Most comfortable all-star?

[pugbug]

I'm staying at Bay Lake Tower for the majority of my trip, but I decided to fly in one night early and stay at an All-star before transferring to Bay Lake. Is there any real advantage to any all-star over another for just one night? Have any of them been more recently renovated? Is one more comfortable or quiet than another? We don't have kids and because our flight is late, I'd like to sleep in a little, so if one of the all-stars is more quiet, that would be great!

Also, is Pop Century worth the tiny bit extra than an All-Star for just one night? It's more expensive by like $20 a room (three adults, so I'm booking two rooms), but if it's worth it, it's no big deal.

Thanks!

 

[dansdad]

I'm staying at Bay Lake Tower for the majority of my trip, but I decided to fly in one night early and stay at an All-star before transferring to Bay Lake. Is there any real advantage to any all-star over another for just one night?

In our opinion, no. Other than theme, they are pretty much identical.

Have any of them been more recently renovated?

No.

Is one more comfortable or quiet than another?

In our opinion, no.

Also, is Pop Century worth the tiny bit extra than an All-Star for just one night?

Again, just our opinion but no.

 

[peg2001]

The All Stars will be equally comfortable. For quiet, a regular (not preferred) room at All Star Music is a good bet.

My opinion only, but no, Pop is not worth an extra $20 per room per night.

 

[leebee]

We've stayed at POP and ASMusic. I just choose whichever is cheaper, but we prefer ASMu because it's a smaller resort. Fewer kids running around, less noise, less distance to walk. We stay in the Broadway section and have never had a problem with noise. Comfort-wise, they are all the same!

 

[wishicouldgomoreofte]

I like the Broadway section too, though have not stayed there in years. I stayed at Sports before and after race a couple times, and really liked the Touchdown section, but now that is preferred prices, and I won't pay for preferred, so am looking at Broadway section of Music again.
I sure hope Broadway is as nice as I remember it, even though I may only be one night. I loved walking by the Calypso Pool, and through the rose garden on my way back to Broadway at night.

 

[mouserrificmom]

They are all essentially the same with different themes, but the rooms are exactly the same. Music is a bit more compact than movies and sports, and I personally think the food court at Movies is better than the others, but that is about it. If it is just a place to rest your head for one night, it won't make much difference where you are.