I'm having to restrain myself here because the last place I ranted on this, I got flamed and mightily. Apparently because I feel that the TWU has too much power in the city (insofar as what their strike affects and the health and safety issues that it causes for the citizens while our police and fire are stretched so thin and the streets so gridlocked that I'm sure there will be reports of people dying for not being able to get to hospitals... at least some major north/south and cross streets are open for emergency vehicles but you still have to be able to get into gridlocked parts of town) I'm a hateful awful person who shouldn't be able to live with myself because I am so against the working class. Nevermind that I work myself, as does my husband, and our solution to the rising cost of living in the city was to move to a place where I have a two hour commute each way. I'm having a hard time feeling sorry for them and their demands when what they already have is so much better than anyone in the private sector. If it wasn't, then why is there a huge waiting list for jobs in the MTA?
I work for a living too. My salary is less than their average (and this is with a graduate degree). I have to pay 20% out of pocket for my health benefits. If I want to retire ever, it's completely up to me to save up the money. My husband has not seen a raise in over 7 years, but is grateful to have a job in an economy where many of friends were laid off and have had to take jobs at levels much below their previous salaries. It's not some rich CEO making billions of dollars that will end up paying for the things these people want, it's the tax payer and the commuter, most of whom can scarcely afford to commute as it is. I'm just so sick of the GREED being displayed here.
This is not over health and safety issues. This is over pensions. This is over the fact that they want new hires (the ones on the waiting list) to pay 6% per year for the first 10 years into their pension fund. After that they drop down to the 2% everyone else has and can retire at 55. If I only paid 6% into my 401k I'd never be able to retire, and certainly not after only 25 years. I'd have a finite pot of money that I had to budget carefully over the rest of my life and not an endless supply of medical benefits and half salary for as long as I live. In 2002 the MTA paid about $150M into pensions, this year it cost them over $500M. Again I ask... where is this money coming from? From my pocket and from the pockets of people who can afford it even less than I can.
I'm lucky that I brought home a pile of work this week. My employer is reasonable. If I can't get all of my hours in, I can afford to take the financial hit. My heart is breaking for those people for whom the extra cost of commuting or not getting into work at all means they have to make the choice between christmas for their kids and paying the rent. I'm not against the working person, I'm just against this particular group of greedy money grubbing working people called the TWU and their fearless leader, who is being a hardnose about this because he didn't do so well in his last round of negotiations with the MTA. His bravado is as much to save his own job (which I would guess is paid pretty darn well) as it is over the "respect" he claims he wants for his people.
The MTA is not blameless either. That agency really needs an overhaul, bigtime. If they find all kinds of extra money they didn't know they have, though, it should go back to the commuters. I already pay nearly $400/month to commute and a fair amount in taxes. I don't want to pay even more so that these people have benefits that are barely dreamt about by people in the private sector. If that makes me an awful, hateful person so be it, that's what I am.