Narcoossee's or Yachtsman for a steak lover?

[Gigi22]

I voted for the YSH, simply on the basis that you shouldn't expect to find a really good steak at a fish restaurant, and vice versa. As you can tell, I'm just not impressed by surf and turf anywhere!

 

[Space Mountain Kid]

i loved the ysh food delish.

 

[Brook1099]

Yachtsmen get my vote, we eat here twice on our trip!

 

[Brook1099]

We have stayed at the BC many times and have yet to use Beaches as a TS, considering it this time, do u get any icecream/sundaes as options or is it limited. TIA

 

[grace&philipsmom]

If you are looking for good steak, definitely Yachtsman.

 

[mdsd8700]

We have eaten at Yatchsman, Narcoossee's and Shula's. My husband and I love steak (especially filet!) and are from the Chicago area so there are lots of great steak places to choose from and we have been to most of them. While of course it is all a matter of personal opinion, if you are looking for the best steak I think it would be Shula's. If you are looking for a very good steak with the best atmosphere at Christmas then go with Narcoosee's. I think Yatchman is good, but not where I would spend my money for such a meal.

 

[kknpj]

We at at both Narcoosee's and Yachtsman last week! I got the filet at Narcoosee's and it was so good! But if you go there, definitely get the sauce they serve with the steak on the side. It has a different taste to it. I couldn't decide if I liked it or not - still can't decide! But the steak was tasty and tender. We went to Narcoosee's so my husband could get the lobster.

We went to Yachtsman for the steak. We had a wonderful here meal also. I got the NY strip and my husband got the porterhouse. Both were delicious and cooked to perfection. We liked our server better at Yachtsman.

I don't think you will go wrong with either choice. I will return to both of them on our next trip!

 

[irishtigger]

While the decorations are beautiful at GF Don't forget the BC has the gingerbread carousel and the BW has the gingerbread gazebo.