oybolshoi
DIS Legend
- Joined
- Aug 16, 2004
- Messages
- 11,879
Perhaps we could take our discussion of HP offline?
I'd go crazy waiting to see the movies before reading the books... so far all of the movies have been rank compared with the books.
OK... maybe that's a bit harsh, but the first two movies were awful! PoA was well done and so was Goblet of Fire. And in a rare move for me, I actually think the movie version of OoTP was better than the book.
My biggest beef with the movies is that all end on a "happy" note or an "upbeat" moment which I find jarring. It's not a happy series...I don't need a movie manufactured happy moment to get me to come back to the next Potter film. I'm a fan, I'll be here... stop trying to manipulate me.
Thanks for letting me get that off my chest.
I don't always want a happy ending... they're trite and over-rated.
Anyway... would be delighted to discuss Harry with anyone who'd like to do so. Feel free to PM me here or email me at my home address: oybolshoi@aol.com.
Back to the cruise talk with you...
I'd go crazy waiting to see the movies before reading the books... so far all of the movies have been rank compared with the books.
OK... maybe that's a bit harsh, but the first two movies were awful! PoA was well done and so was Goblet of Fire. And in a rare move for me, I actually think the movie version of OoTP was better than the book.
My biggest beef with the movies is that all end on a "happy" note or an "upbeat" moment which I find jarring. It's not a happy series...I don't need a movie manufactured happy moment to get me to come back to the next Potter film. I'm a fan, I'll be here... stop trying to manipulate me.
Thanks for letting me get that off my chest.


Anyway... would be delighted to discuss Harry with anyone who'd like to do so. Feel free to PM me here or email me at my home address: oybolshoi@aol.com.
Back to the cruise talk with you...
