we stayed a few years ago and loved it, booked for next summer
we are a family of five so it is hard to say if you will like it based on not knowing who is going in your party.....without kids I am not sure if I would pick the HRH
My husband decided it is his fave hotel ever. We are early 40s parents and the music everywhere was amazing, had such a cool vibe....dj for the kids at the pool played so much of our music, parents loved that and he made it fun for the kids with the games
we ate at the pool bar about 3 times, mainly because we never wanted to leave the chaotic party atmosphere, and the food was pretty good, really great rare tuna app...ordered every time...
pool waitresses were great...beer buckets poolside? fun stuff
kids loved it because they ran around the pool area, loved the slide, and DJ
Scooter is the coolest resort entertainment ever.....they can't wait to go back
I had asked all if they wanted to stay at another hotel next time to try it and they all looked at me like I was crazy....we are doing Disney too and they didn't mind switching hotels to try something new, but my husband said he had one request for our trip next summer...hard rock hotel
ok, as for rooms, we had a room so far down the hall the walk was a pain, maybe ask to have a room a bit closer to the elevator if you don't want this, we booked a deluxe for next trip, and all those rooms are at the bend of the hallway so we will now only be halfway down the never ending hallway
hope this helps
and if you are all adults, I would go with the Italian themed hotel