Okay, we're starting to hear from the jurors.

I have to agee with you.



More than half the respondents didn't know what they were talking about. Given the disclaimer being ignorant of the facts still makes you special ;)

If the respondents were regular Joe's, people who weren't following every detail of the case, that probably represents most Americans. Which means there are far less people joining Facebook petitions, boycott Casey petitions, etc. than the lynch mob is hoping for. Many people just don't care what she does with her life when she gets out next week. Buy her book - don't buy her book - no biggie in the scheme of most people's lives.
 
It means that their decision is more reliably correct than any objection to their decision. That's about as close as human beings can get to "correct".

No, not at all. I understand that you don't like the results of the poll, though.

How can that be, if by the jurors own mouths; that they weren't aware there were other charges she could have been convicted for, other than Murder 1 with the Death penalty?
 
If the respondents were regular Joe's, people who weren't following every detail of the case, that probably represents most Americans. Which means there are far less people joining Facebook petitions, boycott Casey petitions, etc. than the lynch mob is hoping for. Many people just don't care what she does with her life when she gets out next week. Buy her book - don't buy her book - no biggie in the scheme of most people's lives.

What's your point?

Mine was the poll was mostly fools who think just because the can vote they should vote.

I know I don't go around voting in polls and offering opinions on subject matter I know little or nothing about.
 
No she didn't. Her defense was her father did something with the body

Right.

If she had said/admitted that she dumped the body at the woods, this trial would have gone in a different direction.

How can that be, if by the jurors own mouths; that they weren't aware there were other charges she could have been convicted for, other than Murder 1 with the Death penalty?

Wow, if that's true, then they completely misunderstood what they would supposed to be doing. But I don't see how that's possible. All charges and possible convictions were listed right ther on the jury form.
 
Yes but again , something people do not get. With a death penalty case the jury must be death qualified. After the initial voir dire and no objections were made by the attorneys, Each juror was questioned at length and asked if they would have any issue with the do. They were asked if they could issue a verdict regardless of the possible penalty. Each one answered yes . If they didn't , they were disqualified. The fact that this comes into play says more about these jurors.

yes it does say a whole lot.

Let's face it......Most of us on these boards put more time and effort into our Disney vacations than these jurors did with the deliberations. Barely any of them took notes, they did not ask the judge any questions, ask to see any evidence again, etc.

You have a point. I really don't understand not asking questions, asking for clarifications of the charges SOMETHING that would show they were considering all possiblities.


:thumbsup2 ITA

How can that be, if by the jurors own mouths; that they weren't aware there were other charges she could have been convicted for, other than Murder 1 with the Death penalty?

Sounds like someone wasn't listening to those directions? Again, says a lot about the jury.
 
Can somebody with some knowlege about legalities in the state of Florida please tell us - Can the jury take the death penalty off the table???

It has always been my understanding (could be wrong in this case) that the jury was there to decide guilt or innocence... convict or aquit....

I have never heard of a jury sentencing.

Thanks!

The jury recommends the death penalty (or LWOP) in Murder 1 cases where the death penalty is relevant, during the penalty phase (after deliberations/conviction). Florida is actually one of the few states that allows the jury to recommend the death penalty when the decision is NOT unanimous.

The Judge actually would hand down sentencing and can (though it's rare) ignore the jury recommendation.

So yes, technically the jury only decides guilt or innocence...though they do play a part in sentencing for Murder 1 cases.

There's actually some debate about form and function of the jury involvement going on, in Florida, right now:

http://www.miamiherald.com/2011/06/22/2279518/miami-federal-judge-floridas-death.html
 
Right.

If she had said/admitted that she dumped the body at the woods, this trial would have gone in a different direction.



Wow, if that's true, then they completely misunderstood what they would supposed to be doing. But I don't see how that's possible. All charges and possible convictions were listed right ther on the jury form.

I'm still confused about something: if the jury seems not to have understood the directions about choosing the relevant charge, then how on earth did they end up split 6-6 on manslaughter at one point??? Manslaughter was not the original charge brought, it was one of the options they could have stepped down to. How come they got as far as taking a poll and being 6-6 on manslaughter, yet #3 comes out afterwards and pretty much says they couldn't convict for such a high charge as murder 1?
 
How can that be, if by the jurors own mouths
These people aren't trained and talented communicators. Attacking them for not saying the words you'd find pleasing is indefensible.

I'm convinced that people who hate the verdict are going to disparage the jurors no matter what they say, no matter what they did. It's just a reflection of the default disrespect many Americans adopt for people they choose not to like. For many people, now, it's all a matter of satisfying the blood-thirst that the coverage of the trial fostered. And these same folks are the ones who would have just as readily praised the jurors, for doing the exact same work, if they had come back with the verdict that those folks wanted.
 
These people aren't trained and talented communicators. Attacking them for not saying the words you've find pleasing is indefensible.

They also aren't sitting behind keyboards where they have the advantage of anonymity and the backspace key.
 
I'm still confused about something: if the jury seems not to have understood the directions about choosing the relevant charge, then how on earth did they end up split 6-6 on manslaughter at one point??? Manslaughter was not the original charge brought, it was one of the options they could have stepped down to. How come they got as far as taking a poll and being 6-6 on manslaughter, yet #3 comes out afterwards and pretty much says they couldn't convict for such a high charge as murder 1?

Actually ,they were 6-6 on Count 3 which was manslaughter

That said, for Count 1, which included the Murder 1 option, they ALSO had the choice to go with Manslaugher.

Here is the verdict form:
http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/2011/images/07/04/verdict.forms.pdf#

Here is the indictment:
http://www.foxnews.com/projects/pdf/Anthony_Indictment.PDF
 
Right.

If she had said/admitted that she dumped the body at the woods, this trial would have gone in a different direction.



Wow, if that's true, then they completely misunderstood what they would supposed to be doing. But I don't see how that's possible. All charges and possible convictions were listed right ther on the jury form.

I was just reading the story from the juror's appearance on GMA. It sounded to me like the jury found the story of an accidental drowning combined with a panicked cover-up/disposal to be plausible. In the absence of more definitive evidence that constituted reasonable doubt for them.

So, if they believed the death to have been truly accidental and there were no charges levied for improper disposal of the corpse, then the lesser charges (manslaughter) were equally inapplicable to the actions of the defendent. Thus, not guilty. While I understand that not everyone agrees with that, it is an understandable explanation for their findings.
 
They also aren't sitting behind keyboards where they have the advantage of anonymity and the backspace key.

True, but you better bet your bottom dollar that if I were selling my story to be played nationally and heck, in today's time, internationally, I would make sure I had the right words ready.

I find it more telling when people speak off the cuff, you get a clearer picture of their true feelings.
 
These people aren't trained and talented communicators. Attacking them for not saying the words you've find pleasing is indefensible.

how many different ways are there to say it? they can speak in coherent sentences can't they?

"If they charged her with other things, we probably could have gotten a guilty verdict, absolutely," Ford said today on "Good Morning America." "But not for death, not for first-degree murder. That's a very substantial charge."

That is the quote the poster is referring to (bolding mine). I am not sure how many other ways one can try and understand it??? :confused3 The bolded part says it all.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom