Hey all!! Just back last night from our vacation! We got a custom cake at both GFC and CR. I will post pictures some time this week of the cakes.
GFC - I checked in and asked about the cake. There was nothing on our ADR and it took them FOREVER to find it in the back. They did bring it out eventually. Corbin's birthday cake wasn't what I was picturing in my mind. I ordered a Cars themed cake and a vanilla mini-castle cake for DMIL. What we got was a Cars themed cake with vanilla and chocolate fondant. The Cars picture was a stand up on chocolate of all of the Cars from the movie. That part was very cool. It wasn't very "kiddie" though-very grown up looking. Would have liked something a bit more fun. As for DMIL's castle cake, it was a cheesecake one-not what I'd ordered. It worked out. She enjoyed it.
CR - Here I'd ordered a vanilla cake with white buttercream in a Nemo
theme. After getting the first cake, I really wasn't sure what to expect. They seated us and gave everyone their personalized menus and soon after getting our drinks the divers swam over and showed the boys their signs. The large turtle laid at the front of the tank almost our entire meal. DS1 just kept pointing and yelling "Crush! Crush!!" and "Shishes!!!! Shishes!!" (fish) I would eat here again just for the atmosphere! We finished out dinner and the waiter brought out the cake at the perfect time with candles lit and everything! DS4 blew out the candles all by himself (this is huge for him-he's NEVER done that before!!!) and excitedly cut the cake. This was a much more traditional styled cake that I'd pictured in my mind.
Out of the two, CR was much less of a hassle to get the cake and the presentation was amazing! DMIL and I both liked this cake better than the GF cake. (I'm pretty picky though!). DH preferred the GFC cake over the CR. DS4 loved both of them
Overall, I'll order a cake for our December trip for DS1's birthday somewhere along the trip for sure!! Maybe try GF again and be more specific about being a child themed cake.
Both places boxed/wrapped the cake up for us (CR did not have boxes but the waiter wrapped it in foil and shaped it like a swan-amazingly this held up VERY well until my husbadn closed the van door on the cake!

) We just put it in the bottom of the stroller and went about visiting the parks. Wtih GFC, we left it in the van for a couple of hours before going back to our room. It was in the high 80s/low 90s so the fondant was beginning to melt when we got back to the car. After CR, we wandered the park for a bit longer and the cake was perfectly fine when getting back to the room.
I took plastic containers to store both of the left over cakes int he fridge. Our fridge was NOT big enough (one from ASSp) so I put the cake in there over night with the door open a little crack so it got cooled off then left it on the table by the air conditioner the rest of our time there. It came home with us and is in the fridge now, probably to be finished tonight!
Oh....(sorry for the VERY long ramble!!!) the CR waitier even gave us our desserts to go since they're included with the plan!

I've got three chocolate wave desserts in my fridge too!! I'm going to be one sugared up woman this week!!
Overall, I'd totally order the cakes again no question just being much more specific about what I wanted.
Also, it's a good thing I helped stir the pixie dust because DH and DS4 got NOTHING anywhere else we went.