I love the theme, it's compact, and it's an easy walk to POR. Or take a boat or bus there and enjoy what it has to offer. And it has the boat ride to DTD and back.