Narcoossee's or Fulton's?

[sproutmd]

Which would you choose and why? We will likely be ordering shellfish...

ETA: Or do we need to do both?

 

[SusieBea]

We've eaten at both several times. I prefer Narcoossee's. I feel the food and the service at Fulton's can be inconsistent. Plus I always feel crammed in at Fulton's. I feel the food is good at Narcoossee's, the atmosphere is lovely, and we've usually had good service. Just my opinion.

 

[senadler]

I would review the menus to help you decide. We are going to Fulton's this trip because my son loves crab, but does not really like lobster. I find there are more shellfish options for him at Fulton's. If you like the options at both, I prefer the overall atmosphere and service at Narcoossee's.

 

[sproutmd]

I'm struggling because we like crab. The menu looks more appealing at Fulton's, but we want the atmosphere at Narcoossee's. The prices look better at Fulton's, but Narcoossee's might be better for the kids. We have a reservation at 7:40 p.m., and I don't know if the reservation is late enough to hang out for the fireworks.

 

[SusieBea]

I feel your pain because I like crab, too. And I agree that the prices are better at Fulton's. If you go to Narcoossee's and the fireworks are at nine, you'll be golden. They pipe in the music and you can go out on the veranda. And if they're later, you can hang around and go back to the veranda. It's really very magical. Good luck!

 

[horse11]

I know there will be many that may disagree but what about keeping your reservation at Nacoossee's and then do a TS at Cape May. I love crab and Lobster and have eaten at all three; Narcoossee's, Futons, and Cape May. The Atmosphere at Nacoosee's can not be beat especially if you stay to see the fireworks after your meal. The food was amazing!!! We loved Fulton's too but I was just as happy with the all you can eat crab legs at Cape May. of course they are snow crab vs king crab but you can eat until your heart is content. Plus it is a buffet so it would be kid friendly and less expensive.

 

[SouthJersey]

Narcossee's.

 

[hookedonears]

Narcoossees doesn't have the seafood selection that Fulton's has, but if your just looking for quality of food, there's no question that Narcoosses is by far the best. No comparison. The atmosphere is much nicer as well.

 

[DisneyWishes14]

Neither. Food was cold and mediocre at both.

 

[Uncleromulus]

Narcoossees easily.

But better than both is Blue Zoo.

 

[Bailey 512]

Narcoossees - Food is good and the atmosphere is nice.

 

[sproutmd]

Well...we are staying at Dolphin. So, I'm thinking we keep Narcoosee's (try it out, watch Wishes) and make a reservation at Blue Zoo on our break day. Thanks, all!

 

[Huggups]

Narcoosee's!