If you don't mind staying in a regular (very nice!) hotel room, then you'd enjoy the OKW studio. It's a large hotel room with a microwave and mini-fridge. But it has frequent bus shuttles to all the Disney parks and the grounds are quite beautiful. There are boat rides to DTD and a festive atmosphere to the main recreation area. Unfortunately, a studio is not nearly as comfy as a nice 1BR or 2BR timeshare unit
and Disney charges II exchangers an additional $95 just because you're trading into a Disney resort. Also, Sept 6th, they'll close the main OKW pool for a renovation (adding a pool slide) and it's not scheduled to re-open until sometime in mid-December. If your trip is in between those dates, you could use their other quiet pools or take a free bus over to a nearby resort (Saratoga Springs) to use their pool (permitted during pool renovation), which has a pool slide.
As for the other resorts you've mentioned, do stay with a "
5 Star" resort when trading via II to try for the nicer places. (Gold Crown is the RCI award, 5 Star is the II award.)
Fairfield Star Island & Star Island Resort are two sections of the same place. It's very, very nice with lots of amenities. If you get a 1BR with full kitchen (not partial) or larger, you'll enjoy a beautiful, deluxe, spacious room and lovely resort amenities. The main pool area has two pretty pools, one with zero-entry. Nice fitness facility and spa; tennis courts; lounge; weekly entertainment poolside; kids' activities and playground - very nice place located on a side street off Rte 192
east of WDW (10 min. drive to property, 5 more to theme park lots). The pool is tops with preschoolers (zero-entry) and the resort itself is great for adults. Easy drive to all the area parks.
Wyndham Palms is pretty new and well-liked. Attractive, spacious rooms with deluxe features, somewhat fewer resort amenities than Star Island but still very, very nice. It's located on a side street off Rte 192
west of WDW (15 min. drive to property, 5 more to theme park lots). Lovely place for adults and families who want a beautiful place to stay while visiting the WDW parks, longer drive to Univ/Sea World.
Calypso Cay is brand new, 5 min. closer to the parks than the others mentioned and offers a pool slide at one of its pools. The rooms are somewhat smaller and less luxe than the other two but still sound (from reports) like a great place to stay - especially if you have young school age kids who really like a pool slide. Good location for all the parks.
The other places mentioned have more mixed reviews by past guests. Depends on what you are seeking. When it comes to timeshares, size does matter. If you are comparing a 2BR to a studio, consider carefully. A 2BR in one of the 5 Stars you've listed will offer lots of space, better sleeping (quiet) with separate BRs, full kitchen, 2 full baths, inroom w/d, jacuzzi bath, spacious DR/LR with table to seat 6. The studio is more of a place to sleep and shower. The resort's general amenities matter a great deal to some people and not at all to others. Consider what matters to you.
