There was another thread about e-ring insurance on here awhile back. The consensus was to definitely get it insured. Insurance will give you the money to get another ring and whether your ring was $500 or $50,000 it's still money that you don't want to lose and pay twice. You'll need a certified appraisal, which isn't cheap, but it will give you every detail on your e-ring, including pictures. My insurance company told me to get a separate policy for my e-ring. That way, if we're ever dropped (we live in FL and homeowners insurance companies drop people all the time) or we leave them, or move, we won't have any lapse in coverage. So, we have a completely separate jewelry policy for my e-ring. I'm covered 100% for loss, theft, mugging (Heaven forbid!), or if the stone gets damaged. It makes me feel better to have the insurance, knowing if something did happen it can be replaced.