Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[totalia]

I thought Scott looked creepy/scary from the beginning. There is just something about him that gives me the creeps. I tried to like him. But, he really makes me uneasy.

I so completely agree. I don't like him. There's something about him that just says "I'm going to hit you" and has right from the beginning.

 

[totalia]

I don't even consider it when I decide who gets my vote. I don't care if he did it more than once. I vote for whose voice I like, no whose past is morally up my alley. I find it disturbing that you jump on these threads to continually harrass people for their opinions.

*sighs* Thats what people always say when they don't like the other persons opinions. Nice try.

 

[totalia]

You're right. But it also doesn't mean it's NOT the only time he did. Here in the United States, you're supposed to be innocent until proven guilty.

lol. And we both know what the reality is don't we (no matter how right or wrong it is)?

 

[Nancy]

I was a little surprised at the results of voting percentages that were posted. Wow...Bo was way down there....and Carrie had a big lead.

 

[snoopy]

Why do people care who likes who? I can never understand that about these threads and the message boards devoted to American Idol. Who cares? I like who I like, you like who you like.

I'm VERY surprised to see that list. Is that valid? Although I'm not surprised to see Carrie at the top of it...she seems like she has that wholesome thing going on....people are going to vote for her whether she's the most talented or not. My personal favorite is now Constantine for his versaility, Anwar for his raw talent and likeability, and Bo just because I think he has the whole package. Do I care that other people don't like my choices? Nope! Not one bit.

 

[Planogirl]

Bo didn't do so well the last few weeks so I'm not totally surprised that his percentage was so low this time. It seems weird though because I could not get through when I called for him. I hope that he does much better next week and people vote for him in far greater numbers.

I am surprised to see Carrie so high though. I like her but she seems kind of bland and I never thought that her country style would appeal to so many people.

I also don't care if people don't like my choices. That's the nice thing about shows like these, we can all decide who we prefer regardless of what anyone else thinks.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

I was very surprised by the bottom 3, and shocked to see Nikko go! I expected to see Scott, Anthony, and Anwar on the stage, with Scott going home. IMHO, Vonzell is normally one of the strongest performers (though the musical theme seemed to be tough on everybody this week). Also, I thought Nikko did pretty well.

I really expect Scott to be going home within the next 2 weeks, partly because it seems that alot of people are having trouble getting over his past. Personally, while I don't approve of what he did, I try not to judge. However, I have to agree that his performances have been rather lackluster lately. He looked shocked last night when Ryan told him he was safe; I think he expected to be sent home.

I liked Bo's and Anthony's honesty when Ryan asked them what they thought of their performances. Both agreed with Simon that they didn't do very well, and seemed surprised that they weren't in the bottom 3.

I'm still sticking with Nadia, Carrie, or Bo as the winner, though Constantine seems to be picking up some steam lately.

 

[ekmdisney]

I didn't watch the first three seasons but I have read on here that someone named Frenchie was kicked off because she posed topless.

Frenchie, did NOT pose topless. She posed in BBW sexy under things, for a sexy underwear web site. SHE HAD CLOTHES ON! But becaue she was young, and didn't know any better, she signed a contract with the photographer, that said they could use the pics any old way. SOOO the pics showed up on another web site, that not all the people were wearing clothes. Yes, some of those people were topless and bottomless. But because Frencie's pic showed up on the site, even though she didn't pose for the site, the producers of AI said that she had to go.

But the last I heard she was doing alright. She is in a production of RENT on or just off Broadway. Which is were her really great and strong voice should be...on BROADWAY! But I'm still hoping a CD will show up soon.

 

[StaceyA]

But the last I heard she was doing alright. She is in a production of RENT on or just off Broadway. Which is were her really great and strong voice should be...on BROADWAY! But I'm still hoping a CD will show up soon.

As far as I know she is in the on broadway production of Rent, and doing a heck of a job at it!!

 

[StaceyA]

I'm VERY surprised to see that list. Is that valid?

I saw that list last night on the website someone mentioned www.idolforums.com I'm pretty sure that is a rumor, or should I say that it isn't put out there by Fox, so we don't know if it is exactly Valid or not.

 

[julia & nicks mom]

I'm VERY surprised to see that list. Is that valid?

The list can't be valid b/c it shows Scott with the least number of votes

 

[orangeblossom]

Yes, it can be...it's for the 48 contiguous United States.

 

[tae1218]

My 5 year old loves Anthony. If I did vote I would have to vote for him because of how excited he gets when he sees Anthony. I love to see him dance when Anthony sings and for that reason I would vote for Anthony.

My DD loves Anthony too. She usually wants to vote for him but she chose to have me call and vote for Constantine instead. But she did like Anthony's outfit.

 

[totalia]

Why do people care who likes who? I can never understand that about these threads and the message boards devoted to American Idol. Who cares? I like who I like, you like who you like.

I'm VERY surprised to see that list. Is that valid? Although I'm not surprised to see Carrie at the top of it...she seems like she has that wholesome thing going on....people are going to vote for her whether she's the most talented or not. My personal favorite is now Constantine for his versaility, Anwar for his raw talent and likeability, and Bo just because I think he has the whole package. Do I care that other people don't like my choices? Nope! Not one bit.

Why are 90% of the threads that appear on this forum popular? And why should anyone care about anything that the people are posting.

The answer is no reason. We just do.

 

[totalia]

Love to know why Carrie is on the top of that list. I can't stand her. I really hope she doesnt win and we can be spared her idea of entertainment.

 

[snoopy]

Why are 90% of the threads that appear on this forum popular? And why should anyone care about anything that the people are posting.

The answer is no reason. We just do.

Huh?

I don't really get what you are saying. With the exception of the political threads, I rarely see people objecting to other people's likes and dislikes. This thread seems to be the exception. I just don't get it. I'm not asking you to give me a reason, I'm just making an observation. I find it an odd thing. I like reading everyone's opinion each week, especially those people who take the time to do a full summary. Sometimes I find myself going, "did they hear the same song/singer that I did????", but I certainly never find myself getting upset or enraged that someone has a different favorite than I do. I've seen these AI threads in the past get to the point where they were one step away from being locked......I guess I don't see the debate?! How can you debate individual likes and dislikes?

 

[Cindy B]

Its amazing to see how close those mainland US numbers are.

I personally can't stand Scott, (even before the arrest) so to see him still in bothers me. I got put off from Scott in the group sing, when he didn't interact with his team.

 

[totalia]

I don't get upset just because someone doesn't like the same singer i do. And I don't see anyone here getting upset about that either.

Whats bothering me is that, even though someone like Scott was arrested for domestic abuse (or whatever it is that they are calling it today), it should just be dismissed because everyone makes mistakes. I think the thread has devolved at this point to some of us who are bothered by people shrugging it off and the one who are just shrugging it off and saying it doesn't matter.

I would LIKE to move on to something else other than talking about Scott's personal behavior (which I think he should have been booted for but it's Hollywood, thats what they do). Unfortunately its become this weeks obsession with some of the women out there just as dissing Constantine was last weeks obsession.

 

[korzmom]

Why does SIMON keep pushing for CARRIE I thought he didnt like country...I find her kind of boring, good voice but no personality... and does anybody else think that PAULA needs to take a random drug test????

 

[Tasha+Scott]

I don't get upset just because someone doesn't like the same singer i do. And I don't see anyone here getting upset about that either.

Actually I don't think that's completely true b/c it seemed like you got pretty upset the other day b/c people were saying they didn't like Constantine.

I would LIKE to move on to something else other than talking about Scott's personal behavior (which I think he should have been booted for but it's Hollywood, thats what they do). Unfortunately its become this weeks obsession with some of the women out there just as dissing Constantine was last weeks obsession.

I agree (well, somewhat) with this part. I would also like to move on from the whole Scott's past thing. We already know what he did and that it upset so many people and then there are those of us that don't feel it's fair to judge someone we know nothing about other than through the media. I personally would like this thread to go back to being about the singing and who we like and dislike...not talking about someone's past...but that's just me!