Not one classmate shows for six year old's birthday party

I stand behind my comment. Someone may have to leave early, get something they left in the coat room or their locker, use the restroom - there are any number of reasons they could catch you. And really how easy would it be to secretly slip them in their book bags? Especially somewhere where it would be sure to be found. Some of these book bags have sooooo many pockets! I know the best bet for parents finding invites would be for them to be placed in their "away" folders.
And let's say you could do it discreetly. How do the kids know who has or has not been invited when they get excited and start talking about the party?
Very hurtful!
That happened to a friends daughter. So she went up to the friend and asked where her invitation was - only to be told by the Birthday Girl - you're not invited!
Well, before you tell me that it's "not cool" to distribute these invitations, and since it's not against school policy for the students to give invitations out........would you rather that I allow the birthday child to hand these invitations out in front of other children? :confused3 Sheesh.....I'm trying to NOT make any child feel bad.
 
Well, before you tell me that it's "not cool" to distribute these invitations, and since it's not against school policy for the students to give invitations out........would you rather that I allow the birthday child to hand these invitations out in front of other children? :confused3 Sheesh.....I'm trying to NOT make any child feel bad.
I'm sure you are. I'm just amazed your school would allow this. Allow any type of solicitations! Do you have the option to refuse to distribute them.
 
We always RSVP. Sometimes we can make it, but usually not. It mostly depends on the time of year. Our school's policy is all girls, all boys or whole class. We are allowed to send in a birthday treat for the whole class, but it must be passed out by the birthday child during lunch, not during class. If they don't eat it at lunch, they take it home. We have never done a kid class party because of cost, but moreso because we don't want our kids getting a bunch of gifts they don't want or need. We've been to a "no gifts" party a couple of times, and most people buy gifts anyway. My kids have a lot of cousins, so we do two parties with family in Indiana over Thankgiving. Their birthdays are 11/22 and 12/4, so it works out well. Lol! This year my son did have a couple of friends sleep over and we went to the movies, but it was pretty low key.

On a side note, I detest the term "snowflake" when referring to children. Children did not write these school policies. Children are not responsible for deciding what room a parent has in their budget to play host to X number of children. I find the term very disrespectful, and classless. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I'm sure you are. I'm just amazed your school would allow this. Allow any type of solicitations! Do you have the option to refuse to distribute them.
My point is, I choose to distribute them. It's better then having a child hand them out on their own at recess or in the cloakroom in front of students who are not invited. Like I said already, I confiscate them and hand them out discreetly.
 

I stand behind my comment. Someone may have to leave early, get something they left in the coat room or their locker, use the restroom - there are any number of reasons they could catch you. And really how easy would it be to secretly slip them in their book bags? Especially somewhere where it would be sure to be found.

It's not really that hard. Our policy is that we put the invites in the mail bag that goes to and from school, teachers get the stack of invites when they check mail bags during first recess and then distribute them to the mail bags of the kids that got invited at the same time they put in the take home reading books, field trip forms, pizza day forms, etc; It's done during last recess and no, there are no kids in the room while any of this is being done. As for kids talking, of course they do. That's why it's our jobs as parents to teach them that it's rude to talk about these things with people who weren't invited.

And as for those that have expressed the idea that blanket-invites are some sort of social engineering, you wouldn't think so if (or when, for the childless), your kid is the one left out. I'll never forget the gratitude of a mom from my DS's 3rd grade year. The invitation her child got to DS's party was the FIRST ONE he'd ever received. I'll never really know what issues caused him to be such an outcast (he seemed like a pretty regular little kid to me), and he and my DS never became good friends, but including him was a kindness that cost us nothing and meant the world to him. It was a very teachable-moment for my DS too, as those kind of values are important to us. It's a very, very different thing than "everybody gets a trophy". Childhood itself is NOT a competitive sport where the losers just need to know their place...

My nephew is autistic and other than birthday parties for family he doesn't get invitations very often. There's one boy who doesn't really play with him but still invites him to his party every year. I sometimes wonder if his family really gets how much that means.
 
If everyone likes everyone! Then why make the rule? Oh, because that's not always the case and everything has to be equal and fair in public school. Which is a farce in the real world. Not everyone gets invited to lunch at work. Not all grown ups get invited to a lot of events. Should our employers put a rule out that says all office groups have to go to lunch together or not at all.

This is a pure Snowflake rule. So no one gets their feels hurt.
Let me get this right... you think 5 & 6 year olds should have the maturity to understand not everything is fair, and if they don't know it, they should learn it at that age?

Goof grief, fire doubles every 30 second to a minute. An engine and four man crew stuck on the other side of town will do a lot of property damage, just for a PR event.

So, no duty crews or inline engines should ever be used do personal PR work.
I'm guessing you never see on duty crews at a restaurant, the grocery store, or getting gas? The ONLY place they can respond from is their station? Did you ever consider that engine and four man crew doing the PR event just MIGHT be on the same side of town as the fire?
 
If everyone likes everyone! Then why make the rule? Oh, because that's not always the case and everything has to be equal and fair in public school. Which is a farce in the real world. Not everyone gets invited to lunch at work. Not all grown ups get invited to a lot of events. Should our employers put a rule out that says all office groups have to go to lunch together or not at all.

This is a pure Snowflake rule. So no one gets their feels hurt.

And here we have it, folks. Here is the reason schools have this rule.
 
This is why we never had parties for DS after this happened the one time we tried it.. He does have mild Asperger's, and grade school was extremely hard for him socially. He's now 17, and he has been invited to exactly ONE official party in his entire life. (One of the girls in his kindergarten class invited the entire class so he did get an invitation that one time.) He does hang out with friends at their homes sometimes these days, and he will call that a party, but it really isn't one; just a handful of kids playing video games and ordering in pizza; nothing really planned.

It had also happened to me as a child, and I remembered how much it hurt. My parents switched over to the "special family outing" method of birthday celebration, and I felt we should do that, too, but when DS was in first grade DH insisted that he should be able to have a party like other kids; that maybe he wasn't getting invited because he had never had a party of his own. He was in Cub Scouts so we invited them and all of the boys in his class, in the hope that at least a couple of them would show up. No such luck. When it became clear that we were getting no guests we actually went door to door in the neighborhood to see if we could find kids to come (there were no other boys his age in our neighborhood; all girls.) In the end we managed to round up 6 children, mostly girls and most a bit older or younger, but he was just so thrilled to have other kids come to the house that it kind of worked out OK. I'll tell you that even when we knocked on the doors of neighbors we had never met, more that one child responded to his parent's asking by saying, "you mean that weird kid? No way." The schoolyard grapevine had been at work; the only kids who agreed to come were some who had never met him, and only the girls ever deigned to play with him on any other occasions.

The invitations for the Cub Scout troop had been given out at a meeting, and we later discovered that every single one of them had been thrown away in the trash can outside the meeting room; their parents never even knew about the party (we found that out when DS teacher called us the Monday after the party to say that DS had come in from his afternoon class chore in tears. She had sent him to empty the classroom recycling can into the dumpster, and he saw the whole pile of invitations right on top, where they had landed when the janitor had emptied the big community room can. It was a parochial school, and the church and school shared the dumpster.)

Asperger's tends to come along with a lack of physical coordination that lasts quite a long time; for that reason most younger Aspies will shy away from team sports because they get teased for being so bad at them. They tend more to do things like martial arts if they do a sport at all. This makes it doubly hard for boys to make friends, because so much of boys' social lives these days revolve around organized sports.

Our family tradition for DS birthday since then has been to take the family to WDW; somehow he's OK with that.
 
This is why we never had parties for DS after this happened the one time we tried it.. He does have mild Asperger's, and grade school was extremely hard for him socially. He's now 17, and he has been invited to exactly ONE official party in his entire life. (One of the girls in his kindergarten class invited the entire class so he did get an invitation that one time.) He does hang out with friends at their homes sometimes these days, and he will call that a party, but it really isn't one; just a handful of kids playing video games and ordering in pizza; nothing really planned.

It had also happened to me as a child, and I remembered how much it hurt. My parents switched over to the "special family outing" method of birthday celebration, and I felt we should do that, too, but when DS was in first grade DH insisted that he should be able to have a party like other kids; that maybe he wasn't getting invited because he had never had a party of his own. He was in Cub Scouts so we invited them and all of the boys in his class, in the hope that at least a couple of them would show up. No such luck. When it became clear that we were getting no guests we actually went door to door in the neighborhood to see if we could find kids to come (there were no other boys his age in our neighborhood; all girls.) In the end we managed to round up 6 children, mostly girls and most a bit older or younger, but he was just so thrilled to have other kids come to the house that it kind of worked out OK. I'll tell you that even when we knocked on the doors of neighbors we had never met, more that one child responded to his parent's asking by saying, "you mean that weird kid? No way." The schoolyard grapevine had been at work; the only kids who agreed to come were some who had never met him, and only the girls ever deigned to play with him on any other occasions.

The invitations for the Cub Scout troop had been given out at a meeting, and we later discovered that every single one of them had been thrown away in the trash can outside the meeting room; their parents never even knew about the party (we found that out when DS teacher called us the Monday after the party to say that DS had come in from his afternoon class chore in tears. She had sent him to empty the classroom recycling can into the dumpster, and he saw the whole pile of invitations right on top, where they had landed when the janitor had emptied the big community room can. It was a parochial school, and the church and school shared the dumpster.)

Asperger's tends to come along with a lack of physical coordination that lasts quite a long time; for that reason most younger Aspies will shy away from team sports because they get teased for being so bad at them. They tend more to do things like martial arts if they do a sport at all. This makes it doubly hard for boys to make friends, because so much of boys' social lives these days revolve around organized sports.

Our family tradition for DS birthday since then has been to take the family to WDW; somehow he's OK with that.
That is sad. So the kids/Cub Scouts all threw the invitations away themselves?
 
I'm so sorry for your son NotUrsala. You obviously tried to make the situation for him better.

One thing that I "beat" into my child (not literally, of course), was to be kind, to include, to protect. Now, even when his other behaviors sometimes drive me crazy, I'm warmed when I see him going out of his way to treat others kindly who are disabled, or elderly, or picked on, or just...different. What's more important that that?

Terri
 
That is sad. So the kids/Cub Scouts all threw the invitations away themselves?

Yes. Not the classrooms invites, but the ones to the Scout troop. We asked another Cub mom who we knew to feel her kid out on the subject, and it turns out that one of the older kids who was a bit of a bully suggested that they all throw them away; apparently none of the boys argued with him on it. I don't know if it happened out of malice or fear of reprisals, but it happened. (We ended up pulling DS out of that troop a year later when he told us that he was being physically harassed by the other kids at Scout events. The Scout leader denied it, but the ringleaders were primarily his two sons. One of the other boys dads agreed to keep an eye out, and caught them at it.)

We had mailed the classroom invitations (getting the addresses from the Buzz Book), and we actually did have some affirmative RSVP's from the parents. However, all of those parents ended up calling on the morning of the party to cancel for some reason or another, and it became clear to us that the boys were balking. By that time, of course, all of the preparations had been made. It was a TRULY hellish day, and I'll never forget it.
 
Not Ursula, I'm so sorry. As I mentioned our dd has autism, and yes she does have hypotonia, which makes team sports pretty much impossible. I can empathize with everything you said. Hugs.
 
I didn't even know that the whole "invite the whole class" thing was even up for debate, I simply thought that was the done thing if a young child was having a "friend" birthday party. I feel that there are no shortage of ways to learn that life isn't fair, this doesn't seem like it needs to be one of them. My mom's mantra to me when I was younger was "be nice to everybody" and it's proved pretty effective.

As for this specific instance, I don't know the details of the invitation, but if it included details for an RSVP, there's no excuse not to give one.
 
Goof grief, fire doubles every 30 second to a minute. An engine and four man crew stuck on the other side of town will do a lot of property damage, just for a PR event.

So, no duty crews or inline engines should ever be used do personal PR work.

Why do you have such a problem with this? Are you feeling left out because no one ever did anything like this for you?


Thinking its ok to make 5 and 6 year old children feel left out is just beyond comprehension to me. Why would you want that? They have plenty of time to learn that life isn't fair. They will learn the lesson same as the rest of us.


You do realize that there are MANY fire departments cross the country that don't have anyone at the station. They are called volunteers and they can still make it to the fire in time. Its called training.
 







New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top