Book him. We loved him too. Neither hubby nor I have ever attended church and therefore didn't want a ceremony with any religious references. He gave us a very nice ceremony based all around love. We looked at a few and I have to agree with Lindsay that he seemed very cool and very us. We were quite stressed and very late for our rehearsal but he was super nice and relaxing. Joked with our planner all through the rehearsal. He asked us what we would like him to wear for the ceremony and looked great in his beige pants and white top (for the beach). Yes, it was a little stressful that we didn't hear from him until a couple weeks before the wedding to finalize the ceremony, but I was prepared for that (from what I'd read on here). He was a great choice for our day.