Sherry E
Currently tag-less...
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2008
- Messages
- 19,646
Sherry, you hit on the perfect person to replace Simon. I don't like him, but Gene Simmons would be the perfect replacement. Wow, I wonder if they thought about him? He rubs me the wrong way, Simon may be abrasive but he isn't repugnant, there in is the difference.
Hopefully they've thought of Gene. If I recall, he was a sit-in celebrity judge a few years ago (during the auditions) and he was good. He is annoying - no doubt about that - but I think he could be a good fit on AI. Otherwise, it's just going to be a lot of hemming and hawing with Randy and Ellen (even though I like them) because they won't want to come out and say that the performance was bad and what specifically was wrong with it. Kara will be trying to spit it out but will fall short of saying, "That was ridiculous."
You know what they really need to do to revamp Idol other than get the right 4th judge? They need to discontinue the horrible group song on elimination night, for one. That reminds me too much of the Brady Bunch singing "I think I'll go for a walk outside now; the summer sun's calling my name...it's a sunshine day!" Ugh.
Also, if they are going to do 'theme nights' where everyone has to sing one type of music, they have to remember that there are many young girls voting who have no interest in Frank Sinatra songs, Barry Manilow songs or Neil Diamond songs or whatever. I'm not even sure how many middle-aged people really care about "Big Band Night." They have to hip things up a little bit and get more current - or a little edgier. I mean, sure, I'd be happy if they did all classic rock songs because it would appeal to me, but I don't think their main demographic would want to hear a bunch of Tom Petty songs.