I paid OOP when we went in september. at the time i figured I was going for broke and would not be able to soon afford to take my little guy back. Wish I could find my paperwork from that, I am pretty sure I kept it, but I am also pretty sure I spent in the neighborhood of $800-900 on food. We did room service breakfast a few times (which is not as bad a value as you think, it was around $30 for the two of us with service charge and tip all told - a buffet would have been more than that and we'd have to take the time rather than eat while getting dressed!) and room service dinner once, a special meal at california grill where I paid no mind whatsoever to what would have been on plan vs. off... I also had a few glow cube grownup beverages (maybe 4 the entire time).
So DDP for our trip is $579. I am also planning on paying for candlelight processional OOP. I am pretty sure I am still going to come out ahead as I booked more character buffets this time (I don't think I did a sit down a day last time either, we skipped a few days maybe. I don't remember lol... I know I did add CP on the fly so I'm guessing that means I hadn't booked a sit down a day). I tended to gravitate toward more expensive QS choices - salmon at columbia harbor house rather than hot dog type stuff. But I will say that when I was planning, there was NO WAY I would pay over $90 OOP for both of us to eat at the hollywood and vine thing, but now I feel free to. I would have limited the character buffets like last time, done lunch or breakfast only (we have a few lunches but also a few dinners), chose kona over ohana and ordered a couple of appetizers instead of entree, I had a burger at sci fi instead of the steak. Now I am free to do what I want really without worry about the cost because... I have expensive taste lol. With tips and a few OOP things (coral reef lunch CP and we may end up with a room service breakfast one day) I may end up close to where I was before but I will be free to make choices I was hesitant to make before.