danikoski
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2014
- Messages
- 2,136
I know I'm a day late on the logo news but my thoughts anyways (that no one asked for or care about)
I've determined why I personally dislike this one. It doesn't have to do with the fact that there are characters in the logo...it has to do with the fact that all the characters are their own style. Live action BB-8, Cartoon Mickey, CGI Woody...it's all over the place. The font/logo itself is quite boring and a bit lazy, but the differences in the characters style really make it seem even lazier. They couldn't even be bothered to think of a way to bring those three different mediums together. It was...'What pictures do we have...ok...photoshop those into the O's and call it a day.'
That post works for the same reason the above logo doesn't. Because all the different characters from the different IPs are represented in the same style, which brings cohesion to the design.
This logo is boring, but fine. Much less "offensive" (for lack of a better word) than the one with the characters in the O's.
EDIT:
With my virtually zero graphic design skills I took a stab at it myself. I'm not saying this is not lazy, but at least it's somewhat cohesive.
View attachment 398493
EDIT EDIT:
Changed my design a bit because I forgot to invert BB-8 correctly lol
View attachment 398508
That logo is great! Disney should hire you...instead, they probably spent an obscene amount of money having a contractor design it for them...