This post makes me think of a situation with my dd6 yesterday. While our two neighbor kids were over, my dd decided to fill a squirt toy with water. I warned her that if she planned to use it, she best be prepared for what may happen. Think ahead a few steps and predict what may happen if you break out a water toy. "Be prepared to give what you get and don't come running to me if you aren't happy with the results," was the gist of what I was telling her. Off she went, adamantly reassurring me she'd be fine. Sure enough, five minutes later she storms into the house, wet spots all over her shirt telling me the neighbor boy got her all wet! Duh!
Same as with this post. Think ahead and be prepared to give what you get. If you come to a message board with a large membership of parents and post complaints and judgments on people's parenting -- even in general (no pointing fingers specifically) -- be prepared to receive some defensive remarks, sensitive and emotional responses. It's the natural order of things.
This conclusion is easy to come to; because this whole thread reeks of the same odorous scent as the "obnoxious kid/bad parent in the restaurant thread" from earlier this week! My goodness! Aren't we a judgmental bunch! From the number of posts I've seen surface on here time and again... someone will complain about some misbehaving/crying/disruptive child and instantly blame all that ails the child onto the parent and call them bad.
Others will post in defense of the parents (because at some point, ALL parents will say or do something that will put them in this category at least ONCE in their lives and so it's so easy to get defensive of it). Then others will jump in and defend the OP's point of view.
DEJA VU, Anyone?
At some point, all parents make a less-than-stellar choice.... which may involve saying or doing something not very logical. But so do non-parents. I have had experiences with just adults who were truly obnoxious and disruptive. When speaking about WDW, cutting in line, smoking in unallowed places, using obscenities, etc. are all distasteful actions that I've seen from adults -- regardless of parental status. Should THEY do THESE things? No. And, they probably know it too.
As for parents losing their temper or elevating their expectations for their children to an unrealistic level and then getting upset with them when they can't achieve that, is basically the same nut. Should they do these things? No. And, they probably know it too!
Things happen, people do stuff they know they shouldn't. Even good people do. Let's see if we can be a little bit forgiveing here. I don't think that it is MY good time that's being ruined if I see a crying kid who's getting a tongue-lashing by his parents to settle down and be quiet. Let's get real. It's that family's time that's getting ruined. How spoiled we must have become to think the entire world revolves around ourselves. I will admit, there are times I feel a sense of entitlement to certain things. At times, though I cringe at the thought, I can be considered a control freak, but this sure takes the cake. To actually feel so entitled to such a specific atmosphere (where all the people around you are behaving up to your personal expectations) when going to a public place is a type of controlling behavior that way surpasses me!
As an aside, since you (the OP) brought it up. How many instances in which you witnessed this behavior, did you actually stick around to see the resolution of? What I mean is, did you see this stuff in passing, or in a line? Because say, if you were in line and were witnessing this, how do you know that maybe the behavior started in that line and after the family got through the line that maybe they decided to go home. Or how do you know that the kids' behavior you saw while walking past them didn't stop 30 seconds later? Kids can cry, whine and be obnoxious even when they're not tired. Many of them can stop just as quick as they started too. AND, let's face it; it is difficult to predict kids' behaviors in such an overstimulating place as WDW. Though we've been to WDW before, each time, each of my four kids have displayed unpredictable behavior at some point. It's life.
When I find my self in the situation you described, call me rude, but I'm not thinking about whether or not we're disrupting someone else's time. Rather, I'm focusing on how to best restore peace to my family unit, for our sake, not yours! When I see another family in this type of situation, I throw a prayer up to God thanking Him it's not me this time and asking him to send some peace to that family. When I encounter someone with the viewpoint of the OP, I pray that they don't have kids, or if they do, that they never behave like normal kids do because they will have to live their lives as hermits and never go out and risk disrupting the general public with less-than-perfect behavior. I pray that those people NEVER, EVER, EVER make a wrong move, a choice that after-the-fact turns out to be a bad one. I pray that though God made us to be "imperfect, yet forgiving" that despite all odds, they find the way to be perfect in all their choices all the time. I wonder how on Earth, despite all the best efforts they put forth, how they think they will make the perfect choice EVERY TIME! Then I laugh and part of me wishes the "mother's curse" onto them, in which they are blessed/cursed with uncontrollable children -- despite how perfect they feel they are -- imagining them having to stay inside locked into their house because (gasp) they can't control their children!
Meanwhile, my "imperfect" family will blissfully, and ignorantly continue to enjoy life and all it has to offer, continuing to do the very best we can -- content with the fact that though we may have ******* once in awhile, though we may make mistakes, we still all love each other, are forgiving, compassionate human beings that can see beyond ours and others imperfections and still have a good time!