yep! we loved hanging around onboard. Call me crazy. Of course the double dip would change that because I would definately go back there as many times a possible!
I saw your pics of the beaches on the Eastern. You are so right. I had already told Laura that we wouldn't bother with any excursions, we'd just hang out at the beach!
You're not crazy. Actually people that cruise a lot think of the Ship as their destination, not where they're going. We planned this one based on the week. It didn't matter where we went. That will be the same in 2009 (unless Alaska is offered - then we will choose by itinerary).
If you go Eastern, you'll have a tough decision with St. Thomas - Meghan's Bay on St. Thomas or Trunk Bay on St. John. Both are great. Just depends if you want to water taxi for 30-45 minutes over to St. John.
On St. Maarten, we did Orient Beach, but to be honest, the beach where the ships come in was just fine with me too (did both).