Le Cellier is the restaurant that we feel the Unofficial Guide to WDW is most unfair to in its review. In fact, though we've learned to take the restaurant reviews in that book with a grain of salt, we avoided Le Cellier for years because they were so vehement in their disdain for it. Finally, this past May we tried it and LOVED it.
Though we enjoy and respect much of what the UG says, now we usually refer to them as the "food snobs"!