I live about an hour from Disney. I’ve been to Disney twice since I’ve lived here. In those two time once was a probably historically low attendance day the day after a hurricane, and it was wonderful. I even figured out how to get my ticket on myDisney and got a fast pass for the only ride that had a wait.
The second time myDisney lost my ticket and would not allow me to make FPS even though I was staying onsite. My Disney fanatic sister was able to add me to her group, and got me FPs, but despite making them 60 days in advance we still couldn’t get the latest rides.
After that experience I found going to Universal was much less of a hassle, and the Harry Potter worlds are awesome.
However, if Disney made a way for me to buy FPs the day of my visit I’d pony up for an annual pass and be there every month.
Right now I feel that I’m at a huge disadvantage going to Disney. Those who understand all the rules and in many cases how to get around the rules for making fast passes get the more desirable rides. Those who are used to the idiosyncrasies of the Disney app are able to refresh and get more FPS while I can’t even get it to show my FPs.
I’m willing to pay more to be even with the folks that know the system well. I’m not willing to pay at all to go and get less of an experience.