katieam1
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Sep 30, 2008
- Messages
- 1,714
Ok, Now I also liked the movie I thought it was ok but they did leave things I loved out of it and added things to it.
-They left out all of the conversations I love about Bella and Edward in the entire book before they realize they love each other. All the rides home, all the times they hung out in school. Now I know they have to condense but it happened too quick in the movie for me.
- The Blood Typing chapter was one of my favorites.
- The hospital scene was different too because Edward came in with Carlisle. Charlie was not in the room he was in the waiting room. Edward and Bella had a few interactions there.
-The Trip home from Port Angeles they never stopped because someone was attached he took her home so they had all of that interaction in the car which is where she truly told him she knew what he was and that she did not care.
-The meadow scene was cut and although they did show them lying in it there was a whole day at the meadow where they did tell each other they loved each other which I thought that at least should have been in the movie it was important to how their relationship progressed.
-The time she went to meet the Cullens. Rose and Emmett were not even there. She refused because she did not like Bella and Emmett was trying to talk her into being ok with it. She was there for the baseball scene but never said anything to bella. It was Alice who said I can smell her from across the field in a nice way or at least I took it in a nice way, not the way Rose said it in the movie.
-Then there was after James started the whole thing and Edward was trying to get Bella out of there. Alice and Emmett went with them and there was a whole everyone trying to convince Edward to fo back to Bella house conversation. Some good examples of Edwards personality there that I thought lacked in the movie. The house scene when they went back after they left Bella's house after she left Charlie was a tad different but not major.
-There was the whole Phoenix thing was different James made Bella go to her mom's house first, there was more days of them in the hotel and that is where her and Alice started forming their friendship which I love! More interaction with Jasper.
-The whole James knew Alice before she was a vamp. (but I was ok with that being gotten rid of, it was not explored in the book like I would have liked. They did mention it in New Moon a little but I wanted to hear more)
-Oh, I forgot there was a whole Chapter on Carlisle when she went to the house which gave his story. I know that isn't a big deal because we will get to Italy in New Moon but I liked it, but I can see why they did not put it in.
-Oh and there was a dance in the middle of the book and then the prom, the Cullens were all there. Alice helped Bella the entire day get ready and Victoria was NOT at the Prom.
Those are just what I can think of I am sure there was more differences but I don't know anymore.
I just want to say again I liked the movie!, and I know that it can only be so long but I would have liked to see MORE of at least Bella and Edward falling in love, and a little more of the details at least right. Plus, a little better acting. I don't know those are just my thoughts.
-They left out all of the conversations I love about Bella and Edward in the entire book before they realize they love each other. All the rides home, all the times they hung out in school. Now I know they have to condense but it happened too quick in the movie for me.
- The Blood Typing chapter was one of my favorites.
- The hospital scene was different too because Edward came in with Carlisle. Charlie was not in the room he was in the waiting room. Edward and Bella had a few interactions there.
-The Trip home from Port Angeles they never stopped because someone was attached he took her home so they had all of that interaction in the car which is where she truly told him she knew what he was and that she did not care.
-The meadow scene was cut and although they did show them lying in it there was a whole day at the meadow where they did tell each other they loved each other which I thought that at least should have been in the movie it was important to how their relationship progressed.
-The time she went to meet the Cullens. Rose and Emmett were not even there. She refused because she did not like Bella and Emmett was trying to talk her into being ok with it. She was there for the baseball scene but never said anything to bella. It was Alice who said I can smell her from across the field in a nice way or at least I took it in a nice way, not the way Rose said it in the movie.
-Then there was after James started the whole thing and Edward was trying to get Bella out of there. Alice and Emmett went with them and there was a whole everyone trying to convince Edward to fo back to Bella house conversation. Some good examples of Edwards personality there that I thought lacked in the movie. The house scene when they went back after they left Bella's house after she left Charlie was a tad different but not major.
-There was the whole Phoenix thing was different James made Bella go to her mom's house first, there was more days of them in the hotel and that is where her and Alice started forming their friendship which I love! More interaction with Jasper.
-The whole James knew Alice before she was a vamp. (but I was ok with that being gotten rid of, it was not explored in the book like I would have liked. They did mention it in New Moon a little but I wanted to hear more)
-Oh, I forgot there was a whole Chapter on Carlisle when she went to the house which gave his story. I know that isn't a big deal because we will get to Italy in New Moon but I liked it, but I can see why they did not put it in.
-Oh and there was a dance in the middle of the book and then the prom, the Cullens were all there. Alice helped Bella the entire day get ready and Victoria was NOT at the Prom.
Those are just what I can think of I am sure there was more differences but I don't know anymore.
I just want to say again I liked the movie!, and I know that it can only be so long but I would have liked to see MORE of at least Bella and Edward falling in love, and a little more of the details at least right. Plus, a little better acting. I don't know those are just my thoughts.



My husband said the same exact thing! He was telling my family about the movie (because my sister 14 wanted to watch it) and those were his exact words!