My neighbor just ruined the magic...

I would deal with it the same as you would when they find out other fictional figures are not real. Tell her the truth. Then tell her that it's still fun to believe in it and she can still choose to have fun with it and make believe it is real anyway. My older kids do that with Santa. Didn't we all?

I don't believe in keeping up the facade once it's discovered. I think that's confusing for kids and makes them less likely to believe you in other instances.
 
i don't understand why other people have to ruin things. whether it's a kid or not, they should be taught that some people have different beliefs, and they are not always right.

Anyway. If a kid asks me, tell them that one of them was the real deal, and the others were filling in for them, since the original can't be every where all the time. Like they had an emergency at their house or something along those lines.

Believing in magic is something I'll never let go of. And will definitely pass it along to all the kids that come into my life. pixiedust:pixiedust:
 
albarellic said:
We explained it the same way we explained mall Santas... one of them is real and you never know if you're going to see the real one or not. Sometimes the princesses get tired and need to take a break, so they have helpers.

^^ This^^ I wish i had a like button ;0)
 
My 8 year old neighbor just told my 5 year old DD that the princesses we met in Disney were not real. They were just the people that worked there dressed up in costumes. What would you do??? I do not want to lie to her when flat out asked if they are real...but I am not ready to give up the magic yet this soon. We just got back from such a magical trip! :sad2: :confused3

I didn't read the other responses. My thought is that 5 year old know that they are not the real characters....I mean, they look nothing like what they see on tv and many characters they know as cartoons! And why would Mickey Mouse be so big? Kids are smart and know, but they don't always tell their parents. They are having too much fun!
 

I personally do not get comments like this that are intended to start trouble or insult the OP. This is a message board for Disney Families. I posted a situation that I thought other Disney families would empathize with. On a common interest message board such as this, is it so outrageous to post something Disney related that happened to my family...and then hope that others might offer some stories about how they handled similiar situations? I figured that a forum such as this was a good place to find families that had experience with this topic. Guess what? I was right!
I'm sorry but I just don't get these types of posts most of the time. Is there a forum that you go on when your kid finds out santa isn't real? What did people do before there was a message board like this?


Thanks to everyone who offered helpful suggestions or stories about their children's experience with believing in the magic.

What I ended up telling her is a combination of a few that were said and I feel pretty good about how it went.

I ended up saying thats too bad the (neigbhor) does not believe in princesses, it was so magical when we met them. She asked if I believed they were real and I said I like to think so. I also told her how everyone is allowed to believe whatever they choose and we should never tell anyone what they should believe. We have recently had a similiar discussion about God so this went over pretty smoothly. I am sure she has her doubts and that is fine, I just did not want her to be crushed and feel like she was betrayed. I have never told her what to believe, she has always just believed they were real and we went with it. It has made for three really magical vacations!

I am really glad that this happened after our trip at least. I know she is right at that age where she might start to question things, especially starting Kindergarten. This makes me so glad we decided to scrape funds together to fit in one last trip while she still believed :)
 
We started going to Disney when DD was 4 and it never even entered her mind that the characters were anything other than people dressed in costumes. We never had to "tell her". Her bain is too logical. It would also never enter into her mind that other children might think they were real. Frankly, I never considered the possibility befroe these boards either. She wouldn't intentionally ruin it for anyone, but would never have known she needed to pretend. She knows other kids believe in Santa and she shouldn't ruin it, but this was never on our radar.
 
i don't understand why other people have to ruin things. whether it's a kid or not, they should be taught that some people have different beliefs, and they are not always right.

You really can't equate someone's belief in a character dressed up as a princess in an amusement park with one's beliefs.
 
Still think kids who do that kind of thing are brats, though.

Not to say that there aren't bratty children, but.....

I choose to think of an 8 year as a very young human who doesn't always think things through and doesn't remember what they are and aren't supposed to say 100% of the time.



And I remember being a kid surrounded by Santa believers at school, wondering HOW they could possibly believe such odd things. And why they got to talk about their beliefs and I had to stay quiet. If I'd had a different personality I could imagine blurting it out because of sheer frustration. (And I still really don't get the love for characters, but the parks are still awesome to me)
 
You really can't equate someone's belief in a character dressed up as a princess in an amusement park with one's beliefs.

belief - an acceptance that a statement is true or that something exists; trust, faith, or confidence in someone or something

I'm pretty sure I can equate this to whatever I want.

I believe in magic and princesses and dragons.

I also believe in God.

These are my beliefs.
 
Let me apologize in advance, as this is be a bit long winded. I have posted this once before, but it really applies to this thread, so I'm posting again. Wall 'o text coming, ye be warned.

I have loved Disney World dearly since my wife first talked me into taking my two older kids (back then, they were our only kids). We went when DD was seven, and DS had just turned five. It was a great trip, despite the crowds and heat of spring break, and us not knowing what we were doing.

We went three years later in December, and loved it again. So much so, that we made a conscious choice to bring home a special souvenir. Yep, we had a new DS the following August.

This started us on our "second family", as we sometimes refer to it. Today, we have three boys aged six, four, and two... to go with our teenagers aged seventeen and fifteen.

When baby #4 was four months old, we went for our third Disney trip. We've loved WDW for some time, but on that trip, the third child went from Mommy's boy to Daddy's Disney buddy. Aged two at the time, he rode a lot of rides with me while mom held the baby. But the real treat was seeing true magic and wonder in his eyes as he met the characters, saw the castle for the first time, etc.

We went back when he was four, child #4 was two, and child #5 was four months old. He was more into rides then, but again, the two year old was filled with magic.

I see parents deciding to wait until their kids are tall enough to ride everything before they go to WDW. I understand the logic, having had a short five year old that couldn't do it all (and wanted to do so). But wow, the magic that you miss.

Recently, we booked for this November. DD17 will not be going, to my dismay... she just hasn't cared for Disney since becoming a teen, and we've decided to not force her to go. Fortunately, DS15 still loves it. Obviously, the little boys are looking forward to it like crazy.

At travel time, we'll be mom and dad, DS15, DS6, DS4, DS2. Mom will not be able to ride a ton this time, as baby #6 is on the way.

DS6 and I were recently talking about the upcoming trip. The little boys are very into Star Wars right now; I was mentioning how I'd love to go in June one year for SWW, even with the heat and crowds. It was then that my Disney buddy asked a question that made me wistful.

"Who do you think dresses up as Darth Vader?" he asked.

I knew this day would come, of course. DS is very bright. And naturally, you can't expect a child to believe that the characters are "really real" forever. I had hoped it might last a bit longer, as he is our first to be home schooled; there is a little more innocence in him than, say, in his baseball teammates. Still, I had seen less magic during our trip when he was age four compared to his trip at age two; it stands to reason that most of it would be gone by the worldly age of six (when we travel this year).

Saddened, I prepared to have a talk about how it's fun to pretend, that so much of the joy of WDW comes from imagination, etc.

"What do you mean?" I asked, deciding to play coy for a bit longer. "Isn't that the real Darth Vader?"

"You're silly," he told me. "The real Darth Vader wouldn't just stand around to meet people."

Good point, kid. Still unsure of what to say, I flipped it on him. "Maybe," I allowed. "Who do you think it is?" I asked.

He thought about it for a minute. "Mickey Mouse," he spoke with some assurance.

I asked him what he meant, so he explained. "I bet Mickey Mouse dresses up as Darth Vader. At least sometimes. " As if it was a clearly obvious answer.

I allowed that maybe he was right, and we went on to talk about other things. Apparently there is still some magic left... at least for a little while longer.
 
My husband dress as Darth Vader for many charity events and it always amazes me to see the kids come up so wide eyed & happy to see him, but what amazes me even more is the adults that are giddy as a child to meet him. So many are amazed that he breaths they way Darth Vader breathes. It just makes me so happy to see this & brings the magic back even though I know who is in that suit:-)
 
My nephew told my daughter when she was 6 that they are just people in costumes. He was being spiteful to her when he said it, he was 7. The next year we went to Disney she told me that the characters were people in costumes, but she was OK with it and wanted her picture taken with them anyway....but that the Princess, Tinkerbell and anybody who was a "face" person was the real deal.
 
belief - an acceptance that a statement is true or that something exists; trust, faith, or confidence in someone or something

I'm pretty sure I can equate this to whatever I want.

I believe in magic and princesses and dragons.

I also believe in God.

These are my beliefs.

Well I meant someone's belief system, sorry if that was unclear.
You can believe in whatever you want, and if its magic or dragons or characters dressed up that is fine and there is nothing wrong with that. However your comment about different beliefs aren't always right doesn't apply to those things in my world, sorry. Dragons don't exist, magic doesn't exist, those princesses ARE just women in costumes, therefore your belief can actually be considered wrong. I'll teach my children that everyone has their own belief system and a right to believe in what they want, that isn't the same as teaching my kids to not speak the truth about fictional dressed up characters because that belief "is not wrong". I'm teaching them its not wrong to believe in those things, but its not wrong to discuss the truth about those things either. YMMV.
 
luvmy3 said:
Well I meant someone's belief system, sorry if that was unclear.
You can believe in whatever you want, and if its magic or dragons or characters dressed up that is fine and there is nothing wrong with that. However your comment about different beliefs aren't always right doesn't apply to those things in my world, sorry. Dragons don't exist, magic doesn't exist, those princesses ARE just women in costumes, therefore your belief can be actually considered wrong.

Whoa whoa whoa...this thread is crushing all kinds of dreams here. Next you'll be telling me reality shows are scripted. Stop the madness!!
 
Whoa whoa whoa...this thread is crushing all kinds of dreams here. Next you'll be telling me reality shows are scripted. Stop the madness!!

No, no, no, don't you worry. Those are definitely real!

:rotfl:
 
My 8 year old neighbor just told my 5 year old DD that the princesses we met in Disney were not real. They were just the people that worked there dressed up in costumes. What would you do??? I do not want to lie to her when flat out asked if they are real...but I am not ready to give up the magic yet this soon. We just got back from such a magical trip! :sad2: :confused3


On our trip when my DD was 5, she kept asking if they were real, and I didn't want to lie and didn't want to spoil the magic. I came up with a easy and quick solution...I told her....

"As real as you can get!"

She took that to mean they WERE real! AND...I didn't lie. They are the closest to real as you can get.
 
I look at it the same way I would with Santa, tooth fairy or the E Bunny. When I was younger and the kids in my neighborhood made fun of me for believing in these things my parents sat me down and said. They are real if you believe they are, just because others dont believe does not mean you cant. When I asked my mom if she believed she responded with " I sure do! Thats why I get presents from him!".

Even to this day my sister and I are grown up but we still get presents from Santa. I tell my kids the same thing. I believe and he still comes. I would let her make the decission on if she thinks they are real or not. She could know that yes they are people in costume, but she could still believe they are the real deal.

My kids know that it is just employees (my sisters friend is a character) but they still think its the real thing! However, I will admit they still believe in Santa, TF and EB. We even have an elf on the shelf and they believe that creepy little thing is real! and I am 10000% ok with that! And when they choose not to believe anymore.. I will be ok with that too.
 
On our trip when my DD was 5, she kept asking if they were real, and I didn't want to lie and didn't want to spoil the magic. I came up with a easy and quick solution...I told her....

"As real as you can get!"

She took that to mean they WERE real! AND...I didn't lie. They are the closest to real as you can get.

I love it! lol
 





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE



New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom