Paddlefish or The Boathouse!

[Mousetopia]

Both seem fantastic! I can only do one! Its all about the seafood for me. I have never been to either. Thoughts?

 

[CynBeth]

We loved The Boathouse when we tried it for the first time in November.

 

[DVCjj]

I vote Boathouse. Loved many times.
Went to Paddle several years ago and not a good experience. That doesn't say what it is now though.
But knowing how everything seems to be a big mess at stores and restaurants etc. etc. we are not giving it another try.

 

[DWillowBay]

Last week, I went to Paddlefish as I have never been able to get there and wanted to try it. Never. Again. My best advice is to go to Boathouse. Far Superior. Service was weak, food was meh, atmosphere was boring, though as a punishment, I had a clear view of the Boathouse. Weeping.

 

[Mousetopia]

I sm rem

Last week, I went to Paddlefish as I have never been able to get there and wanted to try it. Never. Again. My best advice is to go to Boathouse. Far Superior. Service was weak, food was meh, atmosphere was boring,

though as a punishment, I had a clear view of the Boathouse. Weeping.

I am remembering now..way back planning spotty reviews hmm

 

[PalmettoPath]

Boathouse. Currently among our top three at WDW.

 

[ande2428]

Boathouse and it’s not even close. The rooftop bar at the paddlefish is worth a stop on a beautiful night.

 

[boxer]

Tried Paddlefish in May--great service, but waaaay over-priced for the quality and portion size of the food. Boathouse clearly the better choice.

 

[EmilyGahr]

100% the Boathouse no question! Went there in 2019 and it was amazing. We were deciding between Boathouse and Paddlefish for our trip this past January, and decided to try Paddlefish since we had never been... biggest mistake! Food was not great and overpriced, atmosphere was very disappointing. Will 100% choose Boathouse every time!

 

[han22735]

Boathouse is the better choice. But we sat on the roof of paddlefish and had apps and drinks and it was great.

 

[seven dwarfs]

The boathouse for sure. We have been several times and it is always great. Great food, great service and great drinks.

 

[The Mayor]

Boathouse hands down. One of our favorite restaurants and in my opinion, one of the best on Disney property.

 

[Mousetopia]

Thank you all! Boathouse it is. Reservation already made via Open table for december