hi Kim...
I'm not sure I totally understand your question...but here's my two cents.
If you are doing an intimate vow renewal at Disney, you only have five choices. And since you are having 15 guests, you essentially eliminate Sunset Pointe as an option (I believe Disney is only allowing 10 guests at that location now, but ask your EM just to be sure!).
The Wedding Pavilion is more expensive (and quite a bit bigger than the other locations)...don't know if that is a consideration. Cost was a factor for me which is why I didn't choose the Pavilion, but it is beautiful.
I chose Sea Breeze Point because we were planning to stay at the Boardwalk. I wanted someplace close to our rooms. That was the biggest reason for my choice. It is a beautiful location, and I was thrilled when I saw it in person!
As to the other locations, they are all beautiful in their unique way...you have to decide about the "atmosphere"...I think in that respect, the Gazebo at the Yacht Club and Sea Breeze Point are very similar...and Sunrise Terrace at the Wilderness Lodge has a very distinct "woodsy" (but gorgeous) feel, at least IMO.
I can tell you that unless things have changed, for an intimate vow renewal, you really only have four times to choose from: 9am, 11am, 1pm, and 3pm. And that's only if the location you pick isn't already booked for a specific time on the date you want.
We picked 11am because DH isn't a morning person, and since we were there in September, we knew it would be HOT AND HUMID in the afternoon, so that time worked out best for us. When you are choosing a time, consider the temps and likely weather; for example, I would probably NOT choose an outdoor location (anything other than the Pavilion) for an afternoon wedding in July...too darn HOT!!
Hope that helps...I'm sure others will give you better advice...but really, choosing a location is a very personal choice!
