Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[damo]

Where does it give his name? I can't see that anywhere!

 

[Philadisney]

Where does it give his name? I can't see that anywhere!

it doesn't, and that's a good point, it could be some guy who looks like him - EXACTLY like him, though....and from the same area....kind of a coincidence.

of course it's the internet, so you have to take it with a grain of salt. anyone could have put that there.

ps speaking of websites, this one is for all you mary roach fans: http://www.maryroachweb.com/
(yes i am aware that may just be me )

 

[Cindy B]

it doesn't, and that's a good point, it could be some guy who looks like him - EXACTLY like him, though....and from the same area....kind of a coincidence.

of course it's the internet, so you have to take it with a grain of salt. anyone could have put that there.

Thats interesting thought. Someone could have put those pictures up and made up that stuff as well. The last login date was Jan 1 2005. Idol wasn't on in January, right? Who knows it could have been a drunken NYE kind of thing..

Just holding out hope...

 

[ChrisnSteph]

=Cindy But it isn't officially listed as men seeking men, and believe it or not I looked at all 25 from NJ. I didn't want to look at the ones from NY, so I didnt.

Actually Cindy, it is. (I tried linking to it but it wouldn't bring the page up)

You have to do a search, click Men seeking Men, check the right city and age group. I found it. If that's not Anwar, it's his twin!

 

[SeaSpray]

ps speaking of websites, this one is for all you mary roach fans: http://www.maryroachweb.com/
(yes i am aware that may just be me )

Her web site is not too shabby!

 

[Tasha+Scott]

Well, I thought Vonzell was definitely the best tonight, followed by Nikko and then Bo and then Carrie. I guess my next choice would be Nadia even though I wasn't really feeling her tonight. I am so glad more people are starting to like Vonzell after tonight b/c I have been one of her fans since the very beginning. I was really disappointed in Scott tonight. I like him but he was really bad tonight IMO.

I predict the bottom 3 will come down to Anthony, Scott, and either Jessica or Anwar. I think Anthony will be the one to go though.

As far as whether Anwar is gay or not...I don't know, but my Dh has been saying that he thinks he is since the very beginning. He says he just gives off that vibe to him. I sort of agree but am not saying that is a bad thing. Some of my closest friends are gay so don't take my comments personally if you are one of his fans. I do agree that it isn't smart to put that online when you are a teacher, but I also agree that it might not have even been him that put it on there. Who knows?!

 

[Philadisney]

Thats interesting thought. Someone could have put those pictures up and made up that stuff as well. The last login date was Jan 1 2005. Idol wasn't on in January, right? Who knows it could have been a drunken NYE kind of thing..

Just holding out hope...

ah, if it hasn't been logged into since january, then my speculation is that it's probably really him (or his twin). no one would have known who he was back then

 

[mrsv98]

Ok, I brought up Anwar's Idol page and the dating page and looked at them side-by-side. If that isn't Anwar then it is his double or someone put up a page pretending to be him. I tried to find some distinguishing mark but the dating pics are too blurry. I am amazed that a teacher would do this, even tho being gay is "in" it is still risky for a teacher to be so blatent. I have taught with gay teachers and while they didn't hide their orientation, they didn't make an issue of it either.

As for tonight, I liked Bo, Constantine (first time for everything!) and Carrie. I think Vonzell had her "night" tonight but I want to see her replicate tonight's success, she hasn't been able to sing like this before so she needs to do it again to impress me.

 

[totalia]

Why has the conversation degraded to who's gay and who's not? Who cares? let's talk about the talent, not gossip about stuff that means nothing.

Have to say Paula looks stoned lol. She's also way too soft.

Bo -all right Not bad. Not Great.

Jessica- so boring I felt like I was going to go to sleep.

Anwar- not bad. Stood out more than many of the others. Personally I think he will be in the top five and should be.

Nadia- I liked it. She's passionate. Well done.

Constantine- Beautiful. Best of the night.

Nikko- He's done this week. Boring and lackluster.

Anthony. Cute and charming. Well done.

Carrie- may also be going this week

Scott- *Yawn*

Vonzell - Not bad.

The way its going, its goiong to come down to Constantine, Nadia and Bo.

 

[IloveDMB]

Who cares if he is gay or not? That doesn't discount his singing abilities, or lack thereof sometimes. Tonight was boring, just like last week. I still think he has one great voice, but he better start singing songs that suit his voice.

I thought Constantine was so, so good tonight. It was a great song and a great performance.

Nikko was so good. Was that another Dru Hill song? It if is, that's two weeks in a row that he's done great renditions of their songs. I think as he is improving, Anthony is getting worse. All that hype, and three bad weeks in a row. I hope he goes tonight.

 

[totalia]

I so much agree about Constantine. He could win this thing.

 

[thatchicktrish]

Who cares if he is gay or not? That doesn't discount his singing abilities, or lack thereof sometimes. Tonight was boring, just like last week. I still think he has one great voice, but he better start singing songs that suit his voice.

I thought Constantine was so, so good tonight. It was a great song and a great performance.

Nikko was so good. Was that another Dru Hill song? It if is, that's two weeks in a row that he's done great renditions of their songs. I think as he is improving, Anthony is getting worse. All that hype, and three bad weeks in a row. I hope he goes tonight.

The song Nikko sang was "Can we talk" by Tevin Campbell and I think he did a great job with it. He started out a tad rough but he pulled it together pretty quick and ended it good. I was kind of disappointed in Scott's performance, that Brian McKnight song is one of my favorite songs of all time though so I don't like anyone "messing" with it. I liked Constantine tonight. Is it just me or is everyone else continually amazed at Constantine's height when he stands next to Ryan?? lol it makes me laugh everytime I see them next to eachother.

 

[Planogirl]

Bo has been my favorite from the very beginning but I absolutely hated the song he chose tonight. I don't think that anyone could sing that thing well.

Constantine did a really good job. He keeps improving.

I also liked Carrie and Vonzell. Jessica has a good voice but no fire.

 

[nicurn]

hmmm... not particularly impressed with anyone tonight. my choice for the bottom 3 would be (and not in any particular order)

scott
anthony
jessica (cause I just don't like her) (and agree completely with what simon said to her tonight about being unlikable... )

maggie

 

[txaggie94gigem]

oh my...why doesn't someone switch Paula's coke glass with Simon's and see what happens.... What is she on???? At least she hasn't started hugging and kissing on Randy yet but I expect her to start dancing on the judges table soon...

The worst performance of the evening for me was Scott...i am sorry but that performance was so pitchy it hurt my ears...that said I hope Anthony goes...he is BORING to listen too with no real fire...

Carrie and Vonzell were the best girls tonight. Constantine, my favorite, did the best of the guys tonight...I know some of you don't like the dreamy look but man he is hot!

I wish Bo would have done a different song...I really liked Anwar in the beginning but he has not done a great performance since moving onto the big stage...if he does not step it up he will be gone soon...I agree about Jessica in that she just doesn't have "it" whatever "it" is....I like Nikko but it is hard for me these past couple weeks because I don't know the songs he has been singing....

I think Scott, Anthony or Jessica will go home...are the phone numbers right this time???

 

[beattyfamily]

Bo -still nice voice but not a great song choice.

Jessica- I love her voice but there's something missing; she's still one of my top 3 though.

Anwar- didn't enjoy him at all tonight.

Nadia- Yuck for two weeks now.

Constantine- interesting choice and he pulled it off.

Nikko- didn't like it.

Anthony - What is he still doing here? YUCK.

Carrie- LOVE LOVE LOVE!

Scott- Horrible and worst performace yet

Vonzell - ok but can she do it again?

I still think the top 3 should be Carrie, Jessica and Bo.

Go Carrie!

 

[Cookie55]

So I didn't read it wrong? Good! I was starting to feel bad for potentially harming his reputation. (BTW, I wasn't slamming him for being gay, I was just posting what I thought I saw.)

WHY, WHY, WHY ARE YOU EVEN TALKING ABOUT THIS???????? WHO CARES??????? If you're so worried that you might have harmed his reputation, then you can't say that you weren't slamming him for being gay..... This is so totally moronic that this is being discussed as if it is a remotely relevant topic to a singing competition. First of all, you are basing everything on the premise that this is substantiated/factual information that he, in fact, posted. Second of all, I couldn't possibly care less if he did or "is"!!!! I don't recall Clay's allegiances ever being questioned. Hmmmmmm......

 

[geetey]

Is it just me or is everyone else continually amazed at Constantine's height when he stands next to Ryan?? lol it makes me laugh everytime I see them next to eachother.

ME! ME!! I say something to my family everytime they are standing next to each other. Constantine must be a giant! LOL!

Vonzell is getting better each week. I also really enjoyed Nikko's performance. DH is still in love with Carrie.

I think it is Scott's week to go home, but I doubt I will get my wish. I do think the bottom three will be Jessica, Scott and Anthony.

 

[PrincessaC]

I thought I would never say this but I am really falling for Constantine. Is it just me or is he getting cuter and cuter????? And his performances are getting better too... sheesh... I'm really liking him now!

 

[totalia]

I thought I would never say this but I am really falling for Constantine. Is it just me or is he getting cuter and cuter????? And his performances are getting better too... sheesh... I'm really liking him now!

lol. I know. He's just so incredibly hot. There's something so sensual and sexual about him and it comes through in the way he acts on the stage.