Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[RyMickey]

Nadia was even worse watching her the second time, but I really like her. She was just having an off night, IMO. I also think if she doesn't make it all the way on AI then she could do America's Next Top Model. lol

I agree that it wasn't Nadia's best, but I think she really has talent. I never vote, but I'm actually a little nervous that two nights of her not at her best could harm her chances tomorrow...so, I think I might actually be voting tonight.

RyMickey

 

[izzy]

Jiminy Christmas! Mikayla's song was worse hearing it the second time around.

I'd also like to smack her upside the head for being such an immature, mouthy brat.

(Can you tell I REALLY don't like her?)

 

[RyMickey]

After watching the recaps at the end, it'd be great to have a Final Four of Carrie, Bo, Nadia, and Vonzell.

RyMickey

 

[StaceyA]

calling for Scott and it is busy, busy, busy!

 

[orangeblossom]

I got through twice for Jessica....I'm calling once for S.O. and once for myself.

 

[Beanie]

LOL at Mikalah's shirt! I guess she knows that a lot of people don't like her and she was making a joke out of it.

I missed it tonight, what did Mikalah's shirt say?? I am assuming they just showed highlights from last night and the contestants didn't have to sing live again tonight?

 

[macraven]

calling for Scott and it is busy, busy, busy!

try now, i have called three times and got through right away.

 

[ShuisFan584]

Mikalah's shirt said "My Job is to ANNOY You"

 

[mouseclick1]

I missed the show last night so I was glad it recapped tonight! Bo and Nadia are still my favorites, though I agree with others that this was not Nadia's greatest performance. Bo, however, has never let me down! I can't believe it but Constantine is actually growing on me! I don't think he's cute and I am definitely NOT into the scrunchy thing he does with his nose, but I think he has gotten better since the beginning. I thought his rendition of "I Think I Love You" was very fun to watch and sounded pretty good!

 

[Planogirl]

I am having a horrible time getting through for Bo. It wasn't nearly this busy last night. I wonder why?

 

[thatchicktrish]

grrr I'm having a hard time getting through to vote for Nikko

 

[Nancy]

My dd missed last nights show so we ended up having it on again, even though I wasn't going to watch again. Oldest DD actually said that she didn't think Mikayla was that bad. She doesn't like Scott or Anwar.

 

[totalia]

Constantine the best yet again lol. He needs to win this thing.

 

[Cindy B]

The lines were busy almost the entire hour after the show for the following people:

Vonzell, Bo, Anwar, Jessica, Carrie and yes, Constantine (I promised my daughter I would throw a few votes for him for her!) My DH likes Carrie and Jessica and had a hard time getting through for his "Favorites".

I didn't even watch tonight. I found out that the performance order didn't change, and just called like yesterday.

Mikalah talked? Why bother doing that? She did better the first show when she would nod.

 

[Tasha+Scott]

Mikalah's shirt said "My Job is to ANNOY You"

Well, she has definitely done her job! Now...will somebody please FIRE her! I have to say that last night I didn't think she was as bad as usual but after hearing her again...I change what I said. She sounded horrible. Sometimes hearing them sing again helps their chances...but sometimes it hurts them. And then of course she HAD to talk tonight and grate on my last nerve again! Her shirt was correct anyway.

As far as how I think everyone did the 2nd time around:

The ones that sounded better after hearing them again:
Bo
Scott (simply b/c I didn't get to hear him last night)
Vonzell
Nikko

The ones that sounded worse after hearing them again:
Anthony
Mikalah!!!
Nadia (I love her but it wasn't her week!)

And the ones that I thought were just as good or as bad as they were to me last night:
Carrie
Constantine
Anwar
Jessica

Who I think should go home tomorrow night: Mikalah!!!
Who I think WILL go home tomorrow night: If there is any justice in this world--Mikalah!!!

 

[RyMickey]

What's really interesting this year is that almost everybody is listenable. With the exception of 1 or 2 singers, I enjoy listening to everyone. To me, it seems like it's going to be a real week-to-week thing to determine who goes home.

Anyway, this week I think the bottom three will be: Mikalah, Anthony, Scott (I just don't see Anthony and Scott having a really big fanbase compared to the others. That being said, I think that Jessica isn't as popular as the judges would like her to be, and despite singing well last night, she could easily be in the bottom three).
Who will go home: Like someone else said, if there is any justice in the world, it will be Mikalah.

RyMickey

 

[Virgo10]

For the most part my feelings about the 11 stayed the same with a few exceptions.

Nikko: I had him rated at a 3.5 after the first night but bumped him up to a 4 last night. He really was quite good and, in comparison to some of the other, is so much fun to watch on stage. He got a vote.

I actually thought Nadia, Mikalah and Constantine were worse than the way I felt on Tuesday. None of them got a vote.

Anwar and Anthony were blah and no votes for them either.

Carrie and Vonzell got a vote. Scott and Jessica got multiple votes.

And I wore out my Votey finger for Bo. Bo, Bo, Bo. I Tivo'd the show just to listen to him sing that song.

I still think and hope Mikalah is out of here tonight.

Roberta

 

[StaceyA]

try now, i have called three times and got through right away.

I see you posted this at 10:31, I was just getting in bed...LOL I have to be at work at 7am so sometimes I go early...

I was able to get through around 10ish quite a few times....

 

[aprilgail2]

I see you posted this at 10:31, I was just getting in bed...LOL I have to be at work at 7am so sometimes I go early...

I was able to get through around 10ish quite a few times....

I called around 1030 and had no trouble getting through on any of the lines I tried except Jessicas...hers was busy a few times. I normally wait until close to 11 when the show is on at 8 and get through every time I call.

 

[Mickeyfaniam]

if I am sure of only one thing...it is that Makayla was awful!!!

AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL!!!! And did I say AWFUL????

Makayla has to go!!