Overweight children -- a vent (and yes, I know I'm going to get flamed)

OP, thanks so much for putting your son's medical issues out there for the world to read! I found them very interesting and can easily see how his past feeding problems can contribute to improper signals for him now when he eats. Many of us learn our food coping skills as young children. That's the time when many of us learn to become emotional eaters and, unfortunately, that behavior sticks and is very hard to get past.

Your son sounds as if he has problems discerning when he is hungry and when he is full. It seems these sketchy signals can probably lead him into overeating at many of his meals.

And for what it's worth, I don't think most children's excess weight comes from the occasional birthday party or pizza party. It's all right to have those once in a while. But it's the everyday stuff that's important for you to monitor.

This is a great statement. I think, based on what you've stated, I'd keep doing what you're doing in trying to make what you eat at home healthier. I also probably work on portion control with him and showing him what is an appropriate amount of food for someone his age and size. I totally wouldn't worry about parties but would just discuss with him that ONE piece of cake and he should stop. Two pieces of pizza and he should stop. I remember from some of my son's birthday parties, some kids would come back for more and more cake. I had another boy who was a BIG kid (mainly tall but overweight) and he drank all the drinks at the party--I mean sucked them down like he was having a six pack of beer on a Friday night and had almost a whole pizza to himself.

As for school lunches, do you know if he is buying stuff he shouldn't. My coworker's son ended up overspending his lunch funds because he was buying Gatorade and Vitamin waters on the side when his parents told him not to. Both parents are extremely overweight and are very concerned with his weight. They ended up having to cut off his lunch card so they could control his food more at school.
 
Childhood weight is a bit of a mystery..

My DD 10 (almost 11) is listed on the BMI as being obese. Except she is not.
She is pudgy, not even chubby.
The doctor told us to cut her meals in half and get her to exercise.
Oddly enough, she barely eats at all, eats mostly salad and fruit, and when he gave us the order for exercise, she was active in both competitive swimming (10 hours in the pool a week) as well as competitive dance (Jazz, Tap, Acro, Musical Theatre, Ballet) for 10 hours a week.

thats 20 hours a week of exercise.
She is solid. There is MUSCLE under the pudge.

So what do we do? put a 11 year old girl that is super active on a 450 calorie diet?!?!?!
 
I don't see why you are assuming the OP doesn't send her son with food. She said he eats away from home, so she doesn't get to monitor what actually goes into his mouth. Believe me, if you saw what goes on in school lunchrooms and wherever kids eat together, and how much of the carefully-chosen healthy food sent by moms goes into the trash, and how much junk gets purchased or traded for in its place, you'd know what she means.

I understand exactly what the OP means. She knows there's a problem, she worries about the problem, she worries about the best way to guide her son through the problem. But the problem she's venting about isn't the difficulty of the road they're travelling... it's the lack of respect people show towards total strangers because of their weight.

It is simply rude to offer dirty looks, annoyed comments about "Some people...", free unsought advice, or any other kind of treatment that is less respectful than you would give to someone who is not overweight, especially if you do not even see the unsavory behavior you're attributing to them (stuffing their faces with unhealthy food and not exercising).

Northstar I love it ;) finally someone understands what the OP means,I couldn't of said it better.
 
I've known many families where one child out of three or four has a weight issue. Obviously not totally a parenting issue.

This is our family. I have 3 sons. Two are skinny as a rail and my poor middle son battles with weight. My husband and I are not overweight, however, I have family members that are obese (so I think the gene comes from my side of the family).

We have been very lucky since our doctor a few years ago (our son was about 13 at the time) recommended us to a weight clinic for children. We go once a month and learn about weight, exercise and nutrition. It has been a tough ride. We have dramatically changed our house to revolve around my son's health problem. I say health problem because his weight has now affected his blood pressure.

I have found out that parenting a child that has weight issues is a tough one. You don't want to be the constant "nag" and worry about hurting their self esteem and have them eat emotionally ... but on the other hand, I can't stand by and let him "kill himself slowly".

If this post helps at all, I have found that over the last 2 years, my son has still gained a little weight ... but not nearly as much as he would have if we didn't go to the weight clinic. I have also found that my son has to help himself and internalize his goal to lose weight. In the last few months, I think we have finally found his motivation since he has not been allowed to lift weights for football ... until his blood pressure is under control ... which means losing weight. (He has lost 7 pounds and has about 15 more to go! :cool1:)

So, I am sending many, many hugs to you and your family :hug::hug::hug:. This is going to be hard for all of you and I am so sorry you are hurting from it.

No flames or judging from me ... I know how hard this is.
 
No flames OP...none at all. :hug:

I have 5 kids. 4 are average, one is overweight. The boy walks to and from school, runs instead of walks EVERYWHERE, eats pretty healthy compared to his siblings (he actually enjoys salad and veggies and fruit), but he's chubby. My eldest was also chubby, and now is a 5' 10 " 15 year old.

I have seen a nutritionist for my 9 year old. They said we are doing everything right. He eats healthy, and is active. I think that my pediatrician's office puts too much emphasis on the BMI charts....every child is different. My 9 year old is definitely heavy. Yes. My dd who is 6 is not. According to the BMI chart, her height to weight ratio says that she is. The doctor didn't even look at her when telling me that she was fat. :headache:

My kids see my dh and I eating well, and going to exercise daily. My 9 year old wants to go, but is too young to go with beyond hanging out in the kid's room. He knows he's bigger than some of the other kids, and we are trying to help in non hurtful, non judgemental ways. Our pediatric practice is not very good about making sure they don't put the child down in front of said child. Until you have to deal with it either with yourself or one of your kids, thinking it's as simple as getting off your rear and moving and eating vegetables is not always the answer.


Not for nothing...you need a new pediatric group ASAP! I wouldn't accept that attitude/behavior from a doctor ever.
 
This is such an emotionally loaded issue that I thought about creating a new user name and doing this anonymously, but I decided that that's just contributing to the problem I'm venting about, so I'm going to go ahead and do it. I know I'm going to get flamed, but I feel like I have to say what I'm going to say.

I'm sick and tired of the level of judgement that is becoming so prevalent in society against overweight children and their families, and I'm hoping that maybe by venting a little here, people can see another perspective.

My 11 year old is overweight -- not, technically obese as his BMI isn't quite that high, but well into the "overweight" range. You can tell by looking at him, that he could stand to lose some weight. When we go out in public it breaks my heart when I can tell people are looking at him and judging him by this one feature, and not seeing the bright, funny, kind, creative person that he is. I also feel like they judge me, like they look at my child and assume that I let him sit on the couch in front of the TV and eat potato chips all day. I've read some forums or places that are supposed to offer support and people feel entitled to jump in and post horrible things to parents who are looking for help for their children. I've even seen posts where people have tickers saying that they weigh 300 plus pounds, and have only lost a few, and yet they are incredibly judgemental of parents. You'd think

The thing I wish is that people would get that this is a complicated issue. My son's a good example of this phenomena. He's had a history of medical issues when he was younger that have likely made it harder for him to know when he's hungry and when he's full, plus he's taken some medications that can impact a child's appetite and growth. He's also got asthma and allergies, that slow him down at certain times of the year.

But even beyond that, the messages that society gives parents about weight loss is very confusing. I get the message that I'm responsible for everything he eats, but in reality, like most kids his age, he eats about 1/2 his meals and snacks away from home -- at school, or camp, or on the sidelines of a sports practice, or at a friend's house or grandma's. There's also a lot of consensus in the literature you read about childhood weightloss that you shouldn't forbid foods, or be controlling, or talk to your child about their weight -- but it's challenging to control what your child eats in their absence without doing those things. I get the message that physical exercise is crucial and screen time is bad, but also that pushing your child too hard is bad, and that kids need downtime. Self-esteem is also important, and sometimes I'm choosing between something that he loves (like going to a friends house, even though I know he'll be playing video games there, or letting him be involved in the school play, even though the practices conflict with Tae Kwon Do). When people criticize parents of overweight kids, they make it seem like it's just "follow the yellow brick road" or "love your child enough to do the right thing" but that doesn't reflect the fact that sometimes the road isn't bright yellow, it covered with brambles and hard to see, and sometimes loving your child isn't enough to see the way. All of these issues would be present even if we didn't have the medical issues that we do.

I've been worried enough about this issue, that today I went to an appointment with a therapist/nutritionist who specializes in this issue. I brought his weight chart, but didn't bring him. Her basic message was that we're actually doing great. Kids with his history often end up morbidly obese, and he isn't. His BMI has been stable for several years at an age when many kid's weight gain is accelerating. He eats a wide variety of food including at least 5 servings of different fruit and veggies a day. We never have food battles, I put healthy food on the table and he chooses what and how much he wants and ends up with a healthy mix of foods. He's physically active with sports camps in the summer, PE and recreational sports leagues during the school year, plus he walks the dog daily and we do things like hiking, biking, ice skating, and swimming. She says all of that is way more important than a number on the scale, and other than scheduling a snack each afternoon (so he doesn't end up starving and binging) we should just continue as we're doing. Anyway, it was really good to hear this because I feel like usually the message I get is that I must be dong wrong.

My Cousin's son was a big kid. Pudgy, not massively fat, but he was obese for being 8 years old. Tubby. Today he is 6'4" 225 lbs and the starting tight-end on his football team. He's 14. We all grow differently. I could never put on weight or muscle when I was a kid. At 35, that all changed. Now I'm about 30lbs overweight (60 over what I was in HS, but I can put on muscle if I work out. We change. It's also very hereditary.
 
OP, I'm not going to flame you, but I am going to admit that I am very judgemental of a few families that I know becuase they are not like you. They ignore their children's weight issue, they contribute to it, at the same time complaining about it. There are no underlying medical problems in these familes (at least none that they know about). I also believe that is another reason why obesity in kids is running rampant, its because of parents like in the families I know. I'm not saying I judge everyone that way, I know there are other things to take into account like genetics and health conditions and that everyone who is overweight cannot help it. I just happen to know people who can, and I have no problem judging them.
 
No flames here as you come across a caring parent. I know how people judge anyone who is different, be it overweight, handicapped, too tall, too short etc.

If you are concerned about his health though, make it a family effort to be more active and have healthy options for all meals. I understand your point about giving children choices and my children choose their snacks every day. They can have yogurt, fruit, cheese or pretzels for example. Very different textures and tastes but all relatively healthy choices. Birthday parties are celebrations and of course you shouldn't send carrot sticks, but if you have healthy options rest of the time, no big deal (no pun intended).

Childhood obesity is so much more than how a child looks. It puts a child at a greater risk for so many diseases and health conditions. It's not too late to focus on health, not weight.
 
No, you do not need to send carrot sticks and a chicken breast to a birthday party. What you need to do is talk to your son about making the right choices before the party. Tell him WHY cake would not be good for him at this point and time. He is 11 not 2. He can live without having a piece of cake and not end up having a meltdown like a toddler. Feed him BEFORE the party so he isn't hungry there. Or, what I always did is find out what they were having at the party and send the safe version for my son when he was little. If they are having pizza (the favorite of most parties) make him a whole wheat pizza, sans cheese or just a sprinkle and some veggies. Now that my son is 13, he could care less about the food. He eats ahead of time and is fine. The only problem he has is when the party is at a restaurant and all they are doing is eating (they aren't bowling, playing video games, etc). That seems to be the common theme now. He just doesn't go. He will survive. He can hang out another day. It really isn't the end of the world.

Making her son a different pizza IS singling him out as is making him turn down the birthday cake.

Your child has allergies, and cannot eat what the other kids eat. That is a whole different world than an overweight child.

An overweight child LOOKS different from the other kids and FEELS different from the other kids. They have to bend over backwards to even slightly fit in. The certainly do not need to add "eats different" to the list. There is no reason why he cannot have the same foods the other kids are eating. A birthday party now and then does not make someone overweight.

OP, you will get no flames from me at all.

I have a weight problem, dd does not at this time. She "has a stomach" as several well meaning relatives have pointed out to me (but not to her THANK goodness!). I have not changed what she eats, I have upped the exercise. Since I need to walk every day, she rides her bike with me. She also swims most days and works out with the Wii some. I do make sure fruits and veggies are offered at every meal and eating fast food is limited to one meal a week. If she goes to someone's house or to a party--I do not mention what she needs to eat or not eat. Sometimes when we are cooking supper, we talk about choices and what foods are better for you and why. I also limit the snacks and drinks most of the time, we do have plenty around when her friends come over though so she has all that then.

I think one of the main things is to not make food a struggle at this point. Have more healthy options, cut out a lot the junk food at home but I sure wouldn't make him feel deprived at all or make him feel like he has to be different from the other kids.
 
Making her son a different pizza IS singling him out as is making him turn down the birthday cake.

Your child has allergies, and cannot eat what the other kids eat. That is a whole different world than an overweight child.

An overweight child LOOKS different from the other kids and FEELS different from the other kids. They have to bend over backwards to even slightly fit in. The certainly do not need to add "eats different" to the list. There is no reason why he cannot have the same foods the other kids are eating. A birthday party now and then does not make someone overweight.

I am not saying that allergies and being overweight are the same. I am saying that a true food allergy can be life threatening and, as a parent, I will go to any length to educate and protect my son. I think a truly obese child (not a child that is slightly pudgy) can also be life threatening and, as a parent, I would again go to any length to educate and protect my child.
 
It sounds like you recognize there is a problem and are working on it with him by offering healthy foods and encouraging exersize. It sounds like you are heading in the right direction. I'm so sorry for the rude comments and glares your son gets from strangers (and not-so strangers). I can't stand the thought of your sons self esteem being dampened by rude people:(.
I love the one posters example of her and her college friend eating and exersizing the same, yet one being skinny and one being overweight. Genetics and all sorts of factors often play into weight.
I have 5 children. They come from the same two parents, they eat the same foods, and get the same amount of exersize. Two of them are tall and skinny. Two of them are short and skinny. And one is tall and hefty. He is not obese and I'm not even sure he is considered overweight, I think his BMI is still in the "average/normal" range; but he is clearly built differently than the others. He just turned 13 last month and wears a mens shoe size 11, he is about 5'6 and 130 pounds. He is not fat, but is clearly built big- like an in-shape football player.
I could say the same about teeth- All of my kids are made to brush their teeth the same amount. Two have never, ever had cavaties, One has had one cavaty ever. One has the occasional cavity, and one has a cavity every single time we go! She brushes her teeth plenty good- I think some people are simply more prone to cavaties and she is one of them......
I also think some people are more prone to being overweight...... Those people have to work harder than the average person to keep the weight off and it sucks, but it's just the luck of the draw sometimes and I hate that other people view this so negatively.......
I wish the best for you and your son.....
 
If it's mainly dna how to you account for the explosion in childhood obesity? DNA does not drastically change like that?
In 1980 only 7% of kids were obese. Now it's almost 20%. No way would you see that type of genetic mutation in under 1 generation, if I remember my college biology correctly.
http://www.cdc.gov/HealthyYouth/obesity/


[/I][/B]


I disagree. Think about how young children are starting puberty now adays compared to a generation or two ago. Things change..... I definately think the modern lifestyle of television and video games, and fast food plays into it, but genetics are certainly a big part of it.
 
I disagree. Think about how young children are starting puberty now adays compared to a generation or two ago. Things change..... I definately think the modern lifestyle of television and video games, and fast food plays into it, but genetics are certainly a big part of it.

Genetics plays a big deal in whether a particular person will become obese, but changes in genes can't explain the rapid rise in obesity over the last 50 years. Genes don't evolve that quickly.
 
I disagree. Think about how young children are starting puberty now adays compared to a generation or two ago. Things change..... I definately think the modern lifestyle of television and video games, and fast food plays into it, but genetics are certainly a big part of it.


That's not genetics, that's the hormones and steroids in our food supply.
 
You said your son's BMI is in the overweight range but not obese. I really wonder how many people are judging him or making comments. I don't think it's as many as you think.
 
I am not saying that allergies and being overweight are the same. I am saying that a true food allergy can be life threatening and, as a parent, I will go to any length to educate and protect my son. I think a truly obese child (not a child that is slightly pudgy) can also be life threatening and, as a parent, I would again go to any length to educate and protect my child.

We all know that it can be life threatening to be obese. The problem with some of the things you are saying is that they do not take into consideration the mental and emotional aspects of the effects of being overweight.

If her child is overweight, small changes may need to be made but IMHO some of the things you are suggesting would be going overboard. He does not need his mother's total control over his food, that may help teach a child with allergies to certain foods, it does not help someone who is overweight.

At this point he is only a bit overweight, there may be no mental or emotional issues going on with it and the weight may fall off as he gets taller (dd has two boys in her class that this has happened with in the past two years) but if mom suddenly starts controlling every bite he puts in his mouth, it will turn on both of them and can lead to a life long weight problem.
 
BMI does nothing to distinguish muscle from fat and any doctor who determines a child is overweight or obese (not the OP, but others on this thread) just by the chart and not looking at the child, should not be consulted again.

Being thin does not equal being healthy and being fat, overweight, or anything else you can call me, does not equal being unhealthy. I have no ill effects, am quite strong and exercise regularly. If I was naturally thin and had the same regiment, no one would judge me.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom