KrazyPete
skeleton
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2006
- Messages
- 2,161
I don't really like the Booth/Pinocchio theory. I have to admit that it's possible. Anything is possible when Rumpel is the Beast and Red Riding Hood is the Big Bad Wolf.
But, don't you think that if Pinocchio had been transported at the same time as Emma then the story would have been "Infant and Young Boy Found on Roadside" instead of "Boy Finds Baby?" The origin of the boy who found the baby should have been just as mysterious as the baby itself. To fix that problem you have to theorize that Pinocchio was transported into the real world enough in advance of Emma so that the story of his own mysterious appearance had faded. That gets a little convoluted for me buy it.
Then you have the character of Pinocchio in the story. He's kind of weak character. He makes some bad decisions, he redeems himself, but he's not really heroic. Our mysterious stranger seems like a different kind of person entirely.
Anyway, no offense to anyone who thinks otherwise. That's just my perspective on it.
But, don't you think that if Pinocchio had been transported at the same time as Emma then the story would have been "Infant and Young Boy Found on Roadside" instead of "Boy Finds Baby?" The origin of the boy who found the baby should have been just as mysterious as the baby itself. To fix that problem you have to theorize that Pinocchio was transported into the real world enough in advance of Emma so that the story of his own mysterious appearance had faded. That gets a little convoluted for me buy it.
Then you have the character of Pinocchio in the story. He's kind of weak character. He makes some bad decisions, he redeems himself, but he's not really heroic. Our mysterious stranger seems like a different kind of person entirely.
Anyway, no offense to anyone who thinks otherwise. That's just my perspective on it.
