Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[Nancy]

Nadia...not a good song choice, but I like her. I wasn't watching, I just listened so I missed the hair, I'll have to watch recaps.

Mikayla....even yuckier then Constantine

Anwar, I'm not sure...I like his voice, not sure if I liked him singing that song.

 

[Sandy22]

Anwar really had me worried there but he worked it out for the last half.

 

[2bemarried]

Anwar was OKAY. Not his best...but he's definitely not the worst tonight either.

 

[zoegirl]

yeah I think it's her week to go. She's been bad two weeks in a row.

 

[Sandy22]

Oh yah - makayla is going home this week.

 

[PooohBear]

I really liked Jessica tonight

 

[Nancy]

Enjoyed Jessica, even though I hate that song.

My bottom 3: Mikayla, Nikko and Constantine

Hopefully Mikayla will be gone.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

11. Jessica-- "Total Eclipse of the Heart"-- One of my fave songs, and Jessica is definitely doing it justice. Very good vocally, and alot of energy. One of her best performances tonight.

 

[Rhonda]

Bye Bye Mikayla!

 

[2bemarried]

Jessica was the BEST one of the night. I think she even topped Carrie.

 

[Sandy22]

Going soon: Mikayla, Anthony

Going all the way: Bo, Nadia, Jessica

I still don't get what's so hot about Carrie?

 

[Philadisney]

i think nikko and mikaylah will be in the bottom 2 next week. i'll be voting for jessica, bo, scott, anthony (i know he's not that good, but i'd like to keep him around for a bit), vonzell, and nadia

 

[damo]

I wonder how Paula would do on a breathalizer test. Man, she was weird tonight.

We really liked Bo, Constantine(he weirded me out but my 16 yo son who has never heard that song before thought he was great), Carrie, Vonzell and Jessica. Anwar is getting into this habit of starting shakey and finishing well.

I do think Mikalah will be done tonight.

 

[macraven]

going to spend the next two hours voting.
hope all of you are doing the same.

vote for your favorite and come back tomorrow so we can moan, and complain together...........


you all know by now who i like.

 

[orangeblossom]

Jessica sounded great tonight...I voted for her even though Carrie is generally my favorite.

 

[palmtreegirl]

Anthony- Ok, better towards the ending. But after everyone else went he's very forgettable tonight.
Carrie- Whoa big hair 80's flashback.
Scott- He definitely felt the song, not the strongest singer but a decent job.
Bo- Not a fan.
Nikko- Very good job.
Vonzell I thought she did a great job!
Constantine- I enjoyed it, thought it was a fun choice, first time I've liked him.
Nadia Ohh not good. Such a disappointment, I just didn't enjoy her performance at all.
Mikayla- Not a singer, bye Mikayla.
Anwar- Zzzzzzzzzzzz.
Jessica- She definitely pulled the song off, great job.

Worst by far- Mikayla, please go home Mikayla.

 

[MrsMud]

Great show tonight! Best was...
Nadia's hair! I kept thinking over the past few weeks that her smile reminded me of a cartoon character, but tonight between the hair and the smile, I finally realized who it was. Now I really like Nadia and she's a beautiful girl, but she looked like MAX, THE GRINCH'S DOG! You know, when he's weighed down by that one big antler in the middle of his head?

 

[DemonLlama]

she looked like MAX, THE GRINCH'S DOG! You know, when he's weighed down by that one big antler in the middle of his head?

 

[Nancy]

Just saw Nadia's hair on recaps...all I can say is

Just figured out who Anthony reminds me of....Donny Osmond! Him being there tonight brought my teeny bopper years back to me. His singing and dancing style is all Donny way back when. (maybe that's why I like Anthony...I had such a crush on Donny!)

 

[Cindy B]

Anthony- Did he sing? I can't remember anything about it.

Carrie- . I thought she was a poser by going from country to a 80s queen. It reminded me of that final scene in grease when Sandy is all tight tops, and stillettos.

Scott- Yes, he had emotion. Not the greatest song though
Bo- Fabulous! It was dare I say better than Jim Croce
Nikko- ZZZZZ
Vonzell-- She pulled it out!
Constantine- He cracked me up.
Nadia Hello the 80's wants its hair back!

Mikayla- Not good.
Anwar- I loved Anwar, but I don't think he did great
Jessica- Not my favorite song, but she kicked BOOTY