Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[zoegirl]

Yeah, Paula sure like her, she was up dancing.......not sure if I like that.....

 

[2bemarried]

Paula is high on sugar or caffeine tonight.

 

[macraven]

scott Roxs............

 

[SPAM]

OMG CONSTANTINE!! that is my favorite song of all time! he was so sexy singing it! he has my vote!

 

[zoegirl]

Oh good grief tell Constatine to GET OFF THE STAGE YUCK!

 

[Disney1fan2002]

Not a Constantine fan, but WOW..he sounds just like David Cassidy (is that a GOOD thing? LOL) I have my back to the tv.

 

[2bemarried]

Ummmm...Constantine....no.

 

[Nancy]

I'm going against everyone else here so far. I liked Anthony...it wasn't his best, but it wasn't horrible either. I thought Carrie was awesome! I was unsure of how she would do with Heart, but she surprised me. I did think Simon's comments were a bit much though.

Scott, another great performance, I really like him.

Bo..I loved his performance. I love the song and I love how he performed it.

Nikko...doesn't do it for me.

Vonzell...nice job, love the song.

Constantine...YUCK! I'm sorry but the close up on his face his eyes look all bloodshot...oldest DD said he looks like he's stoned.

 

[Mercy]

OMG! Constantine has got to GO!!!! He is the worst! That song was terrible!

 

[SPAM]

Not a Constantine fan, but WOW..he sounds just like David Cassidy (is that a GOOD thing? LOL) I have my back to the tv.

it was a good thing! i loved david cassidy back on the partridge family

 

[Philadisney]

i don't like the song that vonzell sang, but i really like her, and i thought she did it well, so she'll get a vote from me. i usually can't stand constantine, but i enjoyed his performance tonight, shockingly! must be cos i love that song....

 

[orangeblossom]

I didn't like Constantine tonight.

 

[2bemarried]

Nadia's hair!!!

Great vocals though.

 

[zoegirl]

Usually like Connie but tonight...no way....Nadia honey, who told you to fix your hair in a fauxhawk? It's the worst she has been...

 

[Octoberbeauty]

I missed Bo, Nikko and Vonzell fighting on the phone with my exh! Just another reason to not like him.

 

[SPAM]

yeah, what was up with nadia's hair? ugh, it didnt fit the song and it was a total fake mohawk. i hate those. the rest of her hair is just slicked back. it looks ridiculous.

 

[Philadisney]

WOW Nadia....i love her hair i love cyndi lauper but i don't think that was a great song choice, i would've rather heard "all through the night" or "change of heart" or something. nadia definately has my support though

 

[cocowum]

She looks like Foghorn Leghorn

 

[orangeblossom]

I didn't like the hair, but liked the song and that's what counts.

 

[disneyworldgirl]

7. Constantine-- "I Think I Love You"-- Alot better than I thought he'd be able to do with this one (I grew up on the David Cassidy version). Very good job on this one, though, and he brought a little bit of an edge to it. He's definitely got alot of personality.

8. Nadia-- "Time After Time"-- Not sure about this song choice; I'm not sure it suits her. She's normally at the top each week, but this wasn't one of her best performances.