Oh my! She looks awful!

[MosMom]

Wow, the front one is even worse.

 

[goofyforlife]

And I don't think double-sticky tape is a good substitute for a good bra.

Like she needs one..... There nothing there.....

Quick give this girl something to eat

 

[GoodFairies]

I thought she had always been that skinny, but she did used to be more muscular.

 

[drgnfly30]

Someone give the girl a sandwich! Yikes!!

 

[BeckWhy]

This is getting rediculus (sp hahah). You got her, Nicole Richie (not saying that kids should look up to her), Lindsey Lohan, etc etc etc. I remember seeing a thing on tv and it was Nicole Richie and Lindsey Lohan and all they kept saying to each other is "OMG You are so skinny" "No you are way skinnier than me" and thats all they said to each on and on.

But many none of these girls really do have an eating disorder.... maybe they are high on coke or meth.

*shudders* EWWWW.... Either way is horrible.

 

[MorganLeFey]

definitely too thin.

and for all that the gown is Gucci, it's awful too.

 

[AllyandJack]

Maybe she's naturally thin...but, for the love of God, know your body and wear something to flatter it.

 

[milkabum]

Next time please post a printable photo-sickness bag.

 

[Maleficent13]

Maybe she's naturally thin...but, for the love of God, know your body and wear something to flatter it.

This was my first thought too...

 

[MosMom]

I think the dress accentuates her lack of figure and isn't really a good choice for her. I looked at some pictures from her in Bend it like Beckham and she is really thin back then too...

http://www.keiraknightleypalace.com/bendbeckham.asp

Look at the bottom left one of her in a sports bra with her stomach showing. Pretty thin there too. Most of her pictures don't have her looking that thin...I just think that gown makes her look awful. I've never heard anorexia mentioned about her until now and probably because of that gown.

 

[phorsenuf]

Here's another picture. She doesn't look as thin, but I don't know when it was taken. Looking at some pics of her though, it doesn't seem she was always this thin.

 

[Gaspode]

I'm really glad that no one just assumed "eating disorder" when my sisters and I were younger. We were all skin and bones for years--just the way my family is, my mom and dad were the same way.

Does anyone have a picture of her looking heavier than this or is this what she's always looked like? I guess I could understand it better if this was a sudden change like Lindsay Lohan.

I am very slim. Always have been. So I'm not one to go around assuming people have eating disorders or calling them out for being "too thin" etc cos' I've had some of that said to me all my life.

But, imho, there is a difference, and imho once again, Keira, in those pictures, sadly seems to have crossed that line.

As I said in my first post, either she has an eating disorder or is very ill in some other way. For example a very close friend of mine has recently (for the second time in her life) been through some very traumatic things and convinced herself she wasn't worthy of food. She started to starve herself. Very distressing. Not an eating disorder in the sense we all automatically think of (anorexia/bulemia) but an eating disorder of sorts, and one rooted firmly in what else had happened to her and how she thought of herself. (Thank God she is on medication to help now and eating once again)

Anyway, I truly feel for Keira and believe she needs help, one way or another.

Here she is looking slim but, imho, healthier:

So yes, she's always been slim but now, imho, has crossed a line and is unhealthily so - for whatever reason.

- Gaspodé

PS. Sorry for all the 'imhos'

 

[Crankyshank]

I don't think she has an eating disorder. All of the pictures of her show her body looking pretty much the same. She also doesn't have the lollipop head look going for her.

I think she's naturally thin, is wearing a bad dress for her figure, and probably lost a few pounds from stress (filming all those movies back to back plus doing the press junket has to be incredibly stressful).

 

[JohnMouse]

I don't like what Keira wore at the Pirates opening in London. I thought she looked like a princess in that white dress at the Pirates opening at DL-she looked like Belle a little bit.

 

[DisneyAddict_M]

Yeah, she could be just naturally thin. I think she's always looked similar to that. My dbf looks like he could have an eating disorder...his collar bone, hip bones and ribs all stick out prominently and he's basically all skin and bones. I know for a fact he doesn't have any kind of disorder...he just has a really fast metabolism.

I'm not saying she doesn't have a disorder, just that we can't tell for sure.

 

[CheshireVal]

I think she's always been really thin, but that dress is just super unflattering.

 

[Blondie]

She should fire whoever told her to wear that dress.

And if she picked it out, she needs help with decision making.

It appears like she's a naturally thin woman. Maybe she's lost a few pounds for whatever the reason (stress, etc.) Losing a few pounds for her would make a big difference.

 

[phorsenuf]

Well, with how she looks in that dress I can understand all the speculation.
What was she thinking? Doesn't she have a full-length mirror??

 

[SandraVB79]

She looks scary-thin. I have only seen her act in POTC 1, and I can't remember from that one that she is THAT thin.

Quick, give her a Monte Christo!! That should help

 

[JulyGirl]